A study of incentive mechanism to weaken bullwhip effect of supply chains

Weimin Ma,Wenwen Yue

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ICSESS.2011.5982281

2011-01-01

Abstract:Bullwhip effect increases instability of supply inventory management and leads to a high fluctuation in the demand of products. This article examines how information sharing reduces the bullwhip effect and then introduces the utility theory to design an incentive mechanism. © 2011 IEEE.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Bullwhip Effect and Supply Chain Costs with Low- and High-Quality Information on Inventory Shrinkage

Hongyan Dai,Jianbin Li,Nina Yan,Weihua Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2015.11.004

IF: 6.4

2016-01-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:Inventory inaccuracy is the mismatch between the recorded inventory and the physical inventory, which is severe and widespread in industry. A few studies have investigated the bullwhip effect with the existence of inventory inaccuracy. The development of information technologies has provided companies with access to accurate inventory information in real time. This will surely affect the bullwhip effect and supply chain costs. The aim of this paper is to build an analytical model to systematically investigate these effects. We consider a retailer-manufacturer supply chain in which the retailer faces inventory shrinkage, which is the main cause of inventory inaccuracy. Both the situations with accurate real-time inventory information, i.e., high-quality information, and the situation with statistical inventory information, i.e., low-quality information are studied. We examine the relationships between the bullwhip effect, information distortion and supply chain costs with different levels of information quality. The results of our analysis enrich the existing literature on the bullwhip effect. First, we show that the bullwhip effect is magnified along the chain when higher-quality information on inventory shrinkage- specifically real-time rather than statistical data- is obtained. Second, we show that the magnification of the bullwhip effect does not necessarily result in higher costs. Third, we demonstrate that higher-quality information increases the benefits of information sharing. Our paper provides new insights into the causes, extent and economic dynamics of order variability in the presence of inventory inaccuracy, and may thus suggest ways of more effectively managing the bullwhip effect and inventory. (C) 2015 Elsevier B.V. and Association of European Operational Research Societies (EURO) within the International Federation of Operational Research Societies (IFORS). All rights reserved.
The Cause and Countermeasure of the Bullwhip Effect Explained in the Economics

Tao Zhang,Jing Tian,Yue-Jie Zhang,Xian Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/icmlc.2006.258848

2006-01-01

Abstract:The bullwhip effect that exists universally in the supply chain affects the efficiency of the total operation of the supply chain. This paper analyzes the bullwhip effect phenomenon by the principal-agent theory, and considers it stems from the structure of the supply chain. In other word, any pair in a supply chain with business relation all has a bidirectional principal and agent partnership. This kind of partnership is caused by incomplete information and imperfect contract, including the lacking of effective prompting and supervising mechanism that result the repeated secondary choices of goals and aim between the principal and the agent. This paper builds a two-phase mathematic supply chain model in the case of asymmetric information and studies the information sharing problem on the basis of principal-agent theory. The results show that the producer can spirit up the retailer by price discount, market reassigning, and allowance, as return for the sharing of information
The Impacts of Inventory Inaccuracy on the Bullwhip Effect in a Multi-stage Supply Chain

DAI Hong-yan,ZHOU Wei-hua,CHEN Zhi-kang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-6062.2013.02.027

