A Monte Carlo Comparison of Panel Unit Root Tests under Factor Structure

J. H. Lin,Yi Hu,M. J. Wang,X. H. Xia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13504851.2012.695067

2013-01-01

Applied Economics Letters

Abstract:This article investigates and compares, through Monte Carlo experiments, the finite sample sizes and powers of the proposed 'second-generation' Panel Unit Root Tests (PUTs) under the strict and approximate factor structures, respectively.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Asymptotically Uniformly Most Powerful Tests For Unit Roots In Gaussian Panels With Cross-Sectional Dependence Generated By Common Factors

Oliver Wichert,I. Gaia Becheri,Feike C. Drost,Ramon van den Akker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0266466624000112

IF: 1.968

2024-04-30

Econometric Theory

Abstract:This paper considers testing for unit roots in Gaussian panels with cross-sectional dependence generated by common factors. Within our setup, we can analyze restricted versions of the two prevalent approaches in the literature, that of Moon and Perron (2004, Journal of Econometrics 122, 81–126), who specify a factor model for the innovations, and the PANIC setup proposed in Bai and Ng (2004, Econometrica 72, 1127–1177), who test common factors and idiosyncratic deviations separately for unit roots. We show that both frameworks lead to locally asymptotically normal experiments with the same central sequence and Fisher information. Using Le Cam's theory of statistical experiments, we obtain the local asymptotic power envelope for unit-root tests. We show that the popular Moon and Perron (2004, Journal of Econometrics 122, 81–126) and Bai and Ng (2010, Econometric Theory 26, 1088–1114) tests only attain the power envelope in case there is no heterogeneity in the long-run variance of the idiosyncratic components. We develop a new test which is asymptotically uniformly most powerful irrespective of possible heterogeneity in the long-run variance of the idiosyncratic components. Monte Carlo simulations corroborate our asymptotic results and document significant gains in finite-sample power if the variances of the idiosyncratic shocks differ substantially among the cross-sectional units.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,statistics & probability
Unit Root Test in Panel Data Basing on the Limiting Spectral Distribution of Large-Dimensional Random Matrix

ZHAO Xiao-fang,WANG Cheng,MIAO Bai-qi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-0984.2013.22.003

2010-01-01

Abstract:With the development of Computer information technology, large-dimensional panel data models have been introduced into the econometric researches during the past three decades, in order to solve the more and more complex economic phenomenons. As we know, the one-dimensional time series has the across time feature, so the panel data does. Then, when we confront with the panel data, we must be sure it is stationary. That means we should test unit root before regressing in order to avoid spurious regression. This article provides a new unit root test method for panel data which is basing on the theory of the limiting spectral distribution of large-dimensional random matrix.
The Local Power of the CADF and CIPS Panel Unit Root Tests

Joakim Westerlund,Mehdi Hosseinkouchack,Martin Solberger

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07474938.2014.977077

IF: 1.2

2014-10-20

Econometric Reviews

Abstract:Very little is known about the local power of second generation panel unit root tests that are robust to cross-section dependence. This article derives the local asymptotic power functions of the cross-section argumented Dickey–Fuller Cross-section Augmented Dickey-Fuller (CADF) and CIPS tests of Pesaran (2007), which are among the most popular tests around.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,statistics & probability
A Unified Approach on the Local Power of Panel Unit Root Tests

Zhongwen Liang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1710.02944

2017-10-09

Abstract:In this paper, a unified approach is proposed to derive the exact local asymptotic power for panel unit root tests, which is one of the most important issues in nonstationary panel data literature. Two most widely used panel unit root tests known as Levin-Lin-Chu (LLC, Levin, Lin and Chu (2002)) and Im-Pesaran-Shin (IPS, Im, Pesaran and Shin (2003)) tests are systematically studied for various situations to illustrate our method. Our approach is characteristic function based, and can be used directly in deriving the moments of the asymptotic distributions of these test statistics under the null and the local-to-unity alternatives. For the LLC test, the approach provides an alternative way to obtain the results that can be derived by the existing method. For the IPS test, the new results are obtained, which fills the gap in the literature where few results exist, since the IPS test is non-admissible. Moreover, our approach has the advantage in deriving Edgeworth expansions of these tests, which are also given in the paper. The simulations are presented to illustrate our theoretical findings.

