Abstract:As an important indicator of plant photosynthetic activity, leaf chlorophyll content (LCC) has often been estimated non-destructively in the past decades from reflectance spectra measured with various spectrometers and leaf-holding accessories. Most studies established LCC predictive models with either integrating sphere measured directional-hemispherical reflectance factor (DHRF) spectra or leaf clip measured bidirectional reflectance factor (BRF) spectra. Given the effect of specular reflection on leaf reflectance, it remains unclear how DHRF spectra differ from the corresponding BRF spectra and whether the derived predictive models could be transferred between these two types of spectral data. To fill the gap in spectral examination and model comparison, this study aimed to examine the effect of specular reflection on leaf reflectance properties, the commonly used spectral indices or indicators, and the derived regression models across a broad variety of leaf DHRF and BRF spectra. Specifically, we quantified the difference between leaf BRF and DHRF spectra measurements and evaluated the effect of specular reflection on the estimation of LCC with 20 spectral features in four categories (simple ratio, SR; modified SR, mSR; double difference index, DD and red edge position, REP). Seven measured datasets collected from a combination of species, growing conditions, sites, and years were used to evaluate the model difference and calibrate the unified models across DHRF and BRF spectra. The robustness of those predictive models was validated with independent measured and simulated datasets comprised of both BRF and DHRF spectra. Our results demonstrated that the BRF spectra exhibited systematically higher amplitude than DHRF spectra. The widely used vegetation indices (VIs) in the SR category exhibited the most noticeable sensitivity to specular reflection as a significant proportion in BRF spectra. The adverse effect of specular reflection can be alleviated by the other three categories to different extents. With further assessment of model comparisons, we determined four unified models from the pooled data with two DD indices and two REP metrics. Application of the unified models to the validation spectra yielded low RMSE values up to 4.5 mu g/cm(2) and would not result in a significant loss in accuracy as compared to the BRF-specific or DHRF-specific LCC predictive models derived from the four spectral features. The assessment of unified models with comprehensive measured and simulated data could help us better understand the mechanism underlying the specular reflection effect on the relationship of LCC with sensitive spectral features. It will also facilitate the direct estimation of LCC with the common types of leaf reflectance spectra, which is beneficial to rapid and non-destructive determination of LCC for the plant science and agronomy communities.

Effective models for correlating spectral reflectance between spectrophotometers

Eliminating Material Dependency in Spectra Measurement Via Non‐neighbouring Band Regression

Spectral-information-divergence based local pls modeling algorithm in near infrared spectroscopy

Empirical Model for Matching Spectrophotometric Reflectance of Yarn Windings and Multispectral Imaging Reflectance of Single Strands of Yarns.

Estimation of Spectral Reflectance Using Color Scanner

Correcting Cross-Media Instrument Metamerism for Reflectance Estimation in Multispectral Imaging.

Maintaining the Predictive Abilities of Tea Moisture Content Models on Different Environment Based on Visible and Near-Infrared Spectroscopy Technique

Experiment Measurement and Research of Bidirectional Reflectance Distribution for Cement and Asphalt Surface

Assessment of Unified Models for Estimating Leaf Chlorophyll Content Across Directional-Hemispherical Reflectance and Bidirectional Reflectance Spectra

Calibrating Spectrophotometers Using Neural Networks

Effective Correction Modeling Between Colorimetric Datasets.

Training Data Selection Study for Surface Colour Measurement Data Correlation.

Testing Methods to Estimate Spectral Reflectance Using Datasets under Different Illuminants

The Near Infrared Spectral Bands Optimal Selection in the Application of Liquor Fermented Grains Composition Analysis]

Modified Model of Color Spectrophotometer SCI Condition Based on Gloss Analysis

Spectral Representation of Object Colours

Spectral Reconstruction Using an Iteratively Reweighted Regulated Model from Two Illumination Camera Responses

Model Robustness Improvement by Absorption and Reduced Scattering Spectra in Short Wave Near Infrared Spectral Region

Stochastic Model for Quantifying Effect of Surface Roughness on Light Reflection by Diffuse Reflectance Standards

Modeling and Analysis of Reflectance Integrating Sphere

Evaluation of Spectral Pretreatments, Spectral Range, and Regression Methods for Quantitative Spectroscopic Analysis of Soil Organic Carbon Composition