2013-01-01

Abstract:The bullwhip effect-the amplification of order variability from the downstream to the upstream stages in a multi-stage supply chain incurs significant consequence in supply chain management.Most of current works addressing the bullwhip effect focus on two-stage supply chains and assume the information distortion will be amplified in the upstream stages.However,whether the amplification effect will exist in the upstream and how it transfers deserve more investigation.Moreover,most bullwhip literature regard the actual inventory in the warehouse the same as the inventory record in the IT system.Nevertheless recent studies have reported that inventory inaccuracy is widespread and severe in industry.Therefore,it is the intent of this paper to extend the study of the bullwhip effect to multi-stages with consideration of inventory inaccuracy. This paper considers a decentralized K-stage serial supply chain with the external demand following the auto-correlated AR(1) process.We assume each stage suffers from inventory inaccuracy due to internal/external theft,unsalables,etc,which is normally distributed.It is further assumed that the supply chain follows an order-up-to policy and all the information is not shared among different parties.Based on this model setting,we build analytical inventory models to obtain the optimal order decisions in two scenarios:(1) inventory inaccuracy exists in the supply chain;(2) inventory inaccuracy is eliminated through advanced technology(such as RFID).Based on the order decisions,the bullwhip effect can be quantified in the form of order variance and the impacts of inventory inaccuracy on the bullwhip effect can then be analyzed. Our analytical and numerical results show several managerial insights.First of all,both the correlation effect of the external demand and the inventory inaccuracy in the supply chain can cause the bullwhip effect.The impacts of the two factors on the bullwhip effect is positively related,therefore the inventory inaccuracy further deteriorates the bullwhip effect.Moreover,the information distortion due to inventory inaccuracy only depends on the variance of the inventory errors,rather than the mean of the errors.It implies that if the amount of the inventory error is huge but its fluctuation is limited,the information distortion will not be substantial.Second,the variability of the external demand and inventory inaccuracy in each stage will be transferred through the order making process up the stream and will be amplified by compounding with the correlation factor of the external demand respectively.Furthermore,the information distortions due to inventory errors of all the downstream stages are accumulated in the upstream stages,resulting in exponential amplification of order variability in the upstream stages,which is more salient when inventory inaccuracy exists. Moreover,we investigate the counter-approach for the bullwhip effect with a focus on the impacts of information sharing.We assume each stage knows not only the external demand,but also the inventory errors in all its downstream stages.Therefore,the decision makers can take advantage of those shared information when forecasting the future demand in order to achieve a better decision.Based on our analytical models and numerical study,it is shown that information sharing will attenuate the bullwhip effect due to inventory errors and reduce the propagation magnitude of the information distortion.The amplification effect reduces from exponential to linear.Consequently,information sharing contributes more when inventory errors present. To this end,understanding how the external and internal information variability affects the bullwhip effect plays a key role for practitioners to make better decisions for supply chain management.
The bullwhip effect in the supply chain and the corresponding solution

Miao Lixin,Guo Xiongbo,Miao Zhiwei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ITSC.2003.1252647

2003-01-01

Abstract:The idea of supply chain management (SCM) is a newly developed theory of management nowadays. But when the demand information is passed on along the supply chain we can see a phenomenon that the fluctuation of the demand information becomes larger and larger, which is called "bullwhip effect". "Bullwhip effect" may have much negative impact. A few measures are introduced to weaken the impact in this paper. We also explain a strategic alliance between the retailer and the supplier and the main forms of the alliance. Furthermore, a compare between the centralized control strategy of the multistage system and the traditional strategy is made to show the advantages of the former.
Coping with the Bullwhip Effect Using Inventory or Cash: an Environment-Behavior-Performance Paradigm

Lu Baile,Gong Qihui,Huo Baofeng,Zhou Weihua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11518-021-5485-5

2021-01-01

Abstract:The bullwhip effect is widely found in business and exerts adverse effects on business activities. To investigate the influence of the bullwhip effect on firms’ performance and their responses, this study proposed an environment-behavior-performance analysis framework and offered a new perspective for studying the bullwhip effect. Using data collected from 1,734 listed manufacturers in China from 2002 to 2017, we adopted regression models to test the proposed model and conducted a series of robustness tests. We find that the bullwhip effect is positively related to operating risk, inventory, and cash holdings, and the moderate levels of inventory and cash are negatively associated with operating risk. Specifically, inventory and cash play different roles and work together to alleviate operating risk induced by the bullwhip effect. However, excess resource holdings are positively associated with operating risk. Therefore, firms with different levels of resources should hold suitable levels of inventory, cash, or both as contingent responses to the bullwhip effect.
Can Institutional Investor-Manager Interactions Mitigate the Bullwhip Effect? Evidence from China

Yan Yu,Pingping Shao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1540496x.2024.2362237