Econometrics,Computation,Methodology
Testing for Structural Changes in Large Dimensional Factor Models via Discrete Fourier Transform

Zhonghao Fu,Yongmiao Hong,Xia Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3559936

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We propose a new test for structural changes in large dimensional factor models via a discrete Fourier transform (DFT) approach. If structural changes occur, the conventional principal component analysis fails to estimate common factors and factor loadings consistently. The estimated residuals will contain information about structural changes. Therefore, we can compare the DFT of the estimated residuals with the null (zero) spectrum implied by no structural change. The proposed test is powerful against both smooth structural changes and abrupt structural breaks with a possibly unknown number of breaks and unknown break dates in factor loadings. It can detect a class of local alternatives at the parametric rate. As a result, the test is asymptotically more efficient than the existing tests in the factor model literature. And our test is also robust to serial and cross-sectional dependence of unknown form without having to estimate any long-run variance-covariance matrix. Moreover, it is easy to implement and tuning parameter-free. Monte Carlo studies demonstrate its reasonable size and excellent power in detecting various forms of structural changes in factor loadings. In an application to the U.S. macroeconomic data, we find significant and robust evidence of time-varying factor loadings.
TESTING FOR STRUCTURAL CHANGES IN FACTOR MODELS VIA A NONPARAMETRIC REGRESSION

Liangjun Su,Xia Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0266466619000446

IF: 1.968

2020-05-12

Econometric Theory

Abstract:We propose a model-free test for structural changes in factor models. The basic idea is to regress the data on commonly estimated factors by local smoothing and compare the fitted values of time-varying factor loadings with those of time-invariant factor loadings estimated via principal component analysis. By construction, the test is designed to be powerful against both smooth structural changes and sudden structural breaks with a possibly unknown number of breaks and unknown break dates in the factor loadings. No restrictions on the form of alternatives or trimming of boundary regions near the beginning or end of the sample period is required for the test. The test has power to detect the usual nonparametric rate of local alternatives. Monte Carlo studies demonstrate excellent power of the test in detecting both smooth and sudden structural changes in the factor loadings. In an application using U.S. asset returns, we find significant evidence against time-invariant factor loadings.

Economics,Mathematics
Characteristic Function-Based Testing for Multifactor Continuous-Time Markov Models Via Nonparametric Regression

Bin Chen,Yongmiao Hong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s026646660999048x

IF: 1.968

2010-01-01

Econometric Theory

Abstract:We develop a nonparametric regression-based goodness-of-fit test for multifactor continuous-time Markov models using the conditional characteristic function, which often has a convenient closed form or can be approximated accurately for many popular continuous-time Markov models in economics and finance. An omnibus test fully utilizes the information in the joint conditional distribution of the underlying processes and hence has power against a vast class of continuous-time alternatives in the multifactor framework. A class of easy-to-interpret diagnostic procedures is also proposed to gauge possible sources of model misspecification. All the proposed test statistics have a convenient asymptotic N (0, 1) distribution under correct model specification, and all asymptotic results allow for some data-dependent bandwidth. Simulations show that in finite samples, our tests have reasonable size, thanks to the dimension reduction in nonparametric regression, and good power against a variety of alternatives, including misspecifications in the joint dynamics, but the dynamics of each individual component is correctly specified. This feature is not attainable by some existing tests. A parametric bootstrap improves the finite-sample performance of proposed tests but with a higher computational cost.
Panel Data Unit Root testing: Overview

Anton Skrobotov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2408.08908

2024-08-13

Abstract:This review discusses methods of testing for a panel unit root. Modern approaches to testing in cross-sectionally correlated panels are discussed, preceding the analysis with an analysis of independent panels. In addition, methods for testing in the case of non-linearity in the data (for example, in the case of structural breaks) are presented, as well as methods for testing in short panels, when the time dimension is small and finite. In conclusion, links to existing packages that allow implementing some of the described methods are provided.

