Donghai Wu,Philippe Ciais,Nicolas Viovy,Alan K. Knapp,Kevin Wilcox,Michael Bahn,Melinda D. Smith,Sara Vicca,Simone Fatichi,Jakob Zscheischler,Yue He,Xiangyi Li,Akihiko Ito,Almut Arneth,Anna Harper,Anna Ukkola,Athanasios Paschalis,Benjamin Poulter,Changhui Peng,Daniel Ricciuto,David Reinthaler,Guangsheng Chen,Hanqin Tian,Helene Genet,Jiafu Mao,Johannes Ingrisch,Julia E. S. M. Nabel,Julia Pongratz,Lena R. Boysen,Markus Kautz,Michael Schmitt,Patrick Meir,Qiuan Zhu,Roland Hasibeder,Sebastian Sippel,Shree R. S. Dangal,Stephen Sitch,Xiaoying Shi,Yingping Wang,Yiqi Luo,Yongwen Liu,Shilong Piao

Abstract:Field measurements of aboveground net primary productivity (ANPP) in temperate grasslands suggest that both positive and negative asymmetric responses to changes in precipitation (P) may occur. Under normal range of precipitation variability, wet years typically result in ANPP gains being larger than ANPP declines in dry years (positive asymmetry), whereas increases in ANPP are lower in magnitude in extreme wet years compared to reductions during extreme drought (negative asymmetry). Whether the current generation of ecosystem models with a coupled carbon–water system in grasslands are capable of simulating these asymmetric ANPP responses is an unresolved question. In this study, we evaluated the simulated responses of temperate grassland primary productivity to scenarios of altered precipitation with 14 ecosystem models at three sites: Shortgrass steppe (SGS), Konza Prairie (KNZ) and Stubai Valley meadow (STU), spanning a rainfall gradient from dry to moist. We found that (1) the spatial slopes derived from modeled primary productivity and precipitation across sites were steeper than the temporal slopes obtained from inter-annual variations, which was consistent with empirical data; (2) the asymmetry of the responses of modeled primary productivity under normal inter-annual precipitation variability differed among models, and the mean of the model ensemble suggested a negative asymmetry across the three sites, which was contrary to empirical evidence based on filed observations; (3) the mean sensitivity of modeled productivity to rainfall suggested greater negative response with reduced precipitation than positive response to an increased precipitation under extreme conditions at the three sites; and (4) gross primary productivity (GPP), net primary productivity (NPP), aboveground NPP (ANPP) and belowground NPP (BNPP) all showed concave-down nonlinear responses to altered precipitation in all the models, but with different curvatures and mean values. Our results indicated that most models overestimate the negative drought effects and/or underestimate the positive effects of increased precipitation on primary productivity under normal climate conditions, highlighting the need for improving eco-hydrological processes in those models in the future.

Relationship Between Variability in Aboveground Net Primary Production and Precipitation in Global Grasslands

Growing Season Precipitation Rather Than Growing Season Length Predominates Maximum Normalized Difference Vegetation Index in Alpine Grasslands on the Tibetan Plateau

Interannual Variability in Net Primary Production and Precipitation.

Global Patterns and Climatic Drivers of Above- and Belowground Net Primary Productivity in Grasslands.

Changes in productivity partitioning induced by precipitation extremes increase inaccuracy of grassland carbon estimation

Global pattern and associated drivers of grassland productivity sensitivity to precipitation change

Precipitation and soil nutrients determine the spatial variability of grassland productivity at large scales in China

Aridity-dependent resistance but strong resilience of grassland aboveground net primary productivity: evidence from long-term naturally occurring extreme precipitation events

Climate Change Alters Interannual Variation of Grassland Aboveground Productivity: Evidence from A 22-Year Measurement Series in the Inner Mongolian Grassland

Divergent responses of primary production to increasing precipitation variability in global drylands

Environmental factors covary with plant diversity-productivity relationships among Chinese grassland sites

Grassland gross carbon dioxide uptake based on an improved model tree ensemble approach considering human interventions: global estimation and covariation with climate

Interannual precipitation variability dominates the growth of alpine grassland above-ground biomass at high elevations on the Tibetan Plateau

Inter-annual Precipitation Fluctuations Alter the Responses of Above- and Belowground Biomass to Water and N Enrichment

Field‐based Estimation of Net Primary Productivity and Its Above‐ and Belowground Partitioning in Global Grasslands

Evaluating the responses of net primary productivity and carbon use efficiency of global grassland to climate variability along an aridity gradient

Legacies of precipitation fluctuations on primary production: theory and data synthesis

The Change in Environmental Variables Linked to Climate Change Has a Stronger Effect on Aboveground Net Primary Productivity Than Does Phenological Change in Alpine Grasslands

Field-based Observations of Regional-Scale, Temporal Variation in Net Primary Production in Tibetan Alpine Grasslands

Diverse chronic responses of vegetation aboveground net primary productivity to climatic changes on Three-River Headwaters region

Asymmetric Responses of Primary Productivity to Altered Precipitation Simulated by Ecosystem Models Across Three Longterm Grassland Sites