The role of concussion history and biological sex on baseline concussion clinical profile symptoms in adolescent rugby players

Connor McKee,Mark Matthews,Anthony P. Kontos,Alan Rankin,Chris Bleakley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11845-024-03677-7

2024-03-25

Irish Journal of Medical Science (1971 -)

Abstract:Abstract Background Accurate concussion monitoring requires access to preinjury baseline data. This is particularly important in adolescent athletes who have a high risk of concussion and are prone to prolonged recovery. As Rugby Union is governed by similar laws for men and women, it is also an ideal population to rigorously examine the impact of biological sex on concussion symptoms. Aims To evaluate self-reported concussion symptoms at baseline in adolescent rugby union players, and examine if subtype-specific symptoms are affected by concussion history and biological sex. Methods Adolescent rugby union players aged 16–18 years were recruited during the 2022–2023 playing season. Participants completed a series of questionnaires covering post-concussion symptoms, concussion clinical profiles, anxiety, depression and fear avoidance behaviours. Independent variables of interest in analysis were biological sex and concussion history. Results 149 participants (75% male) were included. 42% (63/149) reported at least one previous concussion (average time since concussion: 18.7 months, range 1–72). Adolescents with a concussion history reported significantly higher scores than those with no history, across two clinical profiles (ocular and sleep), concussion symptom severity, and depression, all based on medium effect sizes (SMD 0.3–0.5). Females had significantly higher scores across cognitive/fatigue, ocular and sleep clinical profiles, concussion symptoms, anxiety and depression, each with large effect sizes (SMD > 0.5). Conclusions Concussion history and sex are associated with higher baseline scores on specific concussion clinical profile, concussion symptom severity, and anxiety symptoms. These findings highlight the importance of considering baseline differences when interpreting post-injury clinical profile symptoms in adolescent rugby players. (Trial registration: ACTRN12622000931774).

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the clinical characteristic symptoms of concussion in adolescent rugby players prior to injury (baseline), particularly considering the influence of concussion history and biological gender (male vs. female). The study found that adolescent athletes with a history of concussion had more severe symptoms in terms of ocular and sleep clinical features, as well as more severe depressive symptoms, with these differences showing a moderate effect size. Female athletes scored higher in cognitive/fatigue, ocular and sleep clinical features, concussion symptoms, anxiety, and depression, with a large effect size.

The research method involved recruiting rugby players aged 16 to 18 and completing a series of questionnaires before the 2022-2023 season, including post-concussion symptoms, clinical feature screening, anxiety, depression, and avoidance behavior related to fear. The main independent variables analyzed were biological gender and concussion history.

The results showed that athletes with a history of concussion had higher baseline scores on certain specific clinical features, while female athletes also scored higher than males on multiple indicators. These findings emphasize the importance of considering baseline differences when interpreting clinical characteristic symptoms in adolescent rugby players after injury.

In summary, this paper aims to evaluate the impact of concussion history and gender on the severity of concussion symptoms, as well as anxiety and depression symptoms, among adolescent rugby players at baseline. The results suggest that these factors should be considered as important factors when evaluating concussions in adolescent athletes.