Theory,Data,and Instruments: On Ackermann's three-dimensional Dialectical Model of Knowledge Growth

WANG Yan-feng
2012-01-01
Abstract:The thesis of 'theory-loading of observations' or 'the independence of observations' was always in debating between rationalism and empiricism in the philosophy of science.Robert John Ackermann,the New Experimentalist,tried to transcend this two-dimensional debate of theory is thought primarily to guide data,or the reverse.He introduced a dialectical model to understand the growth of scientific knowledge,in which theory,data,and instruments are in three-dimensional dialectical relationship.Ackermann also tried to resolve Thomas S.Kuhn's incommensurability by the continuous improvement of instruments and technique.He is also said that it is because the applying of instruments which differ nature science from social science.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?