The Product Mechanism of Diglossias TOT:Evidence from Mandarin-Cantonese Diglossias
Chen Jun,Su Ling,Zhang Jijia,Xing Shiqi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.2013.01.019
2013-01-01
Abstract:The tip-of-the-tongue(TOT) phenomenon is an intense feeling that the sought-after information is known and that the information will pop into the mind at any moment.Until now,researchers have proposed five theories to explain the TOT's production.These are partial activation theory,transmission deficit hypothesis,blocker hypothesis,metacognitive control theory,and quantitative neural network model.But most of the results from cross-linguistic area support the first two theories.Due to the complexity of Chinese language combined with its difficult operation,there has been a lack of diglossia TOT studies in China.Based on the research of bilinguals, we want to explore how the familiarity of a dialect can influence the TOT and what the mechanism of this diglossia's TOT is. A total of 68 subjects participated in this research.All subjects were native Cantone'se speakers,and were randomly chosen from a junior high school in Guangzhou suburbs.Thirty-nine of them can speak fluent Mandarin,while 29 can speak Cantone'se but not smoothly. This research contained two experiments.In each session,the subject and the experimenter were one-on-one and the experimenter recorded participants response in the whole course.At last,we used mix design variance analysis to process the data of PTOT rates and GOT rates. In Experiment 1,we compared the GOT and TOT rates of two kinds of participants when using different languages.The results showed a significantly higher TOT rates and lower GOT rates for these participants who are unfamiliar with Mandarin.This confirmed the partial activation theory in a preliminary fashion.In Experiment 2,we added auditory priming information as an independent variable, and explored the difference of GOTs and TOTs when naming in different languages and in different priming conditions.The results showed that GOT rates were higher in the condition of Mandarin and Cantone'se priming than in unrelated priming,and the TOT rates were significantly higher when priming and naming were both in Mandarin;but in Cantone'se priming,TOT rates generated by two- naming were non-significant.Moreover,in contrast to Experiment.1,Mandarin --familiar speakers experienced more TOTs than these who were unfamiliar with Mandarin. To sum up,the more the language familiarity one has,the easier it is when it comes to naming.This effect can be explained by the differences of lexical representation and language dependent effects.Besides,it states that the mechanism of diglossia is partially explained by activation theory and can also be explained by nodes structure theory(NST).In Experiment 2,the TOT rates were significantly higher when priming and naming both in Mandarin.As explained by NST,it once again confirms the partially activation theory.