A Comparative Analysis of Low Carbon City Planning in China and Abroad

CAI Qin,HUANG Jing,QI Ye

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-3862.2013.06.001

2013-01-01

Abstract:Many cities in the world chose to develop low carbon city in response to climate change,environmental degradation and energy shortage,and these cities started with development of low city plans.Despite many similarities among the low carbon city plans,distinct features can be identified about the low carbon city plans in China as compared to those in developed countries.The differences are shown mainly in motivations,objectives,activities,and measures and policy instruments for implementation.The Western cities are motivated by their legal obligation for climate mitigation under the UNFCCC and the Kyoto Protocol,and by their visions for future non-fossil energy basis as well as preparation for future economic competitiveness.But the Chinese cities aim at economic growth with greater energy efficiency.Thus,the former are more proactive in taking actions and more ambitious in setting target for carbon reduction,while the latter more cautious in fearing of the consequences of performance evaluation against their targets.While Western cities focus on buildings,transport,and waste management,Chinese low carbon city plan are much more comprehensive,especially focusing on industrial sectors,reflecting the differences in functions of the governments between China and the West.Market-based policy tools are used more frequently in implementation of the low carbon city plans in the West,as distinct contrast to those in China where administrative measures and government-sponsored programs and projects are more often employed.