2024-06-14

Emerging Markets Finance and Trade

Abstract:In this paper, we examine how institutional investor-manager interactions affect the bullwhip effect in corporate supply chains from the perspectives of information transmission and managerial learning. We find that increased institutional investor-manager interactions lead to a reduction in the bullwhip effect. These mitigation effects are realized through three mechanisms: improving the public information environment within the supply chain, disseminating private information, and directing managerial attention to supply chain issues. Additionally, we confirm the mediating role of information environment improvements in institutional investor-manager interactions in mitigating the bullwhip effect. Further analyses show that this mitigating effect are more pronounced in firms with a higher managerial willingness of learning, non-state-owned ownership, suboptimal inventory management quality, or lower supplier concentration.

economics,international relations,business
Exploration of the Bullwhip Effect based on the Evolutionary Least-mean-square Algorithm

Ling-Fang Tseng,L. Tseng,Heng-Chou Chen

2011-12-01

Abstract:There exists a negative influence in the area of supply chain management, called the bullwhip effect, as Lee et al. described [13], a small variance in the customers’ demands may cause remarkable variance in the stocking volumes of suppliers due the distorted demand information between the members of a supply chain. Recently, there is a growing literature on the bullwhip effect and its impact on supply chain performance. The bullwhip effect can be regarded as a magnification of order oscillations while one moves up the supply chain. This magnification is usually measured in terms of a change in the variance of orders placed at each supply chain level. The demand distortion propagates upstream with amplification occurring at each echelon. Lee et al. identified four major causes of the Bullwhip Effect: (1) demand forecast updating, (2) order batching, (3) price fluctuation, and (4) shortage gaming.

Engineering,Economics,Computer Science,Business
Systems Thinking Solving Bullwhip Effect in Supply Chain: From the Perspective of System Dynamics

Xu Li,Lingling Li,Qian Hu,Ying Dai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ICMSS.2009.5305026

2009-01-01

Abstract:Based on the principles of System Dynamics, this paper discusses the causes of the bullwhip effect and possible approaches to controlling it, from the perspective of the dynamic mechanism of the supply chain. This paper takes as example the beer game, each outcome of which show a surprisingly similar bullwhip effect, regardless of who plays the game and when. The only explanation of this is the unstable structure of the beer game system that leads to the bullwhip effect. This paper suggests that this unstable structure is caused by controllable delays - ordering cycle - being smaller than uncontrollable delays - lead time within the whole chain. Looked into are the two most straight forward solutions, increasing ordering cycle and making full use of en-route inventory information, and why the former is difficult to implement.
Inhibitory influence of supply chain digital transformation on bullwhip effect feedback difference

Jing Gao,Yang Gao,Tao Guan,Sisi Liu,Tao Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/bpmj-01-2023-0029

2023-10-19

Business Process Management Journal

Abstract:Purpose This paper breaks through the limitations of the research on bullwhip effect in the traditional supply chain, extends the research perspective to digital supply chain and discusses the weakening effect of digital supply chain on bullwhip effect by comparing the overall performance of the two. Design/methodology/approach This paper starts with the weakening mechanism of supply chain digitization on bullwhip effect, builds bullwhip effect models of traditional supply chain and digital supply chain, respectively, simulates the influence of supply chain digitization transformation on bullwhip effect by using Matlab software and analyzes the causes of bullwhip effect in supply chain led by T company and the digitization process. Findings Firstly, digitization can reduce bullwhip effect in multi-level supply chain by reducing information feedback deviation. Second, digital transformation is conducive to improving the overall performance of the supply chain. Third, government incentives can promote the digital transformation of supply chain and inhibit bullwhip effect. Research limitations/implications Although the study considers the heterogeneous subject -- the government's incentive effect on digital transformation and information sharing – it does not include the influence of the end node in the supply chain, that is the consumer. In addition, this paper only analyzes and discusses the bullwhip effect on the amplification of demand, without considering the situation that the market contraction will lead to the reduction of demand. Practical implications This paper considers the distortion degree and delay degree of information feedback, carries out quantitative analysis of bullwhip effect, builds the bullwhip effect model of traditional supply chain and digital supply chain, uses Matlab software to analyze the difference of the influence of supply chain digital transformation on bullwhip effect suppression and puts forward the corresponding control strategy. Social implications The research shows that digital transformation can reduce the bullwhip effect in multi-layer supply chain by reducing the information feedback deviation, which is conducive to improving the overall supply chain performance, and government support can accelerate the digital transformation of supply chain to a certain extent. Originality/value First, break through the limitations of traditional supply chain research, expand the research perspective to digital supply chain and discuss the weakening effect of digital supply chain on bullwhip effect by comparing the overall performance of the two. Second, quantify the bullwhip effect through information feedback bias and provide an analysis method for the weakening of the bullwhip effect. Third, the driving role of the government in the digital transformation of the supply chain is considered in the study, so that the model is more close to the actual situation of enterprise operation.

