Environmental Governance in China: Interactions Between the State and "nonstate Actors".
Dan Guttman,Oran Young,Yijia Jing,Barbara Bramble,Maoliang Bu,Carmen Chen,Kathinka Furst,Tao Hu,Yifei Li,Kate Logan,Lingxuan Liu,Lydia Price,Michael Spencer,Sangwon Suh,Xiaopu Sun,Bowen Tan,Harold Wang,Xin Wang,Juan Zhang,Xinxin Zhang,Rodrigo Zeidan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2018.04.104
IF: 8.7
2018-01-01
Journal of Environmental Management
Abstract:In the West, limited government capacity to solve environmental problems has triggered the rise of a variety of "nonstate actors" to supplement government efforts or provide alternative mechanisms for addressing environmental issues. How does this development - along with our efforts to understand it - map onto environmental governance processes in China? China's efforts to address environmental issues reflect institutionalized governance processes that differ from parallel western processes in ways that have major consequences for domestic environmental governance practices and the governance of China "going abroad." China's governance processes blur the distinction between the state and other actors; the "shadow of the state" is a major factor in all efforts to address environmental issues. The space occupied by nonstate actors in western systems is occupied by shiye danwei ("public service units"), she hui tuanti ("social associations") and e-platforms, all of which have close links to the state. Meanwhile, international NGOs and multinational corporations are also significant players in China. As a result, the mechanisms of influence that produce effects in China differ in important ways from mechanisms familiar from the western experience. This conclusion has far-reaching implications for those seeking to address global environmental concerns, given the importance of China's growing economy and burgeoning network of trade relationships.