Harmonious Coexistence of Labor Laws and Human Resources Management

Dong Baohua
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2008.04.005
2008-01-01
Abstract:During the legislation of ″Employment Contract Law″,disputes arose as to the social attribute of labor laws and theories of human resources management and the inter-relation between the two.The arguments focused on whether the implementation of labor laws obscures the existence of human resources management and whether human resources management could be adopted as the guideline of labor laws.The key point of these arguments is whether sufficient space should be left for human resources instead of being taken by labor laws at all.In the name of protecting laborers,some scholars hope to compress social space with state regulation.In comparing labor laws and human resources management,three relations should be defined: moral responsibility and legal responsibility should not be inter-replaced;state intervention should have a reasonable boundary with rule of private right and national interest should not be confused with social interests.A basic principle of labor law legislation is that the purpose of labor law is to rectify the ″unjust outcome″ from the ″master-servant″ relation other than to change the relation itself.The legislation shall not block the development for human resources management but prompt the competition between the enterprises and labor unions for standardizing development by perfecting social responsibility of the enterprises and strengthening the power of labor unions.The harmonious coexistence of labor laws and human resources management is the foundation of the labor relations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?