Comparison of Mass Spectrometry and Spectroscopy Methods Applied to Measurements of Water Triple Oxygen Isotopic Compositions
Pengzhen Duan,Sasadhar Mahata,Baoyun Zong,Lijuan Sha,Pu Zhang,Youfeng Ning,Hai Cheng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1360/tb-2021-0773
2021-01-01
Chinese Science Bulletin (Chinese Version)
Abstract:High-precision measurements of oxygen isotopic compositions in water are of great importance for understanding regional and global hydrological cycles and historical hydroclimate change. Several methods have been developed to determine the triple oxygen isotopic proxy (O-17-excess) in water. However, these methods are not applicable because of poor precision or poisonous compound utilisation. Recently. a method based on CO2-H2O equilibration followed by an isotopic exchange between CO2 and O-2 catalysed by hot platinum, was developed to measure water O-17-excess with high precision (less than 10 per meg, 1 per meg=10(-6)). It has also been demonstrated that this method has the capability to obtain sufficiently precise water O-17-excess values, by performing more injections per sample and/or giving longer integration time per injection. Here, we describe the water O-17-excess measurement method using cavity ring-down spectroscopy (Picarro L2140-i) and mass spectrometry (MAT 253) devices, the latter of which comprises CO2-H2O equilibrium and CO2-O-2 equilibration systems that produce pretreated O-2 for measurement. The excellent agreement between the oxygen isotopic compositions of international standard waters, derived from both methods, and the recommended or previously reported values, confirms the reliability and accuracy of the two methods. Each method has advantages and disadvantages in terms of efficiency, sensitivity to environmental disturbance, sample quantity demand, and so on. Repeated measurements of Greenland Ice Sheet Precipitation (GISP) were performed to check the reliability of the data normalisation method to the Vienna Standard Mean Ocean Water-Standard Light Antarctic Precipitation (VSMOW-SLAP) scale. For the Picarro method, delta(18)O(VSMOW-SLAP )and delta O-17(VSMOW-SLAP) values equalled -24.80 parts per thousand +/- 0.03 parts per thousand and -13.15 parts per thousand +/- 0.02 parts per thousand, respectively (l sigma), while for the mass spectrometry method, delta O-18(VSMOW-SLAP) and delta O-18(VSMOW-SLAP) values equalled -24.82 parts per thousand +/- 0.04 parts per thousand and -13.16 parts per thousand +/- 0.03 parts per thousand, respectively (l sigma). The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reported a GISP delta O-18(VSMOW-SLAP) value of -24.76 parts per thousand +/- 0.09 parts per thousand(1 sigma). and the average GISP delta 17O(VSMOW-SLAP) value from previous studies is -13.12 parts per thousand +/- 0.06 parts per thousand. O-17-excess values were calculated from oxygen isotope ratios, and we obtained an average value of 26 +/- 8 and 21 +/- 6 per meg (1 sigma) for the Picarro and mass spectrometry methods, respectively, both of which are close to the average of previously reported values (22 +/- 11 per meg). Collectively. these results demonstrate that both methods can be used to obtain accurate water triple oxygen isotopes with high precision. Moreover, both methods reproduce the previously reported 26 per meg difference between USGS 45 and USGS 47 O-17-excess values. This demonstrates the ability of the methods to distinguish the differences in precipitation. atmospheric vapour, cave drip water, and ice core water samples. Triple oxygen isotope measurement methods were applied to determine summer and winter precipitation O-17-excess values from Nanjing, Xi'an, and Urumqi, which exhibit distinct spatiotemporal differences. Although the precipitation delta O-18 values in Nanjing and Xi'an were significantly greater in winter and lower in summer, seasonal changes in O-17-excess appear complex, and thus more data are required. The precipitation delta O-18 values from Urumqi show the opposite pattern, with higher O-17-excess values in winter. Additional measurements are required to confirm this pattern.