management,business
Bullwhip Effect and Assess of the Information Sharing under ARIMA(0, 1,1)Demand

张钦,达庆利,沈厚才

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1003-207x.2001.06.001

2001-01-01

Abstract:The paper considers a two echelon supply chain which contains a single supplier and one retailer.It studies bullwhip effect and values of the information sharing between the supplier and the retailer under ARIMA(0,1,1)demand,and compares the differences before and after information sharing.The results show that information sharing can bring the benefits such as mitigating bullwhip effect,decreasing on hand inventories and reducing the cost for the supplier.
Optimization of Supply Chain Management in Inventory & Manufactory Based on MPC Strategy

陈文博,杨春节,曹柬,何川

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-3133.2009.05.001

2009-01-01

Abstract:By reviewing bullwhip effect and demand oscillation existing in the Supply Chain Management(SCM),the coordinate issue between inventory cost and Customer Demand Satisfactory(CDS) is discussed.Then,by introducing the Model Predictive Control(MPC) strategy,and the translation of some concepts in process industrial control into the SCM fields,the optimization of supply chain network is successfully realized.Further more,a one-product,three-echelon demand network is modeled and simulated later to analyze its performance in the presence of significant uncertainty,forecast error,and constraints of inventory levels.The result successfully mitigates the bullwhip effect in the supply chain while reducing safety stocks to profitable levels and improving customer demand satisfaction.
How to Control the Bullwhip Effect Based on Systematic Structure Improment

LI Xu,CHEN Yu-sheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-152x.2006.10.020

2006-01-01

Abstract:On the basis on analyzing(s,S) inventory model,the paper analyzes the mechanism of bullwhip effect generation under the(R,S) inventory strategy and puts forward the effective ways to reduce bullwhip effect by improving inventory parameters.
The Quantified Research for the Value of Supply Chain Information Sharing

Chang-bin CHEN,Jun WU,Li WAN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-6332.2007.04.015

2008-01-01

Abstract:In modern business,it is very important for a company to increase its competative ability by building an efficient and competitive supply chain.Information sharing is the base of supply chain management.This article compares the related parameters of the supply chain's performance on the assumption that information is shared as well as is not shared,proving that the "bullwhip effect" is much weaker in the case of information sharing than that of non-sharing.Thus,information sharing is an effective way to control "Bullwhip Effect" and improve the efficiency of a supply chain.
Measuring and implementing the bullwhip effect under a generalized demand process

Marlene Silva Marchena

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1009.3977

2010-09-21

Applications

Abstract:The measure of the bullwhip effect, a phenomenon in which demand variability increases as one moves up the supply chain, is a major issue in Supply Chain Management. Although it is simply defined (it is the ratio of the unconditional variance of the order process to that of the demand process), explicit formulas are difficult to obtain. In this paper we investigate the theoretical and practical issues of Zhang [Manufacturing and Services Operations Management 6-2 (2004b) 195] with the purpose of quantifying the bullwhip effect. Considering a two-stage supply chain, the bullwhip effect is measured for an ARMA(p,q) demand process admitting an infinite moving average representation. As particular cases of this time series model, the AR(p), MA(q), ARMA(1,1), AR(1) and AR(2) are discussed. For some of them, explicit formulas are obtained. We show that for certain types of demand processes, the use of the optimal forecasting procedure that minimizes the mean squared forecasting error leads to significant reduction in the safety stock level. This highlights the potential economic benefits resulting from the use of this time series analysis. Finally, an R function called SCperf is programmed to calculate the bullwhip effect and other supply chain performance variables. It leads to a simple but powerful tool which could benefit both managers and researchers.
Bullwhip Effect in Multi-Product Supply Chain and Its Weakened Method

