Abstract:Vulnerabilities publicly disclosed in the National Vulnerability Database (NVD) are assigned with CVE (Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures) IDs and associated with specific software versions. Many organizations, including IT companies and government, heavily rely on the disclosed vulnerabilities in NVD to mitigate their security risks. Once a software is claimed as vulnerable by NVD, these organizations would examine the presence of the vulnerable versions of the software and assess the impact on themselves. However, the version information about vulnerable software in NVD is not always reliable. Nguyen et al. find that the version information of many CVE vulnerabilities is spurious and propose an approach based on the original SZZ algorithm (i.e., an approach to identify bug-introducing commits) to assess the software versions affected by CVE vulnerabilities. However, SZZ algorithms are designed for common bugs, while vulnerabilities and bugs are different. Many bugs are introduced by a recent bug-fixing commit, but vulnerabilities are usually introduced in their initial versions. Thus, the current SZZ algorithms often fail to identify the inducing commits for vulnerabilities. Therefore, in this study, we propose an approach based on an improved SZZ algorithm to refine software versions affected by CVE vulnerabilities. Our proposed SZZ algorithm leverages the line mapping algorithms to identify the earliest commit that modified the vulnerable lines, and then considers these commits to be the vulnerability-inducing commits, as opposed to the previous SZZ algorithms that assume the commits that last modified the buggy lines as the inducing commits. To evaluate our proposed approach, we manually annotate the true inducing commits and verify the vulnerable versions for 172 CVE vulnerabilities with fixing commits from two publicly available datasets with five C/C++ and 41 Java projects, respectively. We find that 99 out of 172 vulnerabilities whose version information is spurious. The experiment results show that our proposed approach can identify more vulnerabilities with the true inducing commits and correct vulnerable versions than the previous SZZ algorithms. Our approach outperforms the previous SZZ algorithms in terms of F1-score for identifying vulnerability-inducing commits on both C/C++ and Java projects (0.736 and 0.630, respectively). For refining vulnerable versions, our approach also achieves the best performance on the two datasets in terms of F1-score (0.928 and 0.952).

SVR-Miner: Mining Security Validation Rules and Detecting Violations in Large Software

Source Code Preparing Data Transaction Database Mining Inferring Rules Detecting Violations Function Entropy Bugs Negative Rules Frequent and Infrequent Itemsets

V-SZZ: Automatic Identification of Version Ranges Affected by CVE Vulnerabilities

NAR-miner: Discovering Negative Association Rules from Code for Bug Detection

A Mining Approach to Obtain the Software Vulnerability Characteristics

DeepVuler: A Vulnerability Intelligence Mining System for Open-Source Communities

AntMiner: Mining More Bugs by Reducing Noise Interference

Finding A Needle in a Haystack: Automated Mining of Silent Vulnerability Fixes

Mining Secure Behavior of Hardware Designs

Detecting Bugs by Discovering Expectations and Their Violations

Mining Temporal Rules for Software Maintenance

Path-Sensitive Multi-Variable Access Correlations Mining and Related Source Code Defects Detection

Directed Symbolic Execution for Binary Vulnerability Mining

VulMiningBGS: Detection of Overflow Vulnerabilities Based on Graph Similarity

Vulnerability discovery based on source code patch commit mining: a systematic literature review

Pf-Miner: A New Paired Functions Mining Method for Android Kernel in Error Paths

SAFE: Advancing Large Language Models in Leveraging Semantic and Syntactic Relationships for Software Vulnerability Detection

Mining Exception-Handling Rules As Sequence Association Rules

An Effective Taint‐based Software Vulnerability Miner

NEGWeb : Detecting Neglected Conditions via Mining Programming Rules from Open Source Code