Abstract:Developing students' critical thinking skills in writing is essential in different educational contexts. However, the analysis of the argument structure in non-English-major undergraduate students' writing remains largely unexplored. This study aimed to analyze the structure of argumentative English papers written by Chinese university students, based on the adapted Toulmin model of argument structure constituting six elements (claim, data, counterargument claim, counterargument data, rebuttal claim, and rebuttal data). The participants in this study were a class of 47 sophomores enrolled in the course "Modern Education Technology" at Zhejiang University, China. They were required to identify the components of the argument structure in a pre-assigned short text with two opposing views, and to write an argumentative essay. Content analysis was used to assess the students' CT and argument structures. In both tasks, the results found that the majority of the students could identify author's claim with at least a piece of data. They also stated their own claims and provided at least one piece of data to back these up. However, a majority failed to identify the author's counter argument and even though many stated the counter argument claims in their essays, most were unjustified. The majority did not state a conclusion in both tasks. This study may be beneficial in understanding non-English major-undergraduate students' critical thinking skills in English writing and the results suggest that L2 essay writing instructors should use active and explicit methods such as computer-assisted argument mapping tools like RationaleTM to help learners master the argument structure. Some pedagogic guidelines are listed for the implementation of the RationaleTM software in the L2 classroom.

Absence of Analytical Thinking Capacity among Foreign Language Learners and Critical Thinking Training

Analyzing Critical Thinking Elements in the Argument Structure of Non-English-Major Chinese Undergraduate Students' Writing

Can Learning a Foreign Language Foster Analytic Thinking?—Evidence from Chinese EFL Learners' Writings

Developing EFL Students’ Critical Thinking Competence in English Reading Class

Limitations and Improvements in Cultivating Critical Thinking in Schools of the Chinese Education System

The Empirical Study of the Development of Chinese EFL Learners’ Analytic Thinking

Teaching critical thinking to Chinese students in English as a foreign language writing class: A review

The cultivation of critical thinking skills of college students in English classroom

Critical Thinking in General Education in China

Challenges to improving higher education students' critical thinking capacity in China

Why does traditional China education system place less importance on critical thinking than western system? An evaluation of how to implement critical thinking in Chinese education effectively

Critical Thinking Instruction Incorporated in Cross-Cultural Communication Course Design: A Needs Analysis Report Based on Voices of Chinese International College Undergraduates

The Cultivation of Critical Thinking Ability in Academic Reading Based on Questionnaires and Interviews

Research on Cultivating Critical Thinking in High School English Reading Teaching

The Cultivation of Critical Thinking a Long Way to Go —A Teaching Practice and Reflection Based on the Cultivation of Critical Thinking

An Effectiveness Evaluation on Critical Thinking Exercises in Chinese College English Textbooks

Critical Thinking Cultivation in Chinese College English Classes

Views of Chinese middle school chemistry teachers on critical thinking

A Study on the Cultivation Mode of Students’ Critical Thinking Ability Based on College English Curriculum

Learning to teach critical thinking: testimonies of three EFL teachers in China

Brief Analysis on the Cultivation of Critical Thinking in Senior English Reading Teaching