章魏,华中生

2010-01-01

Abstract:This paper deals with the bullwhip effect in a two-echelon multiple products supply chain with correlated market demands.The downstream retailer procures products from an un-capacitated upstream supplier to meet the correlated market demands of multiple products.When the market demands are stationary,we prove the existence of the bullwhip effect and show an analytical formula for the bullwhip effect,if the retailer uses a simple moving average to estimate the market demands.Furthermore,this paper proposes a new method that based on demand forecasting technique to eliminate the bullwhip effect,which is proved to be effective under some circumstances.
Analysis of the bullwhip effect in multi-product, multi-stage supply chain systems–a simulation approach

P. Wangphanich,S. Kara,B. Kayis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00207540902950852

IF: 9.018

2009-07-15

International Journal of Production Research

Abstract:This research aims to develop a simulation approach based on system dynamics modelling (SDM) and adaptive network based fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) for quantifying and reducing the bullwhip effect in a multi-product, multi-stage supply chain. The proposed model is comprised of three groups of variables influencing the bullwhip effect, namely the structure of a supply chain network, supply chain contributions (ordering process in regular situation or when a supplier has a promotion or shortage gaming) and supply chain performances (the number of defects and ordering lead time). As a result, a two layer simulation model is developed with three generic models. The flexibility of this proposed approach is its ability to model various types of ordering policies which are basic inventory policies, material requirement planning (MRP) system and just in time (JIT) approach. The supply chain of a beverage company was selected to validate and demonstrate the flexibility of the proposed model. The findings of the proposed simulation model are consistent with the results obtained from the case study. The error magnitude of the bullwhip effect level varied between 0 and 9% resulting in bullwhip effect reductions of up to 92%. Accordingly, the bullwhip effect levels are significantly decreased by using the proposed simulation model.

engineering, manufacturing, industrial,operations research & management science
The Impact of Bullwhip Effect on the Supply Chain Performance With the Mediating Effect of Information Sharing Among an Enterprise and Suppliers

Asjad bin Aqdas,Muhammad Shakeel,Saqib Munir,Khawaja Zeeshan Waheed

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47067/ramss.v6i2.312

2023-05-14

Review of Applied Management and Social Sciences

Abstract:This research aims to observe the impact of bullwhip effect on supply chain performance, the research is focused on how the bullwhip effect distorts the information sharing and to what extent that distortion effects the supply chain performance of a firm. This research also explains that the quality and quantity of information sharing deeply effects the supply chain performance. It tries to establish the fact that if the information is accurate and is shared timely, this can lead to increased performance, it also emphasizes on the importance of the supply chain integration and partner’s relationship in mitigating the bullwhip effect. This research study will serve as an important contribution to the filed of supply chain management, as such type of research has not been conducted earlier by keeping the Pakistani firms as the unit of analysis. The study reveals that through proper, timely and accurate exchange of information between an enterprise and its supplier the firm can lessen uncertainty, order fulfillment rate is improved, costs is reduced and can ultimately increase the performance. The study reveals that bullwhip effect strongly effects the information and its flow, but if the information is managed properly and its quality is increased then it results in strong partner relations which leads to supply chain integration. It has been found that the supply chain integration strongly effects the supply chain performance of a firm, better the supply chain integration the better would be the performance of the overall supply chain
Blessing or Curse? The Bullwhip Effect of an Omni-Channel Supply Chain with Channel Interactions

Shiyu Liu,Jun Wang,Jinxing Hao,Ou Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4276642

2022-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Due to the more complex structure of the omnichannel supply chain, the variation and influencing factors of its bullwhip effect have aroused increasing scholarly attention.In this paper, we study omni-channel supply chains that include both online and offline channels and the demand for goods in the supply chain depends on a uniform price, which follows a first-order autoregressive process. We employ the minimum Mean Square Error forecasting method and order-up-to inventory to describe the replenishment process. We propose the consumer channel preference coefficient and demand interactivity to represent the channel interactions in omni-channel supply chains. We set up multiple scenarios to discuss the effect of interactions on the bullwhip effect of omni-channel supply chains and obtain the conditions that can reduce the bullwhip effect. Furthermore, from the manager's perspective, we give what characteristics of markets and items are more suitable for omni-channel retailing.
Robust Control of Bullwhip Effect for Supply Chain System With Time-Varying Delay on Basis of Discrete-Time Approach

