Relational Contract Governance and Performance of Outsourcing Collaboration:An Empirical Study of Off-shoring Software Outsourcing from Japan
Deng Chunping,Mao Jiye
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2008.04.005
2008-01-01
Abstract:Software outsourcing is of strategic significance for our nation to overcome the environmental bottleneck and resource con-straints. Offshoring software outsourcing from Japanese clients has the typical characteristics of relational contract, for several reasons. For instance, it is difficult to make formal contracts complete partly because it is hard to assess the knowledge input to a project. Fur-thermore, outsourcing in an offshore cross-cultural setting creates extra risks for project deliverables and cost control, while raising the need for intensive collaboration, flexibility, and high quality com-munication. Therefore, important relational norms, such as commu-nication, trust, and inter-firm adaptation, are expected to play a sig-nificant role in offshoring software outsourcing success. However, there exists little prior research on relational contract governance and its impact on the performance of software outsourcing. In this study, a research model was developed based on the literature inter-views with senior managers and developers in several software out-sourcing companies in Beijing and Xi'an. The independent variables include trust, communication, and mutual adaptation; the dependent variables are project quality and cost control. The research model was tested with questionnaire data collected from 110 project man-agers in nine software outsourcing vendors in China. Results show that communication has a positive effect on project quality and cost control for offshore outsourcing projects from Japan. Moreover, inter-firm adaptation has a positive influence on project cost control. However, contrary to our expectation, Chinese vendors' trust in the Japanese clients has no significant effect on project quality, but a negative relationship with cost control. This unexpected result could be due to the asymmetrical relationship between the large-size Japanese clients and relatively smaller Chinese vendors, who have little bargaining power. These findings could be useful for creating effective relational governance mechanisms and strengthening the Chinese offshoring software outsourcing industry.