Abstract:There are notable divarications on the causation of defensive incline of Fragile High Self-esteem between theorists' proposition and studies.Theorists propose that the defensive incline of Fragile High Self-esteem is rooted in the separation between explicit and implicit self-esteem and corresponding internal attribution after ego-threats.But most of studies have showed that those with fragile self-esteem show external attribution and hostility or aggression(see Sandstrom & Jordan,2007) except for few studies supporting the academic reasoning mentioned above(Harter,1993;Tangney,Wagner,& Gramzow,1992).We postulate that there is a transformation of attribution and emotion after ego-threats and most of former studies haven't differentiated among immediate attribution and accompanying emotion and re-attribution and accompanying emotion. To test the hypothesis mentioned above,the present study recruited 89 subjects who were all college students and carried out a 3 (grouping:immediate group;re-attribution group;unrelated task group)×3(self-esteem type:fragile self-esteem;secure self-esteem; low self-esteem) between-subjects experiment.Firstly we filtered the subjects of 3 self-esteem types based on their scores of explicit and implicit self-esteem.In the formal experiment,all of the 3 types of subjects accomplished an alleged short-term memory efficiency test and accepted a feedback.The feedback was always negative and indicated that the grade was inferior to that of most of college students.In the immediate group,the subjects were directed to evaluate how his/her current feeling was congruent with those emotion words selected from PANA-X which measure shame and hostility immediately after the feedback.In the re-attribution group, the subjects completed a brief questionair consisting of 4 items which measured the re-attribution level before an emotion measurement. In the unrelated task group,the subjects counted his/her own pulse before an emotion measurement. The results showed that the subjects of fragile self-esteem experienced stronger shame than those of secure self-esteem in the immediate condition,and exhibited an external attribution if given re-attribution opportunity and then transformed shame into hostility.As to low self-esteem,they experienced stronger shame than those of secure self-esteem the in immediate condition,too.But they didn't use external attribution in the re-attribution condition and the level of hostility didn't increase. The present study demonstrates that the transeformation of attribution and emotion after ego-threats does exist for fragile self-esteem. The second finding is that those of low self-esteem always keep internal attribution and corresponding shame after ego-threats. These findings are significant for the understanding of the relations between depression and self-esteem.The findings also suggest that we should pay attention to the difference between immediate attribution and accompanying emotion and re-attribution and accompanying emotion in future studies.In doing so,we can get more exact and intensive comprehension for fragile self-esteem and other self-esteem types.

A Study on the Relationship of Self-esteem and Attributional Style with Guilt and Shame

The Relationship Between Guilt and Shame——from the perspective of counterfactual thinking

Family Socioeconomic Status and Adolescents' Academic Shame: The Chain Mediator Effect of Self-Control and Gratitude

The Study on The Correlation Among Social Anxiety、Self-esteem and Attribution Style of College Students

Relationship Between Counterfactual Thinking and Guilt and Shame Taking the university student and the juvenile delinquent as an example

Guilt Versus Shame: Distinguishing the Two Emotions from a Chinese Perspective

Differentiating shame and guilt from a relational perspective: A cross-cultural study

Shame, Personality and Mental Health: an Original Structural Model Research

Hopelessness/Self-esteem Theory of Depression in Undergraduates

Study on Self-Esteem and Emotion Regulation Self-Efficacy and the Influencing Factors among Middle School Students

Esteem in the Personality, Shame and Mental Health Model: Its Direct and Moderating Effects

The Structure of Shame among College Students and Questionnaire Setting

The Influential Effect of Undergraduates' Shame Proneness on Social Anxiety--A Longitudinal Study

A Cross-cultural Study on Psychological Mechanisms of Achievement Attribution

The Effects of Locus of Control and Guilt and Shame on Counterfactual Thinking

Autobiographical Memories of Shame: A Comparative Study in the Context of Cultural Differences of Self

Study on the Relationship between College Students'Attributional Style,Health Level and Suicidal Ideation

The Development of Attributional Style Questionnaire

The Attribution and Emotion Transformation of Fragile Self-esteem After Ego-threats

Self-blame and peer victimization in middle school: An attributional analysis.

The Relationship of Adolescent's Self-esteem and Aggression:The Role of Mediator and Moderator