Selection of Management Innovation Types for Chinese Enterprises in Complex Context
SU Jing-qing,CUI Miao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-6062.2011.04.005
2011-01-01
Abstract:Management innovations become more and more important for modern enterprises operating in the global economy.Some enterprises even beat industry leaders by radical or incremental management innovations.Nevertheless,it is not clear about why some enterprises chose incremental management innovations,and others chose radical ones? What are key determinants of these two different decisions? Which types of management innovation should Chinese enterprises choose in the complex context? To address these questions,we first propose hypotheses based onthe technology innovation theory.Six hypotheses are proposed regard to the relationships between enterprise size,environment uncertainty,entrepreneurship and management innovation type.The case study method isadopted.The initial case study protocol isdesigned and sample cases on the principle of maximum variation and typical sampling areselected to align with hypotheses.We collect data mainly frominterviews,complemented by documents,participant observation and direct observation.Secondhand cases and materials from internet and journals are also used as the data source of other cases.We use ground theory as the data analysis method.The management innovation case of Dalian Sanyo Cold Chain Co.,Ltd.(DSC) isfirst studied due to dataaccessibility..Firstly,high correlation data arescreened out and then analyzed by opening coding,axial coding and selective coding. We identify fifteen concepts,including innovativeness,steadiness,quality-oriented strategy,common HR quality,less experienced top managers,institutional organizational culture,diversity needs,intensified competition,organization security,product innovation,high-tech management,management method innovation,management mode innovation,problem seeking and improvement.Additional seven sub-categories were discovered based on these concepts.These seven categoriesare entrepreneurship,organizational strategy,organizational culture,industrial environment,incremental technology innovation,incremental management innovation,and innovative activity.Finally,selective coding isused to identify the core category,which is incremental management innovation in DSC's case.A story clue isformed by integrating the core category and all other categories,which was testified by data collected and confirmed by top managers of DSC later.However,there isa gap between analysis results and the initial research framework.Therefore,we revise the case study protocol by adding the new variable organizational culture and complementing our findings with two additional cases. The other nine management innovation cases are studied by applying the same analytical method and scheme as the DSC case.These cases include Broad Group,Qingdao Savor Electronic Information Services Co.,Ltd.,China Petroleum Chemical Corporation,Dalian Tianyi Consultant Co.,Ltd.,Spring Air,Greefull Group,Henan Huaying Agricultural Development Co.,Ltd.,Dalian Northern International Exhibition Company,and Zhejiang Senhe Seed Co.,Ltd..Some concepts are the same as DSC's,while others new.New concepts include risk-taking,technology innovation strategy,high level HR quality,experienced top managers,innovative organizational culture,process innovation,institutional innovation,business model innovation,redesign,and so forth.And the new category is radical management innovation.All theseten cases arecompared in order to score each variable of the case study framework.Conclusion is made based on the integration of the same type of management innovation and a comparison of different types of management innovation.First,radical management innovations can only form and be implemented when the external environment uncertainty is high and entrepreneurship and innovation-oriented of organizational culture are strong;otherwise,incremental management innovations are better choices for Chinese enterprises.Second,enterprises thathave implemented or are implementing incremental management innovations under different uncertainties of external environment are forced or driven by different reasons.Enterprises operatingin the high external environment uncertainty canonly implement incremental management innovations successfully becausethe supports of their entrepreneurship and organizational cultures are less than the needs of implementation of radical management innovations.Enterprisesoperatingin low external environment uncertainty are prone to form organizational inertia due to steady market conditions.Third,entrepreneurship is the determinant of organizational culture types..Only enterprises with high entrepreneurship have chances to form innovative culture. The findings of this study can contribute to theories and practices of management innovations.Limitations of this study includelimited sample size under each dimension of research framework,fewer cases,the use of interface data for case analysis,Future study should analyze time series data which can systematically uncover determinants of management innovation types.