Optimal Temperature Ranges Considering Gender Differences in Thermal Comfort, Work Performance, and Sick Building Syndrome: a Winter Field Study in University Classrooms
Jinhua Hu,Yingdong He,Xiaoli Hao,Nianping Li,Yuan Su,Huaidi Qu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2021.111554
IF: 7.201
2021-01-01
Energy and Buildings
Abstract:Enjoyable thermal feelings, high work performance, and low-prevalence sick building syndrome (SBS) have the highest priority in creating indoor environments. Nonetheless, few studies provide clear optimal temperature ranges with full consideration of gender differences with respect to the three above mentioned characteristics. The main objective of this study is to investigate optimal temperature ranges with enjoyable comfort, productive performance, and low SBS prevalence for both male and female students in university classrooms. A winter field investigation, including environmental, physiological, and psychological measurements, was conducted in 27 naturally ventilated and 24 air-conditioned classrooms of a university. The data from 2110 students were collected for analyzing (1) gender differences in thermal comfort, work performance, and SBS, and (2) optimal temperature ranges for balancing multiple benefits. The obtained results indicate that in cool environments, the males exhibited better comfort, higher work performance, and lower SBS prevalence than the females. Specifically, less than 30% of the males felt cold discomfort when the indoor temperature was above 14.6 degrees C, while the corresponding indoor temperature for the females was above 19.5 degrees C. Owing to the strong adaptation to cool environments, less than 20% of the males felt unproductive and showed obvious SBS symptoms when the indoor temperatures were below 18.4 and 16.5 degrees C, respectively. However, due to the relatively weak low-temperature tolerance, more than 20% of the females felt unproductive and showed obvious SBS symptoms irrespective of the indoor temperature. Moreover, 17.3-22.0 degrees C and 18.5-20.8 degrees C were found to be the balanced optimal temperature ranges for the males and females, respectively, with less than 30% of total participants exhibiting cool sensations, low work performance, and obvious SBS symptoms. However, for ensuring participants' high willingness to work, the optimal indoor temperatures should be higher than 20.3 degrees C for males and 20.4 degrees C for females. (c) 2021 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.