Abstract:BACKGROUND:Dairy cattle production systems are mostly based on purebreds, but recently the use of crossbreeding has received increased interest. For genetic evaluations including crossbreds, several methods based on single-step genomic best linear unbiased prediction (ssGBLUP) have been proposed, including metafounder ssGBLUP (MF-ssGBLUP) and breed-specific ssGBLUP (BS-ssGBLUP). Ideally, models that account for breed effects should perform better than simple models, but knowledge on the performance of these methods is lacking for two-way crossbred cattle. In addition, the differences in the estimates of genetic parameters (such as the genetic variance component and heritability) between these methods have rarely been investigated. Therefore, the aims of this study were to (1) compare the estimates of genetic parameters for average daily gain (ADG) and feed conversion ratio (FCR) between these methods; and (2) evaluate the impact of these methods on the predictive ability for crossbred performance.METHODS:Bivariate models using standard ssGBLUP, MF-ssGBLUP and BS-ssGBLUP for the genetic evaluation of ADG and FCR were investigated. To measure the predictive ability of these three methods, we estimated four estimators, bias, dispersion, population accuracy and ratio of population accuracies, using the linear regression (LR) method.RESULTS:The results show that, for both ADG and FCR, the heritabilities were low with the three methods. For FCR, the differences in the estimated genetic parameters were small between the three methods, while for ADG, those estimated with BS-ssGBLUP deviated largely from those estimated with the other two methods. Bias and dispersion were similar across the three methods. Population accuracies for both ADG and FCR were always higher with MF-ssGBLUP than with ssGBLUP, while with BS-ssGBLUP the population accuracy was highest for FCR and lowest for ADG.CONCLUSIONS:Our results indicate that in the genetic evaluation for crossbred performance in a two-way crossbred cattle production system, the predictive ability of MF-ssGBLUP and BS-ssGBLUP is greater than that of ssGBLUP, when the estimated variance components are consistent across the three methods. Compared with BS-ssGBLUP, MF-ssGBLUP is more robust in its superiority over ssGBLUP.

Genetic Parameters Estimates for Locomotion Score, Body Condition Score and Final Type Score of Holstein Cattle in Southern China

Genetic Parameter Estimation for Locomotion Score in China Holstein Cattle

Correlation Analysis between Body Condition Score and Locomotion Score in China Holstein Cattle

Genetic Parameter Estimates for Body Conformation Traits Using Composite Index, Principal Component, and Factor Analysis.

Estimation of Genetic Parameters for Body Weight in Chinese Simmental Cattle Using Random Regression Model

Genetic Parameters for Somatic Cell Score and Production Traits in the First Three Lactations of Chinese Holstein Cows

Estimation of genetic parameters for fertility traits in Chinese Holstein of south China

Factor Analysis of Genetic Parameters for Body Conformation Traits in Dual-Purpose Simmental Cattle

Estimation of Genetic Parameters of Fertility Traits in Chinese Holstein Cattle

Estimation of Genetic Parameters for Reproductive Traits in Connectedness Groups of Duroc, Landrace and Yorkshire Pigs in China.

299 Genetic Analysis of Temperament and Its Correlation with Production, Reproduction, Type, Health and Longevity in Chinese Holstein

Estimation of Genetic Parameters for Conformation Traits and Milk Production Traits in Chinese Holsteins.

Genetic Parameters for Health Traits and Their Association with Fertility and Milk Production in Chinese Holsteins.

Heritability estimation of dairy cows using optimal spline curves in southern area of China

Genetic Parameter Estimation for Figure Traits of Holstein Cattle in Wuhan

Effect of Body Condition Score and Locomotion Score on the Production Performance in Dairy Cows

The Estimation of Genetic Parameters of Holstein Dairy Cows in Ningxia Region

Comparison of Heritability and Genetic Correlation for Milk Yields of First and Second-Lactation Shanghai Holstein Cows

Genetic Analysis of Skinfold Thickness and Its Association with Body Condition Score and Milk Production Traits in Chinese Holstein Population.

Genomic Evaluation for Two-Way Crossbred Performance in Cattle.

Genetic parameters and genome-wide association for milk production traits and somatic cell score in different lactation stages of Shanghai Holstein population