Did the Introduction of CSI 300 Index Futures Improve the Quality of Spot Stock Market: An Empirical Study Based on Simultaneous-equations Model
Xu Hongwei,Wu Chongfeng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2012.04.011
2012-01-01
Abstract:As the first financial index futures item,the introduction of CSI 300 index futures has attracted a great deal of attention.But there are still considerable debates on its potential effects on the spot stock market.Some argue that it can improve the market quality of the stock market,but others argue that futures trading may destabilize the market by reducing liquidity and increasing volatility.This paper,investigates whether CSI 300 index futures improve the market quality,including liquidity and volatility,of Chinese cash A-shares in its earlier period.We construct a simultaneous-equations model to take account of the interact relationship of these attributes,and using the constituents stocks of three CSI scale indexes to be on behalf of different market value stocks.Our evidences show that,in general,the micro liquidity and intraday volatility of the cash equities deteriorated in the earlier period of index futures than before,which is consistent with Silber(1985),Stein(1987) and Subrahmanyam(1991),but not with the policy makers and regulators.Specially,after controlling other factors,the daily turnover decreased and the effective spread widened,suggesting that the Migration Effect was greater than the Incremental effect.And the intraday volatility increased,implying that the index futures made the spot stocks prices become more unstable.Furthermore,CSI 300 index futures had various negative impacts on different stock groups;the underlying and big cap stocks suffered a greater bad impact than other ones.We argue that one of the reasons is that a large number of uninformed investors chose to migrate from the spot stock market into the index futures market,because the latter has many advantages,such as lower transaction costs,higher liquidity,price discovery and risk hedge market.The migration activities resulted in the problems of information asymmetry and adverse selection of the spot market,which eventually led to the deterioration of the quality of market microstructure.The test results using the method Probability of Informed Trading(PIN) proves our hypothesis.