A survey on voltage stability analysis methods

Taishan Xu,Yusheng Xue,Zhenxiang Han

1996-01-01

Abstract:Voltage stability analysis methods are reviewed in this paper, and some potential research topics are discussed as well.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Deterministic And Probabilistic Analysis Of Static Voltage Stability In Power Systems

X. Hou,P. Ju

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/SUPERGEN.2009.5348377

2009-01-01

Abstract:The mechanism of static voltage stability was examined by a visual explanation, in that way, the static voltage stability criterion was obtained. It was indicated that the static voltage stability is determined by both characteristics in generation side and characteristics in load side. Then each kind of two-dimensional plane analysis can be unified in three-dimensional space. It is pointed that both critical voltage and voltage stability margin should be use for indexes. The impact of load model on static voltage stability is discussed by both deterministic and probabilistic analysis method.
Probabilistic analysis of static voltage stability in power systems based on two-point estimate method

HOU Xue-yong,JU Ping,FU Hong-jun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3876/j.issn.1000-1980.2010.03.022

2010-01-01

Abstract:For the quantitative analysis of voltage stability,especially for meeting the requirement of adaptation to its probabilistic analysis,a generalized margin index for static voltage stability (SVS) is proposed. The index can be employed to qualitatively judge the stability and quantitatively describe the degree of instability. The two-point estimate method was introduced into the probabilistic analysis of SVS. With regard to the uncertainty of parameters of power sources and load in power systems,the generalized index of the power difference margin was regarded as a stochastic variable to be solved. Its statistical characteristic values,such as the mean value and the standard deviation,were calculated so as to obtain the probability of the static voltage stability. The results of a calculation example were compared with those of the Monte-Carlo simulation method. It is concluded that the proposed method is valid,and that it can greatly save time while maintaining an equivalent precision.
Three-dimensional Analysis of the Static Voltage Stability and the Critical Voltage in Power System

HOU Xueyong,JU Ping,LU Yang-wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3876/j.issn.1000-1980.2008.03.024

2008-01-01

Abstract:The mechanism of static voltage stability is discussed and shown in diagrams,allowing the static voltage stability criterion to be obtained.Analysis of three-dimensional diagrams indicates that the static voltage stability is determined by both transmission characteristics and load characteristics. Any two-dimensional analyses can be conducted within three-dimensional analyses.
Steady-State Voltage Stability Analysis Considering the Characteristics of Power Electronic Interfaced Loads

Jie Yang,Yuqing Jin,Jianhua Li,Ping Ju

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/PSGEC58411.2023.10255872

2023-01-01

Abstract:In recent years, an increasing number of electrical devices have been connected to the power grid through power electronic devices. The characteristics of these loads are different from those of conventional loads. Therefore, it is necessary to consider the influences of these loads in the study of steady-state voltage stability. Firstly, introduce the definition of voltage exponents and the way to calculate them. According to the experimental data, the voltage exponents of some typical power electronic interfaced loads are obtained. Then, illustrate the load model and load change mode used in this paper. Based on this, take a two-bus system as an example to calculate its critical values in the specific load change mode. Finally, the relationship between voltage exponents and the critical value is analyzed, the results show that large voltage exponents are conductive to steady-state voltage stability of the system.
Research on Voltage Stability of HVDC Receiving-end System Based on Power Limit Trajectory

Yuntian Lou,Chen Li,Fei Wang,Qichao Chen,Zhenjian Xie,Huanhai Xin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ei252483.2021.9713383

2021-01-01

Abstract:The typical receiving-end systems in China are continuously connected with HVDC transmission lines, which changes the traditional grid form and makes the voltage stability problem prominent. How to understand the relation among voltage stability, power grid strength and equipment control is the key to grasp the mechanism of voltage stability and improve the control to avoid the systems entering into static voltage instability and transient voltage instability. In this paper, the relation among the transmitted active power, the voltage at the equipment infeed point and the current of AC system is studied, the relation among the voltage stability and the power grid strength and the control logic of the equipment is explained. Then, the influence rules of line reactance and equipment reactive power on the power limit trajectory (PLT) is studied. In the end, based on the power limit trajectory determined by line reactance, the simulation results of PSCAD/EMTDC showed that the improved DC control method can improve the voltage stability, and the theory in this paper has a certain practical guiding significance.
Small-disturbance voltage stability analysis with EEAC method

