Comment on the Use of the Method of Images for Calculating Electromagnetic Responses of Interacting Spheres

JP Huang,KW Yu,GQ Gu,M Karttunen,L Dong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physreve.72.023401
IF: 2.707
2005-01-01
Physical Review E
Abstract:In this Comment, I argue that the method of images used by Huang, Yu, and Gu [Phys Rev. E 65, 021401 (2002)] and Huang, Karttunen, Yu, Dong, and Gu [Phys Rev. E., 69, 051402 (2004)] to calculate electromagnetic properties of interacting spheres at finite frequencies is inapplicable and does not provide a physically meaningful approximation.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?