Abstract:The accurate representation of the structural and dynamical properties of water is essential for simulating the unique behavior of this ubiquitous solvent. Here we assess the current status of describing liquid water using ab initio molecular dynamics, with a special focus on the performance of all the later generation Minnesota functionals. Findings are contextualized within the current knowledge on DFT for describing bulk water under ambient conditions and compared to experimental data. We find that, contrary to the prevalent idea that local and semilocal functionals overstructure water and underestimate dynamical properties, M06-L, revM06-L, and M11-L understructure water, while MN12-L and MN15-L overdistance water molecules due to weak cohesive effects. This can be attributed to a weakening of the hydrogen bond network, which leads to dynamical fingerprints that are over fast. While most of the hybrid Minnesota functionals (M06, M08-HX, M08-SO, M11, MN12-SX, and MN15) also yield understructured water, their dynamical properties generally improve over their semilocal counterparts. It emerges that exact exchange is a crucial component for accurately describing hydrogen bonds, which ultimately leads to corrections in both the dynamical and structural properties. However, an excessive amount of exact exchange strengthens hydrogen bonds and causes overstructuring and slow dynamics (M06-HF). As a compromise, M06-2X is the best performing Minnesota functional for water, and its D3 corrected variant shows very good structural agreement. From previous studies considering nuclear quantum effects (NQEs), the hybrid revPBE0-D3, and the rung-5 RPA (RPA@PBE) have been identified as the only two approximations that closely agree with experiments. Our results suggest that the M06-2X(-D3) functionals have the potential to further improve the reproduction of experimental properties when incorporating NQEs through path integral approaches. This work provides further proof that accurate modeling of water interactions requires the inclusion of both exact exchange and balanced (non-local) correlation, highlighting the need for higher rungs on Jacob's ladder to achieve predictive simulations of complex biological systems in aqueous environments.

What is the Best Density Functional to Describe Water Clusters: Evaluation of Widely Used Density Functionals with Various Basis Sets for (H 2 O) N ( N = 1–10)

Ab Initio Investigation Of Structure, Stability, Thermal Behavior, Bonding, And Infrared Spectra Of Ionized Water Cluster (H2o)(6)(+) (Vol 145, 154307, 2016)

Ab Initio Investigation of the Lower Energy Candidate Structures for (h2o)(5)+ Water Cluster

Ab Initio Investigation of Possible Candidate Structures and Properties of Water Cluster (H2O)7+ Via Particle Swarm Optimization Method

Possible Low-Energy Isomers of OH (H2O)4 (n = 0, ±1) Clusters Via the Particle Swarm Optimization Algorithm: an Ab Initio Study

Ab Initio Study of Cationic Water Cluster (H2O)(9)(+) Via Particle Swarm Optimization Algorithm

Noninteracting-blip approximation for a two-level system coupled to a heat bath.

Perspective: How good is DFT for water?

Dispersion- and Exchange-Corrected Density Functional Theory for Sodium Ion Hydration

Density functional theory (DFT) study of water autoionization in solvated clusters

Are fragment-based quantum chemistry methods applicable to medium-sized water clusters?

Structure and dynamics of liquid water from ab initio simulations: Adding Minnesota density functionals to Jacob's ladder

The individual and collective effects of exact exchange and dispersion interactions on the ab initio structure of liquid water

Density functional theory studies on the solvent effects in Al(H 2 O) 6 3+ water-exchange reactions: the number and arrangement of outer-sphere water molecules.

Dynamics and structural changes of small water clusters on ionization

Low-Lying Structures and Stabilities of Large Water Clusters: Investigation Based on the Combination of the Amoeba Potential and Generalized Energy-Based Fragmentation Approach

Electron affinities of water clusters from density-functional and many-body-perturbation theory

Infrared Spectra of Small Anionic Water Clusters from Density Functional Theory and Wavefunction Theory Calculations

A computational study of H-bonded networks in cyclic water clusters, (H2O)n (n = 3–12)

A Theoretical Study on the Formation, Binding Energy and Monomer Dipole Moment of Small Water Cluster Systems

Performance of Several Density Functional Theory Methods on Describing Hydrogen-Bond Interactions