Brain Activity during Visual and Auditory Word Rhyming Tasks in Cantonese–Mandarin–English Trilinguals

Yujia Wu,Jingwen Ma,Lei Cai,Zengjian Wang,Miao Fan,Jianping Chu,Yue Zhang,Xiuhong Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/brainsci10120936

IF: 3.333

2020-12-04

Brain Sciences

Abstract:It is unclear whether the brain activity during phonological processing of second languages (L2) is similar to that of the first language (L1) in trilingual individuals, especially when the L1 is logographic, and the L2s are logographic and alphabetic, respectively. To explore this issue, this study examined brain activity during visual and auditory word rhyming tasks in Cantonese–Mandarin–English trilinguals. Thirty Chinese college students whose L1 was Cantonese and L2s were Mandarin and English were recruited. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) was conducted while subjects performed visual and auditory word rhyming tasks in three languages (Cantonese, Mandarin, and English). The results revealed that in Cantonese–Mandarin–English trilinguals, whose L1 is logographic and the orthography of their L2 is the same as L1—i.e., Mandarin and Cantonese, which share the same set of Chinese characters—the brain regions for the phonological processing of L2 are different from those of L1; when the orthography of L2 is quite different from L1, i.e., English and Cantonese who belong to different writing systems, the brain regions for the phonological processing of L2 are similar to those of L1. A significant interaction effect was observed between language and modality in bilateral lingual gyri. Regions of interest (ROI) analysis at lingual gyri revealed greater activation of this region when using English than Cantonese and Mandarin in visual tasks.

neurosciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore whether the brain activities during phonological processing are similar among Cantonese-Mandarin-English trilinguals, particularly when the first language is logographic and the second languages are logographic and phonographic, respectively. Specifically, the study uses functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) experiments to detect the brain activities of subjects during visual and auditory word rhyming tasks to explore the following points:

1. **Similarity of brain regions during phonological processing**: Examine whether the brain regions involved in phonological processing in the visual modality are similar between the second languages (Mandarin and English) and the first language (Cantonese).
2. **Brain activities in different modalities**: Examine whether the brain regions involved in phonological processing in the auditory modality are similar between the second languages (Mandarin and English) and the first language (Cantonese).
3. **Effects of language and modality interaction**: Explore how the interaction between language and modality affects the phonological processing mechanisms of multilinguals.

The study hypothesizes based on the "Symmetry Hypothesis," predicting that the brain activity patterns in phonological processing will be similar between Cantonese (first language) and English (second language), but it cannot infer whether there is a similar brain activation pattern between Cantonese and Mandarin (both logographic languages). By combining visual and auditory task designs, the study aims to further enrich and refine the understanding of phonological processing mechanisms in multilinguals.