Xu Taishan,Yusheng Xue,Han Zhenxiang

1996-01-01

Abstract:A brand-new method for small-disturbance voltage stability assessment (SVSA) is put forth in the present paper, which is based on the natural links between small-disturbance and large-disturbance stabilities, and based on the adaptation of the extended equal area criterion (EEAC) for small-disturbance. A rigorous margin for SVSA is proposed, and is adapted to calculate the maximum loading point. The robustness and rapidity have been verified on the 31 bus Huazhong system and 39 bus New England system.
Research on voltage stability of power system based on hybrid system theory

Gang-feng YAN,Qing-yi TONG,Guang-zhou ZHAO

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-973X.2005.05.008

2005-01-01

Abstract:Analysis of power system showed that its voltage stability had the typical characteristics of hybrid system. However, the power subsystems cannot be described by pure ordinary differential equation (ODE) but by differential algebraic equation (DAE). Therefore, voltage stability boils down to the stability problem of differential algebraic hybrid system (DAHS). The abstract power system models were used to define the general form of DAHS, then a new stability theory framework was presented. The results of stable and asymptotically stable voltage were educed using Lyapunov's direct method. Simulation results show that the presented stability theory results can be successfully used for analysis of voltage stability.
ANALYSIS OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN VOLTAGE STABILITY AND ANGLE STABILITY THROUGH EQUILIBRIUMS

吴浩,韩祯祥

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1000-1026.2003.12.006

2003-01-01

Abstract:Through investigating equilibrium points of a typical power system, this paper shows that voltage stability and angle stability can be linked by the unstable equilibrium points (UEPs) of the system. The unstable mode changes with the power flow mode of the system. The lower part and the other branch of the PV curve contain abundant information about system bifurcating, from which the situation of the UEPs can be learned. The analyzed results indicate that different load model can lead to different system unstable mode. The conclusions are general, and provide deeper understanding of the relationship between voltage stability and angle stability in complex power systems.
THE ANALYSIS OF VOLTAGE STABILITY AND SYNCHRONISM STABILITY IN POWER SYSTEMS

彭志炜,胡国根,韩祯祥

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-8930.2000.01.001

2000-01-01

Abstract:This paper presents the static bifurcation conditoins of voltageand synchronism instability based on bifur～cation theory. According to the conditions obtained in this paper,the relation between the voltage and synchronism stability is studied with the different operation state of the power system. Some new viewpoints are given also.
Study on preventive and corrective control of voltage instability

SUN Jing,ZHANG Bin,DU Ming-xing

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-3415.2007.17.014

2007-01-01

Abstract:The importance of voltage stability research is further recognized from the fact of some severe and widespread blackouts, and one of the research purposes is to explore control measures for preventing voltage instability. In this paper, general control measures to prevent voltage instability and their functions are introduced firstly.Then the controlling strategy to prevent voltage instability in applications is proposed.And finally the simulation of voltage stability based on BCH (B.C. Hydro) system is carried out by VSAT analytical tool. The simulating results testify that the study on preventive and corrective control measures for voltage instability is an important and valuable work.
Stability Analysis and Impedance Reshaping Method for DC Resonance in VSCs-based Power System

Heng Nian,Jun Yang,Bin Hu,Yingzong Jiao,Yunyang Xu,Meng Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tec.2021.3066201

IF: 4.8767

2021-01-01

IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion

Abstract:With the rapid growth of renewable energy and power electronic loads, voltage source converters (VSCs) have been commonly applied in different VSCs-based power systems, which also bring in stability issues due to their power electronic characteristics. The impedance-based stability theory and corresponding reshaping method can be used to analyze and solve system stability issue. However, dc stability issue in VSCs-based power systems becomes more complicated when considering ac/dc coupling relationship. This paper proposes an improved reshaping control strategy based on the detailed impedance model considering grid impedance and control delay. The influence of grid impedance, control delay and control parameters of VSC on dc stability are further analyzed to identify the cause of potential resonance risk. The proposed impedance reshaping method considers the trade-off between stability improvement and control performance, and compensates the impacts of grid impedance and control delay at the same time. The validity of stability analysis and reshaping method is further verified through the simulation and experimental results.
Study of the power system load voltage stability - Part one: Analysis method

