Abstract:Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a public health concern, and there are multiple myths, debates, and unresolved questions about concussion and potential lingering symptoms or long-term effects. Mild TBI (mTBI), or concussion, occurs as a result of many causes, and most cases recover within days to weeks and are not typically associated with long-term effects. 1 The article by Ntikas et al 2 is timely and addresses an important topic, because a subgroup of those who experience mTBI continue to report lingering symptoms beyond the typical recovery window, yet this subgroup and their symptoms remain poorly understood. In their study, Ntikas and colleagues took a novel approach by using an international sample to examine clinical outcomes in individuals presenting to emergency departments in various countries following a sport-related TBI (SR-TBI) and compared them at 3- and 6-month follow-up with a group of adults with TBI who sustained their injury due to other causes. Along with analyzing the entire sample, the authors focused on subgroups most relevant to sport—that is, mTBI with and without intracranial findings on imaging. Clinical outcomes included ratings of functional ability, quality of life, posttraumatic stress, depression, anxiety, and postconcussion symptoms, with outcomes dichotomized to reflect impairment or no impairment. Using functional ratings from the Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended 3 (GOSE) at 3-month follow-up, more than one-half of the SR-TBI group reported incomplete functional recovery (42% for those with mTBI overall, and 33% for mTBI and negative imaging findings), with elevated rates of postconcussion symptoms and impaired health-related quality of life. At 6-month follow-up, despite improvement in psychological indices, nearly one-half of individuals with SR-TBI reported incomplete functional recovery based on GOSE ratings, with subgroups of mTBI reporting negligible changes from the initial 3-month follow-up. Interestingly, there were no significant differences in functional status ratings between groups with and without SR-TBI, although the SR-TBI group did show lower anxiety, depression and other symptom scores compared with the nonsports sample. Related research in adolescents comparing sport-related concussion (SRC) vs concussion due to motor vehicle accidents found that those in the latter group reported higher symptom burden and longer recovery times than those with SRC. 4 The present study builds upon the research literature in 2 substantive ways. First, by leveraging samples from 18 countries, Ntikas et al 2 were able to compare gross recovery outcomes between individuals with sport-related and non–sport-related brain injuries. Few studies have compared directly sport-related and non–sport-related TBI, and such a large and internationally diverse sample theoretically should enhance power to detect meaningful differences and generalize to broader populations. In addition, the authors tracked recovery outcomes over a longer interval than some similar investigations, which is important because recovery trajectories are not uniformly linear and may vary depending on a host of factors, including severity, cause, preexisting conditions, and timing of injury. That said, the finding of such high rates of incomplete recovery ratings among their SR-TBI cases was somewhat surprising, given that most studies of SRC tend to show better outcomes and less frequent lingering symptoms. 1 In reviewing these findings, it is important to keep in mind that TBIs are not created equal, and even within the mild classification, there is heterogeneity. The mild spectrum has been described as concussion, or uncomplicated mTBI, and complicated mTBI, with the latter being associated with evidence of structural intracranial abnormality on neuroimaging. First, it is critical to note that the majority of individuals who sustain mTBI do not show abnormalities on conventional neuroimaging, and imaging is usually not considered to be indicated in most cases of concussion. This is an important distinction because individuals with complicated mTBI usually have greater impairments in the acute period 5 and/or take longer to recover, with some being on par with more serious injuries. 6 To this end, the most recent diagnostic criteria for mTBI suggest adding a qualifier to indicate the presence of intracranial injury as another factor to be considered in the assessment of severity. 7 Consequently, it is challenging to make broad inferences to all mTBI (sport-related or non–sport-related) cases from studies using mTBI samples which include hospitalization and neuroimaging as inclusion criteria. In this study, 2 in addition to the fact that all subjects underwent hospitalization for their injury, 52% of the SR-TBI group had abnormal computed tomography findings, sugges -Abstract Truncated-

Mild traumatic brain injury among a cohort of rugby union players: predictors of time to injury.

Concussion increases within-player injury risk in male professional rugby union

Concussive Injuries in Rugby 7s: An American Experience and Current Review

Symptom presentation and evolution in the first 48 hours after injury are associated with return to play after concussion in elite Rugby Union

Lingering Symptoms Following Sports-Related Brain Injury

Sports-Related Concussion Assessment: A New Physiological, Biomechanical, and Cognitive Methodology Incorporating a Randomized Controlled Trial Study Protocol

Repetitive mild traumatic brain injury in mice triggers a slowly developing cascade of long-term and persistent behavioral deficits and pathological changes

Cumulative Sport-Related Injuries and Longer Term Impact in Retired Male Elite- and Amateur-Level Rugby Code Athletes and Non-contact Athletes: A Retrospective Study

The risk factors and predictors of injury among collegiate rugby players under the age of 20

Anxiety and Mood Disruption in Collegiate Athletes Acutely Following Mild Traumatic Brain Injury

The role of concussion history and biological sex on baseline concussion clinical profile symptoms in adolescent rugby players

Non-reporting of sport-related concussion symptoms: a cross-sectional study of community rugby league players in the UK

A Prospective Pilot Investigation of Brain Volume, White Matter Hyperintensities, and Hemorrhagic Lesions after Mild Traumatic Brain Injury

I won't let you down; why 20% of Men's and Women's Super League players underreported suspected concussions

Exploring concussion prevalence, knowledge and reporting behaviors in women playing rugby union in the United Kingdom

Epidemiology and Time-Loss Shoulder Injuries in Professional South African Rugby Players: A Prospective Study That Focuses on Real-Time Collision Data during a Tackle

MRI-T2 Relaxometry is Increased in Mild Traumatic Brain Injury: Indications of Acute Brain Abnormalities after Injury

Head and Neck Characteristics as Risk Factors For and Protective Factors Against Mild Traumatic Brain Injury in Military and Sporting Populations: A Systematic Review

Predictors and Time-Based Hospital Mortality in Patients with Isolated and Polytrauma Brain Injuries

Mechanisms of Injury Leading to Concussions in Collegiate Soccer Players: A CARE Consortium Study

Return to play after head injury in adolescent sports: evaluating football versus other sports