Dong Chen,Hui-Yao Feng,Yi Huang,Mi Tan,Qi-Yong Chen,Xiao-Shu Wei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/access.2023.3286314

IF: 3.9

2023-06-23

IEEE Access

Abstract:The existence of time delay causes the operation of supply chain system to aggravate the instability, induce bullwhip effect and reduce overall performance. In this paper, a discrete mathematical model with time-varying delay is constructed to investigate supply chain inventory network system with time-varying delay. Based on the proposed discrete mathematical model with time-varying delay, the inventory control strategy is desgined by using Lyapunov-Krosovskii functional analysis method. The feasibility analysis of supply chain inventory control strategy on bullwhip effect and the influence factors of time-varying delay are discussed by means of numerical simulation. The results prove that the inventory control strategy can restrain bullwhip effect effectively. It provides a novel approach to study supply chain inventory network system with time-varying delay from discrete perspective.

computer science, information systems,telecommunications,engineering, electrical & electronic
Incentive mechanism in service supply chains based on wholesale price contract

Haihong Yu,Nan Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ICEEE.2010.5660526

2010-01-01

Abstract:A Service supply chain occurs when a service provider outsources part of the service to a supplier. In service supply chains, as supplier offers service directly to final customers, it's hard for service provider to monitor or measure supplier's work. For this reason, the service provider has to offer an incentive mechanism to the supplier. This paper studies the optimal incentive mechanism in the service supply chain based on the wholesale price contract which is most generally used in practice. By setting up the incentive model, the research mainly discusses the prior condition of incentive, the optimal incentive mechanism and the condition to validate incentive, etc. The result shows: 1) Not all service supply chains need incentive mechanism; 2) Only with certain demand distribution can service supply chains provide effective incentive mechanism; 3) The optimal incentive mechanism has a bouncing discontinuous point. ©2010 IEEE.

A study of incentive mechanism to weaken bullwhip effect of supply chains

Bullwhip Effect and Supply Chain Costs with Low- and High-Quality Information on Inventory Shrinkage

The Cause and Countermeasure of the Bullwhip Effect Explained in the Economics

The Impacts of Inventory Inaccuracy on the Bullwhip Effect in a Multi-stage Supply Chain

The bullwhip effect in the supply chain and the corresponding solution

Coping with the Bullwhip Effect Using Inventory or Cash: an Environment-Behavior-Performance Paradigm

Can Institutional Investor-Manager Interactions Mitigate the Bullwhip Effect? Evidence from China

Exploration of the Bullwhip Effect based on the Evolutionary Least-mean-square Algorithm

Systems Thinking Solving Bullwhip Effect in Supply Chain: From the Perspective of System Dynamics

Inhibitory influence of supply chain digital transformation on bullwhip effect feedback difference

Bullwhip Effect and Assess of the Information Sharing under ARIMA(0, 1,1)Demand

Optimization of Supply Chain Management in Inventory & Manufactory Based on MPC Strategy

How to Control the Bullwhip Effect Based on Systematic Structure Improment

The Quantified Research for the Value of Supply Chain Information Sharing

Measuring and implementing the bullwhip effect under a generalized demand process

Bullwhip Effect in Multi-Product Supply Chain and Its Weakened Method

Analysis of the bullwhip effect in multi-product, multi-stage supply chain systems–a simulation approach

The Impact of Bullwhip Effect on the Supply Chain Performance With the Mediating Effect of Information Sharing Among an Enterprise and Suppliers

Blessing or Curse? The Bullwhip Effect of an Omni-Channel Supply Chain with Channel Interactions

Robust Control of Bullwhip Effect for Supply Chain System With Time-Varying Delay on Basis of Discrete-Time Approach

Incentive mechanism in service supply chains based on wholesale price contract