Abstract:This study investigates the effects of visual mnemonics and the methods of presenting learning materials on learning visually similar characters for Chinese-as-second-language (CSL) learners. In supporting CSL learners to build robust orthographic representations in Chinese, addressing the challenges of visual similarity of characters (e.g., 理 and 埋) is an important issue. Based on prior research on perceptual learning, we tested three strategies that differ in the extent to which they promote interrelated attention to the form and meaning of characters: (1) Stroke Sequence, a form-emphasis strategy, (2) Key-images, a form + meaning strategy utilizing visual code, (3) Pithy Formulas with Key-images, a form + meaning strategy combining visual and verbal codes. A pretest–posttest equivalent-group design was adopted. The independent variables were the learning strategy, the method of presenting character pairs (visually similar vs. dissimilar), and testing time. The dependent variables were learners’ proportions of accurate responses to reading and writing Chinese characters through a posttest (immediately performed after learning) and a delayed posttest (1 week after learning); a learner experience survey was also administered to investigate learners’ opinions on each strategy. Sixty-six non-beginning learners of Chinese participated; they were randomly assigned to one of the two groups in which participants learned ten characters via the three strategies, respectively, differing between whether the characters were presented in similar pairs or dissimilar pairs. Data were analyzed via three-way ANCOVAs. The Pithy Formulas with Key-images and the Key-images generally yielded higher writing accuracy than Stroke Sequence immediately after learning. Notably, the advantage of the Pithy Formulas with Key-images (verbal and visual) over the Key-images (visual) on writing was specific to the participants that learned with visually similar pairs rather than those that learned with dissimilar pairs. All strategies were effective for reading, yet learners’ experience ratings favored the two form + meaning strategies over the strategy that focused primarily on form. Suggestions for future research and pedagogical implications on learning visually similar characters were offered.

Occurrence of Character in Textbooks for Learning Chinese as a Second Language:An Experimental Study

How Chinese Characters Are Taught: An Analysis of Three Popular Textbooks Used in Macao

A Further Study on Frequency Effects of Word and Character on Disyllabic Word Learning by CSL Learners

Chinese character matters!: An examination of linguistic accuracy in writing performances on the HSK test

Properties of School Chinese: Implications for Learning to Read

Effective character teaching methods for L1 English Chinese-as-a-foreign-language learners

Character Reading and Word Reading in Chinese: Unique Correlates for Chinese Kindergarteners

3,5,11 needles: looking for the perfect number of needles--a randomized and controlled study.

The effects of word frequency and character frequency on disyllabic word learning by foreign students from non-character-using countries

Analysis of Chinese Character Writing Norms for Learners of Chinese as A Second Language

Character and word reading in Chinese: Why and how they should be considered uniquely vis-à-vis literacy development

The Effect of Visual Mnemonics and the Presentation of Character Pairs on Learning Visually Similar Characters for Chinese-As-Second-Language Learners

Teaching strategies for Chinese characters similar in forms in TCFL

An examination of Chinese character writing errors: Developmental differences among Chinese as a foreign language learners

A Developmental Study of Chinese Children'S Word and Character Reading

Text Complexity of Chinese Elementary School Textbooks: Analysis of Text Linguistic Features Using Machine Learning Algorithms

Data analysis of Chinese characters in primary school corpora of Hong Kong and mainland China: preliminary theoretical interpretations

Using Eye-Tracking Technology to Explore the Impact of Instructional Multimedia on CFL Learners’ Chinese Character Recognition

A Study of Character Writing Errors by Foreign Learner Using Alphabetic Writing

Modeling the relationships among teacher instruction, learner belief, and learning strategies in Chinese character learning by alphabetic learners

Curriculum design in teaching Chinese characters to American students: when and what?