Abstract:The CIELAB lightness and chroma values of pixels in five of the eight ISO SCID natural images were modified to produce sample images. Pairs of images were displayed on a calibrated monitor and assessed by a panel of 12 observers with normal color vision using a categorical judgment method. The experimental results showed that assuming the lightness parametric factor k(L)=1 to predict color differences in images, CIELAB performed better than CIEDE2000, CIE94, or CMC, which is a different result to the one found in color-difference literature for homogeneous color pairs. However, observers perceived CIELAB lightness and chroma differences in images in different ways. To fit current experimental data, a specific methodology is proposed to optimize k(L) in the color-difference formulas CIELAB, CIEDE2000, CIE94, and CMC. From the standardized residual sum of squares (STRESS) index, it was found that the optimized formulas, CIEDE2000(2.3:1), CIE94(3.0:1), and CMC(3.4:1), performed significantly better than their corresponding original forms with lightness parametric factor k(L)=1. Specifically, CIEDE2000(2.3:1) performed the best, with a satisfactory average STRESS value of 25.8, which is very similar to the 27.5 value that was found from the CIEDE2000(1:1) formula for the combined weighted dataset of homogeneous color samples employed at the development of this formula [J. Opt. Soc. Am. A25, 1828 (2008), Table 2]. However, fitting our experimental data, none of the four optimized formulas CIELAB(1.5:1), CIEDE2000(2.3:1), CIE94(3.0:1), and CMC(3.4:1) is significantly better than the others. Current results roughly agree with the recent CIE recommendation that color difference in images can be predicted by simply adopting a lightness parametric factor k(L)=2 in CIELAB or CIEDE2000 [CIE Publication 199:2011]. It was also found that the different contents of the five images have considerable influence on the performance of the tested color-difference formulas.

Surface Inspection Based on Color Clustering of Mapping Chromatism

Colorimetric Characterization of Scanner by Measures of Perceptual Color Error.

Colorimetric Characterization of Imaging Device by Total Color Difference Minimization

Estimation of Spectral Reflectance of Object Surfaces with the Consideration of Perceptual Color Space

Computational Model for Color Mapping on Texture Images.

Estimation of Illuminant Chromaticity by Linear Fitting Approach

Colorimetric and Spectral Characterization of A Color Scanner Using Local Statistics

Investigation of texture effect on visual colour difference evaluation

Research on Color Normalization of Traffic Sign Image Based on Surface Segmentation and Improved K-means Clustering Algorithm

A Semi-Supervised Color Image Segmentation Method

Image Quality Assessment Based on S-Cielab Model

A New Image Retrieval Method Based on Optimal Color Matching.

A Virtual Color Space Based on Physical Model

Color Constancy Model Based on Topology Resolve-Map in Medical Image Processing

The Display of Deviation Color Map in Inspection of Free-Form Surface

Colorimetric characterisation of low-end digital camera and its application for on-screen texture visualisation

Testing Uniform Colour Spaces Using Colour Differences of a Wide Colour Gamut

Evaluation of Threshold Color Differences Using Printed Samples.

Image-guided color mapping for categorical data visualization

Research and Implementation of Automatic Color Segmentation Algorithm for Scanned Color Maps

Color-difference evaluation for digital images using a categorical judgment method.