Media Identity Study in the Comparative Context
Qiu Ge
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2008.05.016
2008-01-01
Abstract:Media identity study considers media as a similar organism with a certain identity.It has been formed in the society's complex interaction,keeping a close and dynamic contact with society as well.In such a study much attention is paid to the concept of ″identity″,which is considered as the core value of research tools and methods.In order to make a relatively accurate assessment,it is necessary to compare this study with other related theories.Pierre Bourdieu has developed a media-field-centered new research paradigm in the sociology of journalism.They believe that the autonomy of journalism has decreased in face of the influence and penetrability that have increased in the field of economy.As the agent of the ruler's power,news media has been weakening the autonomy of other fields of cultural production,thus impairing the best social conditions for scientific knowledge production and art innovation.There is strong theoretical closeness between media identity study and media field study,but some division between the said studies in terms of the specific research process,involving research object,relative closedness of media field theory,and the more considerable relevance to Chinese issues.Media ecology is aimed at the ″study of media as an environment″.Domestic research focuses on media subsistence and morality.Media identity study and media ecology share a lot in common,such as common theoretical basis,interactive view,and complex concept of causation.Even so,media ecology,which is influenced by technological determinism,may easily ignore the value of people.Media identity makes human beings as the focus of a variety of complex interactive relations.Meanwhile,it is hoped that media identity study will,by breaking away from the inclination of media' practical survival and argument,understand and analyze contemporary media in a field of wider theoretical vision.Through a theoretical comparison between the studies,we can conclude that media identity study is a concept which,though less mature,still has its own characteristics,promising a good future.Nevertheless,however,we have to meet some challenges: to construct a wide and solid framework with rich research results;to base research upon China's media reality by looking at concrete issues;and to keep the research area open,research possibility open and research methods open.