Budget Constraints , Market Opportunities and Off-Budget Financing of Local Governments in China
G. Nathan Dong,Zigan Wang
2018-01-01
Abstract:High uncertainty in tax-based revenue sources in developing countries is often considered a key factor behind local fiscal deficits. Concerns often arise about whether local officials can use their administrative discretion in public asset management to obtain off-budget revenue to help relieve fiscal stress. This paper studies how budget constraints and market opportunities affect off-budget financing using local public assets in the context of China. Land is one of the most valuable public assets within local jurisdictions in China and local officials have the flexibility and discretion in acquiring, developing and selling land for commercial and residential use. Using local fiscal and land-sale data of 35 Chinese cities between 2003 and 2015, this study estimates a supply and demand model that captures both the determinants and market outcomes of a city’s decision to sell land-use rights to real estate developers. The results demonstrate the important effect of local fiscal conditions and a booming real estate market on the use of land sales as a financing tool. A 10% increase in fiscal deficits leads to approximately a 13% increase in land sales and the effect of a 10% increase in real estate prices is an 8.2% increase in land sales. Keyword: Economic development, Local government deficit, land sales, real estate price JEL Code: O18, H71, R28 * Dept. of Health, Policy and Management, Columbia University. 722 W 168th Street, New York, NY 10032. Tel: 212342-0490. E-mail: gd2243@columbia.edu † School of Economics and Finance, University of Hong Kong. E-mail: wangzg@hku.hk We thank Loren Brandt, Ljubica Djordjevic, Michael Funke, Iftekhar Hasan, Fred YK Kwan, Chun-Yu Ho, Takashi Matsuki, Paul McNelis, Pedro Pinto, Kjetil Storesletten, Rongrong Sun, Dragon Tang, Kunyu Tao, Wei Xiong, Eleanor Xu, Yushi Yoshida, Jeffrey Zax, Bo Zhao, and participants at the Association for Budgeting & Financial Management (ABFM) Annual Research Conference (University of Seattle), Conference on China’s Financial Markets and Growth Rebalancing (Fordham University), Conference on Deepening Economic Reforms (Peking University & Stockholm School of Economics), Conference on Finance and Economic Growth in the Aftermath of the Crisis (University of Milan), Conference on Risk in Economics and Society (Shiga University), and National Tax Association Annual Conference (Boston) for helpful comments.