Comparative Analysis of the Efficacy of Surgery and Brachytherapy for Tongue Cancer

张春,蔡述华,刘辉,潘建基

2012-01-01

Abstract:Objective To analyze the efficacy of surgery and brachytherapy in the treatment of tongue cancer.Methods Kaplan-Meier was used to comparatively analyze the efficacy of surgery and brachytherapy of 133 cases of tongue cancer.Results In whole group,surgery was superior to radiotherapy.3 and 5 years survival rates in surgery group were 76.3%,67.7%,mean survival 82.4 months,while in radiotherapy group were 55.0%,35.0%,mean survival 56.3 months,P=0.000.The mean survival time of surgery and radiotherapy in stage I tongue cancer were 76.0 and 98.9 months,P=0.703;that of stageⅡ、Ⅲ were 74.0,40.2 months and 88.9,29.3 months,P value were 0.027 and 0.001;and that of stage Ⅳ were 48.7 months and 27.5 months,P=0.126.Conclusion There is no difference between surgery and radiotherapy in stage I tongue cancer,while in stageⅡ、Ⅲ,surgery has a better survival time than radiotherapy,in stage Ⅳ radiotherapy has better efficacy than surgery.