Abstract:Terrestrial ecosystems play a major role in the interannual variability of the global carbon budget representing a substantial sink equivalent to about one-third of current anthropogenic CO2 emissions (Le Quéré et al., 2018). Therefore, it is vital to understand how plants and vegetation respond to the impacts of climate extremes as this impacts the productivity terrestrial ecosystems. The conterminous United States (CONUS) represent a diverse range of climate conditions and ecosystems where productivity and its interannual variability are controlled regionally by rainfall and/or temperature. The responses of ecosystem productivity to wet and dry years have been previously investigated over the CONUS using annual aboveground net primary productivity (ANPP) data from multi-site observations (Knapp and Smith, 2001). From this previous study, a positive asymmetry of ANPP in response to rainfall anomalies was found at individual sites (i.e. an increase of ANPP in wet years was greater than a decline in dry years). Here, we evaluate the asymmetry of ecosystem productivity to rainfall over the entire CONUS from 2010 to 2018 using multiple data streams including: the Global Unified Gauge-Based precipitation data, the GRIDMET surface meteorological data (maximum temperature, minimum temperature, precipitation accumulation, and Palmer Drought Severity Index), the SMOS satellite L-Vegetation optical depth product, CO2 fluxes (net ecosystem exchange (NEE) & gross primary productivity (GPP)) derived from eddy covariance measurements, MODIS ANPP product, Fluxnet GPP at site scale, and three different GPP products from observation-driven models. We address the following two questions: (1) How does ecosystem productivity across the CONUS respond to rainfall anomalies during the period 2010-2018? (2) Does the evidence for positive asymmetry previously observed using site studies hold true across the entire CONUS? For this, we define an asymmetry index (AI) where positive AI indicate a greater increase of productivity in wet years compared to the decline in dry years, and negative AI indicate a greater decline of productivity in dry years compared to the increases in wet years. We find that the spatial patterns of AI across the CONUS are similar amongst the different products and exhibit more pronounced negative asymmetries over the Great Plains and the west north central region whilst positive asymmetries are observed over the southwestern USA during the 2010-2018 period. While the “shrubland” biome shows a persistent positive asymmetry during the period, the “grasslands” biome appears to have switched from positive (observed by Knapp and Smith, 2001) to negative anomalies during the last decade. The observed asymmetry of the different GPP products is reflected by the negative asymmetry of the precipitation anomalies (skewness of precipitation annual anomalies), which we conclude is the primary driver of negative asymmetry across the US continental surface.ReferencesKnapp, A.K., Smith, M.D., 2001. Variation Among Biomes in Temporal Dynamics of Aboveground Primary Production. Science (80-. ). 291, 481. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.291.5503.481Le Quéré, C., Andrew, R.M., Friedlingstein, P., Sitch, S., et al., 2018. Global Carbon Budget 2018. Earth Syst. Sci. Data 10, 2141–2194. https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-10-2141-2018

Interactive comment on “Asymmetric Responses of Primary Productivity to Altered Precipitation Simulated by Ecosystem Models across Three Long-term Grassland Sites” by

Asymmetric responses of primary productivity to precipitation extremes: A synthesis of grassland precipitation manipulation experiments

Rainfall Manipulation Experiments As Simulated by Terrestrial Biosphere Models: Where Do We Stand?

Asymmetric Response of Primary Productivity to Precipitation Anomalies in Southwest China

Nonlinear response of productivity to precipitation extremes in the Inner Mongolia grassland

Global pattern and associated drivers of grassland productivity sensitivity to precipitation change

Asymmetric responses of ecosystem productivity to rainfall anomalies vary inversely with mean annual rainfall over the conterminous United States

Changes in productivity partitioning induced by precipitation extremes increase inaccuracy of grassland carbon estimation

Photosynthetic Productivity and Its Efficiencies in ISIMIP2a Biome Models: Benchmarking for Impact Assessment Studies

Aridity-dependent resistance but strong resilience of grassland aboveground net primary productivity: evidence from long-term naturally occurring extreme precipitation events

Negative Asymmetry Response of Ecosystem Productivity to Annual Rainfall Anomalies over the Conterminous U.S During the 2010 -2018 Period

Grassland gross carbon dioxide uptake based on an improved model tree ensemble approach considering human interventions: global estimation and covariation with climate

Hydrological and Ecological Responses of Ecosystems to Extreme Precipitation Regimes: A Test of Empirical-Based Hypotheses with an Ecosystem Model

Positive Asymmetric Responses Indicate Larger Carbon Sink with Increase in Precipitation Variability in Global Terrestrial Ecosystems

Extreme Precipitation Patterns and Reductions of Terrestrial Ecosystem Production Across Biomes

Precipitation Amount, Seasonality and Frequency Regulate Carbon Cycling of a Semi-Arid Grassland Ecosystem in Inner Mongolia, China: A Modeling Analysis

Joint Structural and Physiological Control on the Interannual Variation in Productivity in a Temperate Grassland: A Data‐model Comparison

Modelled Effects Of Precipitation On Ecosystem Carbon And Water Dynamics In Different Climatic Zones

Net Primary Productivity Loss under different drought levels in different grassland ecosystems

PRODUCTIVITY OF DIFFERENT TYPES OF GRASSLAND PLOTS AND THEIR RESPONSES TO CLIMATE CHANGE IN THE SOUTHERN CHINA

Patterns and controls of vegetation productivity and precipitation-use efficiency across Eurasian grasslands