Abstract:Motivated by a situation encountered in a real-world application of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), this paper extends previous work on improving consistency of positive reciprocal judgment matrices by optimizing their transformation into near-consistent matrices. A sampling-optimization-adjustment approach is proposed and integrated into the Monte Carlo AHP framework, allowing it to deal with situations where no or insufficient distinct near-consistent matrices can be generated by directly sampling from the original pairwise comparison distributions – a situation that prohibits meaningful statistical analysis and effective decision-making using the traditional Monte Carlo AHP. Three mixed-integer nonlinear programing models are formulated for minimizing the sum of adjustments, maximum adjustment, and number of adjusted elements. Four heuristic algorithms are proposed to solve the models. The most appropriate heuristic(s) under each objective function and matrix size is determined through extensive statistical analysis of numerical experiments. The paper also presents an application of the proposed enhanced Monte Carlo AHP in a real-world industrial example of facility layout design selection, where the traditional Monte Carlo AHP fails to provide sufficient information to perform any statistical analysis on the final ranks and weights for the components in the hierarchy.

A New Consistency Index for Comparison Matrices in the ANP

A Simple Method to Improve the Consistency Ratio of the Pair-Wise Comparison Matrix in ANP

Is It Reasonable for Saaty's Consistency Test in the Pairwise Comparison Method?

Analytic Network Process in Risk Assessment and Decision Analysis

Inconsistency indices in pairwise comparisons: an improvement of the Consistency Index

An Automatic Method to Reach Consensus in a Local Context for AHP Group Decision Making

Possibility-Satisfiability Degree and the Test and Improvement of the Comparison Matrix' Consistency

Support A simple method to improve the consistency ratio of the pairwise comparison matrix in ANP

A direct consistency test and improvement method for the analytic hierarchy process

An Overview and Comparison of Axiomatization Structures Regarding Inconsistency Indices' Properties in Pairwise Comparisons Methods

Simulation Experiments for Improving the Consistency Ratio of Reciprocal Matrices

Consistency Measurement Of Pair-Wise Comparison

Consistency Issues of Interval Pairwise Comparison Matrices

Deriving priorities from pairwise comparison matrices with a novel consistency index

Geometric consistency index for interval pairwise comparison matrices

Consistency Improvement in the Analytic Hierarchy Process

Reducing inconsistency measured by the geometric consistency index in the analytic hierarchy process

Consistency Indices in Analytic Hierarchy Process: A Review

Consistency Improvement of Comparison Matrix Based on Geometric Consistency Index

Optimizing consistency improvement of positive reciprocal matrices with implications for Monte Carlo Analytic Hierarchy Process

Consistency and Consensus Improving Methods for Pairwise Comparison Matrices Based on Abelian Linearly Ordered Group