Zhiwei Peng,Guogen Hu,Zhenxiang Han

1997-01-01

Abstract:In order to study the power system load voltage stability, a new algorithm which changes the equilibrium solution problem into the initial value differential equation problem in vector field is presented by means of bifurcation, topology theory and induced vector field conception in this paper. It indicates that the new algorithm can accomplish tracking the equilibrium solution manifold, searching for the static bifurcation points and discriminating their types successively in a large region with controllable calculation step.
A Comprehensive Survey on Real-Time Voltage Stability Assessment for Power Systems

Gourav Wadhwa,Amandeep Kharb,Satyam Mishra,Mohit Kumar,Shreyansh Srivastav

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2011.10885

2020-11-22

Abstract:Accurate real-time assessment of power systems voltage stability has been an active area of research in the past few decades. In the past decade, after the development of phasor measurement units (PMU), a lot of discussions has been going on phasor measurement techniques for real-time voltage stability. The fundamental idea behind these methods is to find the Thevenin equivalents of the system, and then determine the voltage stability margin based on the equivalent circuits. Some approaches also include the use of Artificial Neural Networks (ANN), for online monitoring of voltage stability margins. These methods are really fast as compared to the other methods. It has been shown that if we can obtain the phase angles and voltage magnitude in real-time from the phasor measurement units (PMU), then the voltage stability margins can be obtained in real-time and we can initiate voltage stability control methods. We are going to discuss Thevenin's equivalent methods and Artificial Intelligence methods in detail in this paper. We will also introduce the traditional methods which were earlier used for power systems stability assessment such as Time Domain methods, Static Methods, and Sensitivity methods. We are going to finally compare these methods and try to give general guidance on choosing a power stability method.

Systems and Control
A Study on Probability of Voltage Instability Based on the Stochastic Characteristic of Load Margin Index

DAI Jian-feng,WANG Hai-chao,ZHOU Shuang-xi,LU Zong-xiang,ZHU Ling-zhi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:0258-8013.2006.13.005

2006-01-01

Abstract:In order to make up the deficiency of traditional analytical method used in the research of voltage stability problem, we need to know the probability information concerned with voltage instability. Therefore, this paper proposes a method to calculate the probability of voltage instability based on the stochastic characteristic of load margin index. This method firstly determines the stochastic characteristic of load margin index through an analysis about the randomicity of parameters which tie up with the tracing of critical point in continue power flow computation, and then figures out the probability of voltage instability by using moment and cumulate method. Owing to take into account more uncertain factors' influence on the voltage stability, the result acquired by this method is much more accurate and reasonable. A numerical simulation based on IEEE 39-bus system reveals that the proposed method works properly.
Study of Stability Analysis and Design Method for Grid-Connected Converter Connected to Three-Phase Voltage Source Converter

Hongyang Li,Min Chen,Haoqing Cai,Changsheng Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/peas58692.2023.10395107

2023-01-01

Abstract:Stability is an important concern for the three-phase grid-connected converter (GCC) connected to a three-phase voltage source converter (VSC). However, the traditional grid-connected converter with parameters designed for grid connection requirements may have the problem of current oscillation when three-phase ac voltage is supported by voltage source converter. In this paper, the output impedance of VSC with double-closed-loop control of voltage and current is established. Moreover, the influences of impedance and controlled power on power system stability are analyzed by Bode diagram. Finally, the control parameters are redesigned and verified on a 100-kW three-phase ac system.
A Review of Data-Driven Short-Term Voltage Stability Assessment of Power Systems: Concept, Principle, and Challenges

Jiting Cao,Meng Zhang,Yang Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/5920244

IF: 1.43

2021-12-30

Mathematical Problems in Engineering

Abstract:With the rapid growth of power market reform and power demand, the power transmission capacity of a power grid is approaching its limit and the secure and stable operation of power systems becomes increasingly important. In particular, in modern power grids, the proportion of dynamic loads with fast recovery characteristics such as air conditioners, refrigerators, and industrial motors is increasing. As well as there is an increasing proportion of different forms of renewable energy in power systems. Therefore, the short-term voltage stability (STVS) of power systems cannot be ignored. This article comprehensively sorts out the STVS problems of power systems from the perspective of data-driven methods and discusses existing challenges.

engineering, multidisciplinary,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications
Practical short-term voltage stability index based on voltage curves: definition, verification and case studies

Wenlu Zhao,Qinglai Guo,Hongbin Sun,Huaichang Ge,Haifeng Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1049/iet-gtd.2018.5725

