Abstract:According to the fundamental theorems of welfare economics, any competitive equilibrium is Pareto efficient. Unfortunately, competitive equilibrium prices only exist under strong assumptions such as perfectly divisible goods and convex preferences. In many real-world markets, participants have non-convex preferences and the allocation problem needs to consider complex constraints. Electricity markets are a prime example, but similar problems appear in many real-world markets, which has led to a growing literature in market design. Power markets use heuristic pricing rules based on the dual of a relaxed allocation problem today. With increasing levels of renewables, these rules have come under scrutiny as they lead to high out-of-market side-payments to some participants and to inadequate congestion signals. We show that existing pricing heuristics optimize specific design goals that can be conflicting. The trade-offs can be substantial, and we establish that the design of pricing rules is fundamentally a multi-objective optimization problem addressing different incentives. In addition to traditional multi-objective optimization techniques using weighing of individual objectives, we introduce a novel parameter-free pricing rule that minimizes incentives for market participants to deviate locally. Our theoretical and experimental findings show how the new pricing rule capitalizes on the upsides of existing pricing rules under scrutiny today. It leads to prices that incur low make-whole payments while providing adequate congestion signals and low lost opportunity costs. Our suggested pricing rule does not require weighing of objectives, it is computationally scalable, and balances trade-offs in a principled manner, addressing an important policy issue in electricity markets.

Pricing when Market Optimization Has Multiple Dual Solutions

Simulation-based Optimization of Mixed Road Pricing Policies in a Large Real-world Network

Dual-Based Heuristic for Optimal Cordon Pricing Design

Pricing in non-convex electricity markets with flexible trade-off of pricing properties

Pricing And Market Clearing Mechanism Based On Consumer Payment And Generation Bid Cost Minimization

Optimal Pricing in Social Networks with Incomplete Information

A Capacitated Firm's Pricing Strategies for Strategic Consumers with Different Search Costs.

Pricing Model for Dual Sales Channel with Promotion Effect Consideration

Pricing to Maximize Revenue and Welfare Simultaneously in Large Markets

Competitive Cloud Pricing for Long-Term Revenue Maximization

A Two-Step Approach to Optimal Dynamic Pricing in Multi-Demand Combinatorial Markets

Pricing Optimization for Selling Reusable Resources

Multi-period Pricing in the Presence of Competition and Social Influence

Dynamic Pricing in a Dual Market Environment

Dynamic Pricing Based on Strategic Consumers and Substitutes in a Duopoly Setting

Pricing Optimal Outcomes in Coupled and Non-Convex Markets: Theory and Applications to Electricity Markets

Crossing Network Externality and Skewed Pricing in Two-sided Markets

Social Optimal Pricing

Optimal Pricing for the Competitive and Evolutionary Cloud Market.

Joint pricing and advertising strategy with reference price effect

Multi-Objective Optimization Model with Application to Electricity Pricing