Econometrics
A Robust Residual-Based Test for Structural Changes in Factor Models

Bin Peng,Liangjun Su,Yayi Yan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2406.00941

2024-06-03

Abstract:In this paper, we propose an easy-to-implement residual-based specification testing procedure for detecting structural changes in factor models, which is powerful against both smooth and abrupt structural changes with unknown break dates. The proposed test is robust against the over-specified number of factors, and serially and cross-sectionally correlated error processes. A new central limit theorem is given for the quadratic forms of panel data with dependence over both dimensions, thereby filling a gap in the literature. We establish the asymptotic properties of the proposed test statistic, and accordingly develop a simulation-based scheme to select critical value in order to improve finite sample performance. Through extensive simulations and a real-world application, we confirm our theoretical results and demonstrate that the proposed test exhibits desirable size and power in practice.

Econometrics
A new approach for analyzing panel AR(1) series with application to the unit root test

Yu-Pin Hu,J. T. Gene Hwang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1509.06442

2015-09-22

Statistics Theory

Abstract:This paper derives several novel tests to improve on the t-test for testing AR(1) coefficients of panel time series, i.e., of multiple time series, when each has a small number of observations. These tests can determine the acceptance or the rejection of each hypothesis individually while controlling the average type one error. Strikingly, the testing statistics derived by the empirical Bayes approach can be approximated by a simple form similar to the t-statistic; the only difference is that the means and the variances are estimated by shrinkage estimators. Simulations demonstrate that the proposed tests have higher average power than the t-test in all settings we examine including those when the priors are miss-specified and the cross section series are dependent.
New Test of Asset Pricing Models in China

Hai Lin,Yongmiao Hong

2013-01-01

Abstract:Asset Pricing is a longstanding problem in finance. In this paper, we evaluate both the one factor model and the Fama-French three factor model for the Chinese capital market from 1997-2004. The model specifications include (i) without an intercept, (ii) with an intercept and (iii) with a jump component. A generalized spectral derivative test recently proposed by Hong and Lee (2005a, 2005b) is used for model specification analysis. The empirical results show that the intercept does not help improve the goodness of fit for both one factor and three factor models. Moreover, it cannot reduce the model specification error either. Although jump factors could greatly improve the goodness of fit of asset pricing models, it has little impact on reducing the specification errors. BM and SIZE factors could efficiently improve the goodness of fit of asset pricing models and reduce the specification error, indicating that BM and HML are important for explaining the change of stock returns. However, not all portfolios passed the Hong and Lee (2005a, 2005b) test. There exist some unexplained parts in Chinese stock returns. Other risk factors or nonlinear return relationships should be considered to explain Chinese capital asset returns.
Testing for Smooth Structural Changes in Time Series Models via Nonparametric Regression

Bin Chen,Yongmiao Hong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3982/ECTA7990

IF: 6.1

2012-01-01

Econometrica

Abstract:Checking parameter stability of econometric models is a long-standing problem. Almost all existing structural change tests in econometrics are designed to detect abrupt breaks. Little attention has been paid to smooth structural changes, which may be more realistic in economics. We propose a consistent test for smooth structural changes as well as abrupt structural breaks with known or unknown change points. The idea is to estimate smooth time-varying parameters by local smoothing and compare the fitted values of the restricted constant parameter model and the unrestricted time-varying parameter model. The test is asymptotically pivotal and does not require prior information about the alternative. A simulation study highlights the merits of the proposed test relative to a variety of popular tests for structural changes. In an application, we strongly reject the stability of univariate and multivariate stock return prediction models in the postwar and post-oil-shocks periods.
Estimation for Unit Root Testing

Dimitrios V. Vougas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1310.1878

2013-10-19

Abstract:We revisit estimation and computation of the Dickey Fuller (DF) and DF-type tests. Firstly, we show that the usual one step approach, based on the "DF autoregression", is likely to be subject to misspecification. Secondly, we clarify a neglected two step approach for estimation of the DF test. (In fact, we introduce a new two step DF autoregression.) This method is always correctly specified and efficient under the circumstances. However, it is either neglected or misused in unit root testing literature. The commonly employed hybrid of the (correct) two step method is shown to be inefficient, even asymptotically. Finally, we further improve/robustify the proposed two step method by employing the missing initial observations. Our finally proposed method is to be used in unit root testing, since it is a new DF autoregression that retains the missing observations.

