Effectiveness Research on Public Participation in Environmental Governance Based on P-S-A Three-tier Model

薛澜,董秀海
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-2104.2010.10.009
2010-01-01
China Population Resources and Environment
Abstract:In China,public participation has become a popular subject in environmental governance area.Stakeholders put more hope on public participation particularly in recent years when environmental accidents and extreme weather events took place more frequently.Consequently,it is a timely and important issue to study the effectiveness of public participation in environmental governance.Based on the supervision and incentive theories of New Institutional Economics,a P-S-A three-tier model was built in this paper where P represented principal(the Government),S represented supervisor(the Public),and A represented agency(the Enterprises).The paper examined and compared the governance results in various scenarios: no public participation,Iow-type-tech supervising,high-type-tech supervising,and public participation with the rights to claim damage.The following conclusions were drawn in the end: flexible incentive arrangement and governance skills are necessary conditions;Iow-type-tech supervising such as reporting corporate allegations of illegal emission would have crowding-out effects on government supervision which may lead to a not-so-good result for the society as a whole;high-type-tech supervising on companies or projects,such as public participation in environmental impact assessment,can effectively improve environmental governance performance;finally,giving general public the rights to claim environmental damage is a fundamental way to change the current situation of soft constrain.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?