Value of Cardiovascular Imaging in Diagnosis of Complex Congenital Heart Disease: ROC Curve Analysis
陈国珍,孙锟,钟玉敏,吴兰平,孙爱敏,张玉奇,王谦,朱铭
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-3606.2009.03.023
2009-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the value of cardiovascular imaging in diagnosis of complex congenital heart disease(CHD) in children with receiver operating characteristic(ROC) analysis.Methods Twenty-eight patients with complex CHD were examined by three cardiologists with two-dimensional echocardiography(2DE),real-time three-dimen-sional echocardiography(RT-3DE),magnetic resonance imaging(MRI),multi-slice spiral computed tomography(CT),and digital subtraction angiography(DSA).All the cardiologists involved in the study were blinded to the clinical data.The results of the pathologic morphology of complex CHD showed in the imaging examination were divided at three levels:atria,ventricles and great arteries,atrial-ventricular and ventricular-arterial continuity,and extracardiac vascular malformations.The results were compared with surgical findings which were used as gold standard,and diagnostic value of imaging technology was evaluated by ROC analysis using a five-point categorical scale that ranged from definitely abnormal to definitely normal.Results The diagnostic assessments of the imaging technology were grouped and further analyzed by ROC curves.In examination of intracardiac malformations,atrial-ventricular and ventricular-arterial continuities,ROC curve for RT-3DE was located left-superior to that for 2DE,MRI /CT,DSA.And the area under ROC curve for RT-3DE(0.96) was higher than that for 2DE(0.92),MRI /CT(0.91),DSA(0.89).There were significant differences between RT-3DE and 2DE(P = 0.021 5),RT-3DE and MRI /CT(P = 0.005 0),RT-3DE and DSA(P = 0.001 5).Thus,left-superior ROC curve for RT-3DE and the larger area under ROC curve for RT-3DE were closer to the ideal discrimination function than that for 2DE,MRI /CT,DSA(P 0.05).While in the examination of extracardiac vascular malformations,ROC curve for DSA was located left-superior to that for MRI /CT,2DE,and the area under ROC curve for DSA(0.99) was higher than that of MRI /CT(A = 0.98),2DE(0.92),DSA(A = 0.89).There was a significant difference between DSA and 2DE(P = 0.007 5),but not between DSA and MRI /CT(P = 0.129 2).Thus,left-superior ROC curve and the larger area under ROC curve for DSA,MRI /CT were closer to the ideal discrimination function than that for 2DE.Conclusions This study showed that above-mentioned imaging methods have advantages and may complement the diagnosis of complex CHD.2DE and RT-3DE demonstrated advantages in displaying intracardiac structures,especially RT-3DE which could provide more spatial cardiac portrayal.DSA,MRI and multi-slice spiral CT were better in displaying extracardiac structures.MRI and multi-slice spiral CT may replace angiography to some extent.