Methodology,Computation
Testing High-Dimensional Linear Asset Pricing Models

Wei Lan,Long Feng,Ronghua Luo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jjfinec/nby002

IF: 3.976

2018-01-01

Journal of Financial Econometrics

Abstract:We propose in this article a new procedure, based on random projections, for testing widely used linear asset pricing models (Sharpe, 1964; Linter, 1965; Fama and French, 1993). This new testing procedure is particularly suitable when the number of assets N is much larger than the number of observations T, and outperforms the existing methods by admitting the covariance matrix of the idiosyncratic term to be nonsparse. Under some mild conditions, we show theoretically that the test statistic is asymptotically normal as long as min⁡{N,T} goes to infinity. The finite sample performance is investigated by extensive Monte Carlo experiments. The practical utility of the new testing procedure is further justified by treating the U.S. stock market. Employing this new testing procedure, we found that the Fama–French (FF) three-factor model (Fama and French, 1993) is better than the capital asset pricing model (Sharpe, 1964) in explaining the mean–variance efficiency of the U.S. stock market.
A generalized nonlinear IV unit root test for panel data with cross-sectional dependence

Shaoping Wang,Peng Wang,Jisheng Yang,Zinai Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeconom.2009.10.034

IF: 3.363

2010-01-01

Journal of Econometrics

Abstract:This paper proposes a unit root test for panel data with cross-sectional dependence. The test generalizes the nonlinear IV unit root test of Chang (2002) to the case where there exist some common factors in panels. The main idea is to eliminate the cross-sectional dependence through the method of principal components as in Bai and Ng (2004) and then apply Chang’s test to the treated data. Under certain conditions, the proposed test is consistent and has a standard normal limiting distribution under the null hypothesis. Simulation results show that the proposed test compares favorably to other alternative tests.
A unit root test based on smooth transitions and nonlinear adjustment

Aycan Hepsag

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03610918.2018.1563154

2019-01-31

Abstract:In this paper, we develop a new unit root testing procedure which considers jointly for structural breaks and nonlinear adjustment. The structural breaks are modeled by means of a logistic smooth transition function and nonlinear adjustment is modeled by means of an ESTAR model. The empirical size of test is quite close to the nominal one and in terms of power; the new unit root test is generally superior to the alternative test. The new unit root test presents good size properties and does not lead to over-rejections of the null hypothesis of the unit root.
Inference In Partially Identified Panel Data Models With Interactive Fixed Effects

Shengjie Hong,Liangjun Su,Yaqi Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0266466623000403

IF: 1.968

2024-01-20

Econometric Theory

Abstract:In this paper, we develop methods for statistical inferences in a partially identified nonparametric panel data model with endogeneity and interactive fixed effects. Under some normalization rules, we can concentrate out the large-dimensional parameter vector of factor loadings and specify a set of conditional moment restrictions that are involved with only the finite-dimensional factor parameters along with the infinite-dimensional nonparametric component. For a conjectured restriction on the parameter, we consider testing the null hypothesis that the restriction is satisfied by at least one element in the identified set and propose a test statistic based on a novel martingale difference divergence measure for the distance between a conditional expectation object and zero. We derive a tight asymptotic distributional upper bound for the resultant test statistic under the null and show that it is divergent at rate-N under the global alternative. To obtain the critical values for our test, we propose a version of multiplier bootstrap and establish its asymptotic validity. Simulations demonstrate the finite sample properties of our inference procedure. We apply our method to study Engel curves for major nondurable expenditures in China by using a panel dataset from the China Family Panel Studies.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,statistics & probability
Varying-Coefficient Panel Data Models With Nonstationarity and Partially Observed Factor Structure

