Abstract:Intrinsic delays in sensory feedback can be detrimental for motor control. As a compensation strategy, the brain predicts the sensory consequences of movement via a forward model on the basis of a copy of the motor command. Using these predictions, the brain attenuates somatosensory reafference to facilitate the processing of exafferent information. Theoretically, this predictive attenuation is disrupted by (even minimal) temporal errors between the predicted and actual reafference; however, direct evidence of such disruption is lacking since previous neuroimaging studies contrasted nondelayed reafferent input with exafferent input. Here, we combined psychophysics with functional magnetic resonance imaging to test whether subtle perturbations in the timing of somatosensory reafference disrupt its predictive processing. Twenty-eight participants (14 women) generated touches on their left index finger by tapping a sensor with their right index finger. The touches on the left index finger were delivered close to the time of the two fingers’ contact or with a temporal perturbation ( i.e. , 153 ms delay). We found that such a brief temporal perturbation disrupted the attenuation of the somatosensory reafference at both the perceptual and neural levels, leading to greater somatosensory and cerebellar responses and weaker somatosensory connectivity with the cerebellum, proportional to the perceptual changes. We interpret these effects as the failure of the forward model to predictively attenuate the perturbed somatosensory reafference. Moreover, we observed increased connectivity of the supplementary motor area with the cerebellum during the perturbations, which could indicate the return of the temporal prediction error to the motor centers. Significance statement Our brain receives somatosensory feedback from our movements with a delay. To counteract these delays, motor control theories postulate that the brain predicts the timing of somatosensory consequences of our movements and attenuates sensations received at that time. Thus, a self-generated touch feels weaker than an identical external touch. However, how subtle temporal errors between the predicted and actual somatosensory feedback perturb this predictive attenuation remains unknown. We show that such errors make the otherwise attenuated touch feel stronger, elicit stronger somatosensory responses, weaken cerebellar connectivity with somatosensory areas, and increase this connectivity with motor areas. These findings show that motor and cerebellar areas are fundamental in forming temporal predictions about the sensory consequences of our movements.

Temporal Prediction Errors Modulate Cingulate–insular Coupling

Prediction-error signals in anterior cingulate cortex drive task-switching

Modulations of Insular Projections by Prior Belief Mediate the Precision of Prediction Error During Tactile Learning.

Temporal expectations modulate coupling between frontal and sensory brain areas

Prediction errors bidirectionally bias time perception

Posteromedial cortical networks encode visuomotor prediction errors.

Temporal Prediction through Integration of Probability Distributions of Event Timings at Multiple Levels

Effect of interhemispheric zero-phase entrainment of the intrinsic mu-rhythm on behavioral and neural markers of predictive coding

Brief temporal perturbations in somatosensory reafference disrupt perceptual and neural attenuation and increase supplementary motor area–cerebellar connectivity

Intracranial Recordings and Computational Modeling of Music Reveal the Time Course of Prediction Error Signaling in Frontal and Temporal Cortices

Temporal Prediction Changes Motor-Related EEG Phase Synchronization and Network Centrality in Alpha and Beta Band

Spatial prediction modulates the rhythm of attentional sampling

Dynamic Brain Responses Modulated by Precise Timing Prediction in an Opposing Process

Does temporal irregularity drive prediction failure in schizophrenia? temporal modelling of ERPs

Prediction Error During Retrospective Revaluation of Causal Associations in Humans: Fmri Evidence in Favor of an Associative Model of Learning

The interplay of contextual and immediate uncertainty: evidence for a common processing mechanism in prediction and cognitive control

Timing Prediction Changes the Signatures of Alpha-Band Functional and Effective Connectivity.

The Medial Prefrontal Cortex Shapes Dopamine Reward Prediction Errors under State Uncertainty

Cooperative thalamocortical circuit mechanism for sensory prediction errors

Uncertainty-modulated prediction errors in cortical microcircuits