Abstract:Building on the theoretical insights of Part I, this paper, as the second part of the tutorial, dives deeper into data-driven power flow linearization (DPFL), focusing on comprehensive numerical testing. The necessity of these simulations stems from the theoretical analysis's inherent limitations, particularly the challenge of identifying the differences in real-world performance among DPFL methods with overlapping theoretical capabilities and/or limitations. The absence of a comprehensive numerical comparison of DPFL approaches in the literature also motivates this paper, especially given the fact that over 95% of existing DPFL studies have not provided any open-source codes. To bridge the gap, this paper first reviews existing DPFL experiments, examining the adopted test scenarios, load fluctuation settings, data sources, considerations for data noise/outliers, and the comparison made so far. Subsequently, this paper evaluates a total of 44 methods, containing over 30 existing DPFL approaches, some innovative DPFL techniques, and several classic physics-driven power flow linearization methods for benchmarking. The evaluation spans various dimensions, including generalizability, applicability, accuracy, and computational efficiency, using various different test cases scaling from 9-bus to 1354-bus systems. The numerical analysis identifies and examines significant trends and consistent findings across all methods under various test cases. It also offers theoretical insights into phenomena like under-performance, failure, excessive computation times, etc. Overall, this paper identifies the differences in the performances of the wide range of DPFL methods, reveals gaps not evident from theoretical discussions, assists in method selection for real-world applications, and provides thorough discussions on open questions within DPFL research, indicating ten potential future directions.

Research on the Process of Power Flow Transferring and Its Identification Method

ON-LINE IDENTIFICATION OF POWER SYSTEM DYNAMIC EQUIVALENT Part Three Analysis of Several Important Issues

Evaluation of methods for measuring the insolvability of power flow

A Network Partition Method for Power System Reactive Power Control Based on Power Flow Tracing

Analysis of Fault Dynamic Process Impact on Flow Transferring Identification

A General Fast Power Flow Algorithm for Transmission and Distribution Networks

A Graph-Based Power Flow Method For Balanced Distribution Systems

An Identification Method of Single-phase Permanent Fault at Transmission Lines with Shunt Reactors

A Novel Method of Fault Diagnosis Based on Synchronized Phasor Measuring and Flow Fingerprint Identification Technology

General formulation of transfer function identification for power system based on WAMS

Identification of Critical Nodes in Power Grid Based on Improved PageRank Algorithm and Power Flow Transfer Entropy

Study of the Concept of Transmission Betweenness Considering the Effect of Reactive Power Flow and Its Application in Identification of Critical Lines in Power Grid

Comparative Research on Rotary Power Flow Controller, Unified Power Flow Controller and Sen Transformer

A Power Flow Transfer Entropy Based AC Fault Detection Method for the MTDC Wind Power Integration System.

Identification of the Transmission Sections for Power System Based on the Breaking Power Flow and Cut Set Filtering

A Dynamized Power Flow Method based on Differential Transformation

Power Flow Regulation Effect and Parameter Design Method of Phase-Shifting Transformer

Research on the Searching Method of Critical Vulnerable Lines for Cascading Failures Analysis

Fault Diagnosis Using Power Flow in Hybrid Measurements System

Data-driven Power Flow Linearization: Simulation

Research on Optimized Decision-Making of Load Transfer under Transformer Fault in Power Grid