Chaohua Dong,Jiti Gao,Bin Peng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07350015.2020.1721294

2020-02-21

Journal of Business and Economic Statistics

Abstract:In this article, we study a varying-coefficient panel data model with both nonstationarity and partially observed factor structure. Two approaches are proposed. The first approach proposed in the main text considers a sieve based method to estimate the unknown coefficients as well as the factors and loading functions simultaneously, while the second approach proposed in the online supplementary document involving the principal component analysis provides an alternative estimation method. We establish asymptotic properties for them, compare the asymptotic efficiency of the two estimation methods and examine the theoretical findings through extensive Monte Carlo simulations. In an empirical study, we use our newly proposed model and the first method to study the returns to scale of large U.S. commercial banks, where some overlooked modeling issues in the literature of production econometrics are addressed. Supplementary materials for this article are available online.

statistics & probability,social sciences, mathematical methods,economics
Panel Unit Roots Test of PPP

徐剑刚,唐国兴

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.0427-7104.2001.06.015

2001-01-01

Abstract:With 23 OECD exchange rate data from the post-Bretton Woods period,a unit root in most of real exchange rates by using ADF and PP unit root tests is found.The main reason is that ADF and PP tests lack of test power.Using LL and IPS panel unit root test,mean reverting behavior is observed in the real exchange rate series in all the countries and long run purchasing power parity holds in the long run.
Sieve Bootstrap for Fixed-b Phillips–Perron Unit Root Test

Zhenxin Wang,Shaoping Wang,Yayi Yan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10614-024-10553-0

IF: 1.741

2024-02-20

Computational Economics

Abstract:This paper extends the fixed- b Phillips–Perron unit root test, namely PP(fb), by using a sieve bootstrap method to deal with serial-correlated errors, especially negative moving average errors. We derive the asymptotic distribution of the proposed test statistics. Our simulation results show that the test substantially improves the size performance without losing power when the error innovations have negative autoregressive or moving average components. Applying the test to both the inflation rates in the U.S. and the Chinese stock market index, we find that the inflation follows a random walk process, just as the Chinese stock market does.

economics,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,management

A Monte Carlo Comparison of Panel Unit Root Tests under Factor Structure

Asymptotically Uniformly Most Powerful Tests For Unit Roots In Gaussian Panels With Cross-Sectional Dependence Generated By Common Factors

Unit Root Test in Panel Data Basing on the Limiting Spectral Distribution of Large-Dimensional Random Matrix

The Local Power of the CADF and CIPS Panel Unit Root Tests

A Unified Approach on the Local Power of Panel Unit Root Tests

Testing for Structural Changes in Large Dimensional Factor Models via Discrete Fourier Transform

TESTING FOR STRUCTURAL CHANGES IN FACTOR MODELS VIA A NONPARAMETRIC REGRESSION

Characteristic Function-Based Testing for Multifactor Continuous-Time Markov Models Via Nonparametric Regression

Panel Data Unit Root testing: Overview

A Robust Residual-Based Test for Structural Changes in Factor Models

A new approach for analyzing panel AR(1) series with application to the unit root test

New Test of Asset Pricing Models in China

Testing for Smooth Structural Changes in Time Series Models via Nonparametric Regression

Estimation for Unit Root Testing

Testing High-Dimensional Linear Asset Pricing Models

A generalized nonlinear IV unit root test for panel data with cross-sectional dependence

A unit root test based on smooth transitions and nonlinear adjustment

Inference In Partially Identified Panel Data Models With Interactive Fixed Effects

Varying-Coefficient Panel Data Models With Nonstationarity and Partially Observed Factor Structure

Panel Unit Roots Test of PPP

Sieve Bootstrap for Fixed-b Phillips–Perron Unit Root Test