2018-01-01

Abstract:Short-term voltage stability (SVS) is a serious issue in modern power systems. In China, the East China Power Network is especially vulnerable to short-term voltage instability due to its increasing dependence on electrical power from external through high-voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission lines. To study the SVS, a criterion/index is first required to evaluate the SVS of power systems. H...
Stability Analysis and Comparison of DC Power System with Different Droop Control Methods

Jun Yang,Meng Li,Heng Nian,Yuming Liao,Bin Hu,Libin Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ei252483.2021.9712962

2021-01-01

Abstract:With the rapid development of renewable energy system, de power system has been widely applied to accommodate multiple renewable energy sources and power electronic loads, where the voltage source converters (VSCs) are commonly adopted as interconnected interface. The power electronic characteristic of VSCs will bring in stability issues, while the impedance-based stability theory can be used to analyze system stability. In the dc power system, droop control method is widely adopted to coordinate different renewable energy sources, where the droop gain and control structure of droop-controlled VSCs will both affect system stability. This paper mainly focuses on the stability issue in droop-controlled dc power system, and investigates the impacts of droop gain and different control methods based on the developed impedance model. Furthermore, the validity of stability analysis results is further verified through the simulation results.
A Discrete System Approach for Short-term Voltage Stability Analysis

Zhuoran Kang,Feng Qian,Minquan Chen,Junlei Liu,Shangyuan Li,Deqiang Gan,Qiuna Cai,Jie Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/apap47170.2019.9225123

2019-01-01

Abstract:A key task in stability analysis is to solve a group of differential - algebraic equations. In this paper, a closed-form solution of the network equations is derived based on the familiar Dommel-Sato iteration. For different load models, we derive the corresponding closed-form network voltage expressions. After applying the improved Euler integration, a discrete system model of AC power grid dynamics is obtained. Examples using the proposed discrete system model are provided, and compared with the simulation results using BPA, a popular production-grade simulation software.
A Two-Level Voltage Stability Monitoring Method Based On P-V Sensitivity Assessment

Junlei Liu,Huaichang Ge,Yinguo Yang,Qinglai Guo,Feng Qian,Hongbin Sun,Mingye Zhang,Bin Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/pesgm.2017.8274188

2017-01-01

Abstract:In this paper, the authors will introduce a two-level voltage stability evaluation method consists of control center level and substation level. At control center level, some certain sensitivities related with operation state of overall system are calculated and these variables are sent to several substations. At substation level, the proposed method adopts a different system model rather than The venin Equivalent Circuit, such that the results of local voltage stability assessment are more accurate than traditional distributed methods. The performance of the proposed method is tested on IEEE 39-bus system.

A survey on voltage stability analysis methods

Deterministic And Probabilistic Analysis Of Static Voltage Stability In Power Systems

Probabilistic analysis of static voltage stability in power systems based on two-point estimate method

Three-dimensional Analysis of the Static Voltage Stability and the Critical Voltage in Power System

Steady-State Voltage Stability Analysis Considering the Characteristics of Power Electronic Interfaced Loads

Research on Voltage Stability of HVDC Receiving-end System Based on Power Limit Trajectory

Small-disturbance voltage stability analysis with EEAC method

Research on voltage stability of power system based on hybrid system theory

ANALYSIS OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN VOLTAGE STABILITY AND ANGLE STABILITY THROUGH EQUILIBRIUMS

THE ANALYSIS OF VOLTAGE STABILITY AND SYNCHRONISM STABILITY IN POWER SYSTEMS

Study on preventive and corrective control of voltage instability

Stability Analysis and Impedance Reshaping Method for DC Resonance in VSCs-based Power System

Study of the power system load voltage stability - Part one: Analysis method

A Comprehensive Survey on Real-Time Voltage Stability Assessment for Power Systems

A Study on Probability of Voltage Instability Based on the Stochastic Characteristic of Load Margin Index

Study of Stability Analysis and Design Method for Grid-Connected Converter Connected to Three-Phase Voltage Source Converter

A Review of Data-Driven Short-Term Voltage Stability Assessment of Power Systems: Concept, Principle, and Challenges

Practical short-term voltage stability index based on voltage curves: definition, verification and case studies

Stability Analysis and Comparison of DC Power System with Different Droop Control Methods

A Discrete System Approach for Short-term Voltage Stability Analysis

A Two-Level Voltage Stability Monitoring Method Based On P-V Sensitivity Assessment