Abstract:Accurate clearance time prediction for road incident would be helpful to evaluate the incident impacting range and provide route guiding strategy according to the predicted results, and thus reduce the travel delays caused by incidents. Currently, a number of approaches have been developed for predicting incident clearance time and investigating the effects of influential factors. Statistical and machine learning methods are the two major methodological approaches. This study aims to make a methodology review for these methods by comprehensively examining their performance in incident clearance time prediction, especially, when omitted variables present significant impacts on selected variables. Specifically, we consider four widely used statistical models: Accelerated Failure Time (AFT) model, Quantile Regression (QR) model, Finite Mixture (FM) model, and Random Parameters Hazard-Based Duration (RPHD) model, and four machine learning models: K-Nearest Neighbor (KNN) model, Support Vector Machine (SVM) model, Back Propagation Neural Network (BPNN) model, and Random Forest (RF) model as candidates. Moreover, the abilities of these methods in uncovering the underlying causality (explaining the causal effects of significant influential factors on clearance time) are also investigated. Incident clearance time data was collected on freeway road sections in Seattle, Washington State from 2009 to 2011. The conclusions can be summarized as follows: 1) the RF model and RPHD model outperform the other three models in data fitting and model prediction in their respective methodological categories; 2) three “heterogeneity” methods including RPHD, FM and QR outperform machine learning methods in model prediction as measured by MAPE; 3) machine learning methods perform stably in model prediction relative to the statistical methods; 4) incident type and lane closure type present significant effects on incident clearance time in all eight selected models.

A Methodology for Freeway Incident Duration Prediction Using Computerized Historical Database

Applying Survival Analysis Approach to Traffic Incident Duration Prediction

Traffic Incident Duration Analysis and Prediction Models Based on the Survival Analysis Approach

Estimating freeway incident duration using accelerated failure time modeling

Incident Duration Modeling Using Flexible Parametric Hazard-Based Models

Incident Duration Model on Urban Freeways Based on Discrete Choice Model

Prediction of Freeway Traffic Incident Delay Based on Simulation

Incident duration model on urban freeways using Ordered Probit Model

APPLICATION OF NONPARAMETRIC REGRESSION IN PREDICTING TRAFFIC INCIDENT DURATION

Prediction of urban expressway total traffic accident duration based on multiple linear regression and artificial neural network

A Hybrid Approach for Urban Expressway Traffic Incident Duration Prediction with Cox Regression and Random Survival Forests Models

Analysis of Regression Method on Traffic Incident Duration Prediction

Traffic Incident Duration Forecast Model of Expressway

An Improved Model of Accident Prediction on Freeways Based on Fuzzy Logic

Freeway Accident Likelihood Prediction Using a Panel Data Analysis Approach

A Comparative Study of Prediction Models on the Duration of Traffic Incidents

Fitting Distribution of Freeway Incident Duration and Accelerated Failure Time Modeling

Statistical and Machine-Learning Methods for Clearance Time Prediction of Road Incidents: A Methodology Review

A Real-hime Prediction Model for Rear-end Crash on Two-lane Freeway

Prediction of Obstacle Clearance Duration of Freeway

A Review of the Traffic Incident Duration Prediction Methods