Abstract:Background: Large number of features are extracted from protein crystallization trial images to improve the accuracy of classifiers for predicting the presence of crystals or phases of the crystallization process. The excessive number of features and computationally intensive image processing methods to extract these features make utilization of automated classification tools on stand-alone computing systems inconvenient due to the required time to complete the classification tasks. Combinations of image feature sets, feature reduction and classification techniques for crystallization images benefiting from trace fluorescence labeling are investigated. Results: Features are categorized into intensity, graph, histogram, texture, shape adaptive, and region features (using binarized images generated by Otsu's, green percentile, and morphological thresholding). The effects of normalization, feature reduction with principle components analysis (PCA), and feature selection using random forest classifier are also analyzed. The time required to extract feature categories is computed and an estimated time of extraction is provided for feature category combinations. We have conducted around 8624 experiments (different combinations of feature categories, binarization methods, feature reduction/selection, normalization, and crystal categories). The best experimental results are obtained using combinations of intensity features, region features using Otsu's thresholding, region features using green percentile G90 thresholding, region features using green percentile G99 thresholding, graph features, and histogram features. Using this feature set combination, 96% accuracy (without misclassifying crystals as non-crystals) was achieved for the first level of classification to determine presence of crystals. Since missing a crystal is not desired, our algorithm is adjusted to achieve a high sensitivity rate. In the second level classification, 74.2% accuracy for (5-class) crystal sub-category classification. Best classification rates were achieved using random forest classifier. Contributions: The feature extraction and classification could be completed in about 2 s per image on a stand-alone computing system, which is suitable for real time analysis. These results enable research groups to select features according to their hardware setups for real-time analysis.

Image-Based Classification For Automating Protein Crystal Identification

Feature analysis for classification of trace fluorescent labeled protein crystallization images

Classification of X-Ray Protein Crystallization Using Deep Convolutional Neural Networks with a Finder Module

Image Enhancement Method for Crystal Identification in Crystal Size Distribution Measurement

Machine learning-based protein crystal detection for monitoring of crystallization processes enabled with large-scale synthetic data sets of photorealistic images

Convolutional neural network approach for the automated identification of in cellulo crystals

Classification of crystallization outcomes using deep convolutional neural networks

Crystal Image Segmentation Based on Gray Distribution Steepest Descent Method

Batch to Batch Variation Identification in Production of Crystalline Products Based on Image Analysis and Particle Shape Classification

Advances in High-Throughput, Automated Techniques and Instrumentation for Protein Crystallization Screening

Robust image descriptor for machine learning based data reduction in serial crystallography

Predicting X-ray Diffraction Quality of Protein Crystals Using a Deep-Learning Method

A simple and robust method for fast crystal identification

Towards automated screening of two-dimensional crystals

TLCrys: Transfer Learning Based Method for Protein Crystallization Prediction

Investigation of AI Algorithms for Photometric Online Analysis in a Draft Tube Baffle Crystallizer

A linear classification approach to model the early cellular responses induced by drugs

Deep Learning-Aided High-Throughput Screening of Time-Resolved Protein Crystallization on Programmable Microliter-Droplet Systems

PredPPCrys: Accurate Prediction of Sequence Cloning, Protein Production, Purification and Crystallization Propensity from Protein Sequences Using Multi-Step Heterogeneous Feature Fusion and Selection

A multiresolution approach to automated classification of protein subcellular location images

Automatic crystal identification for crystallography: a comparison between direct methods and artificial intelligence strategies