Abstract:Trade-offs between economic development and carbon emission reductions, as well as their uncertainties, are great challenges for climate change negotiations. This article focuses on the equality of China's national carbon allowance allocations for provincial economic development while taking into account the uncertainties in provincial economic output and business-as-usual carbon emission. The allocation equality assessment under an uncertainty model was developed based on the Gini coefficient of accumulated carbon emission per unit of gross domestic product (GDP) and Monte Carlo simulations. It was used to compare the equity and related provincial carbon abatement burdens between the grandfathering allocations under an absolute cap and the output-based benchmarking allocations under a relative cap. The results showed that the volatilities of national carbon abatement and accumulated carbon emission per unit of GDP were more stable under the relative cap. The benchmarking mechanism resulted in a more equitable allowance allocations for provincial economic development and mitigated shocks in provincial output volatility to the equity of national overall allowance allocations. This mechanism was expected to produce a more evenly distributed carbon abatement burden-sharing across provinces, and to reduce the uncertainties of provincial carbon abatements. The benchmarking mechanism is thus proposed as an appropriate choice for China's current equitable provincial carbon allowance allocations. Policy relevance The trade-off between economic development and carbon emission reduction is the most controversial issue in climate change negotiations. The uncertainties in economic outputs and carbon emission also pose great challenges. With the obvious imbalance and uncertainty in provincial developments, the equitable allocation of carbon allowances among provinces is the key for China to develop a national carbon emission trading scheme. The comparison of allocation mechanisms under uncertainty provides more practical suggestions for policy making in China. Benchmarking results in more equitable allowance allocation and yields more even and stable abatement burden-sharing across provinces. It narrows the gaps in economic development emissions rights between developed and less developed provinces, and mitigates the shocks of provincial outputs and business-as-usual emissions to the overall allocation equity and provincial carbon abatement burdens. This benchmarking is suggested as a reasonable choice for China's provincial carbon allowance allocation method.

Output-based Allowance Allocations under China's Carbon Intensity Target

Allowance allocation matters in China's carbon emissions trading system

Incorporating Consumption-Based Emissions Accounting into Climate Policy in China: Provincial Target Setting and ETS Baseline Allocations

The Influence of Different Allowance Allocation Methods on China's Economic and Sectoral Development

Study on CO<sub>2</sub> Intensity Reduction Allocation of Construction Industry in East China

On the Construction of Initial Allowances Allocation Mechanism in Transitional Period: Incentive Analysis and Optimal Design

Innovative Carbon Allowance Allocation Policy For The Shenzhen Emission Trading Scheme In China

The environmental and economic effects of the carbon emissions trading scheme in China: The role of alternative allowance allocation

Allocation of Carbon Emissions among Industries/sectors: an Emissions Intensity Reduction Constrained Approach

Regional allocation of carbon dioxide abatement in China

[Analysis and Optimization Suggestions on Allowance Allocation Methods of the Power Industry in the Carbon Market]

Impacts of Alternative Allowance Allocation Methods under A Cap-And-Trade Program in Power Sector

Revealing the political decision toward Chinese carbon abatement: Based on equity and efficiency criteria

Scenario analysis of ETS revenue allocation mechanism of China: based on a dynamic CGE model

Addressing Regional Disparities in Allowance Allocation in China’s National Emissions Trading Scheme

Research of the Initial Allocation Method of Carbon Allowance

Interprovincial Allocation of China's National Carbon Emission Allowance: an Uncertainty Analysis Based on Monte-Carlo Simulations

A General Equilibrium Analysis on the Impacts of Regional and Sectoral Emission Allowance Allocation at Carbon Trading Market

Exploration of the Initial Allocation Scheme of Carbon Emission Rights in China: International Experience and Policy Implications

Design and impact assessment of policies to overcome oversupply in China's national carbon market

Pricing Carbon Allowance Based on Marginal Abatement Cost