The Outflow of Academic Papers from China: Why is It Happening and Can It Be Stemmed?
Jing Shao,Huiyun Shen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1087/20110203
2011-01-01
Learned Publishing
Abstract:Helped by deepening reform and openness, as well as increased overall national strength, science and technology in China have developed rapidly in recent years. The number of published scientific papers has also increased year by year. Statistics released in November 2009 by the Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China (ISTC) showed that the number of Science Citation Index (SCI) papers, Engineering Index (EI) papers and Index to Scientific & Technical Proceedings (ISTP) in 2008 from mainland China was 95,500, 85,000, and 59,299, and accounted for 6.6% (rank 4), 21.5% (rank 1), and 11.5% (rank 2), respectively. These were up, compared with 2007, by 7.2%, 12.3%, and 37.5%, respectively. Overall, in 2008 , the ‘Chinese’ total of 270,924 papers accounted for 11.5% of all papers and ranked 2 in the world. This indicates that in numerical terms mainland China is near the top position. It is a pity, however, that all these papers are written in English and that most of them are published in journals of foreign countries, such as the US and the UK. This outflow, especially of papers reflecting outstanding achievements in scientific research, has become very common, with the trend increasing year by year. (For example, in the 1990s, Chinese scientists published only about 6,000 papers per year covered by SCI,1 compared with the 95,500 quoted above.) Moreover, seldom are outstanding domestic or foreign results published in Chinese journals, and we believe that such an outflow has hindered the development of Chinese journals. China has set up a large number of so-called ‘Key Laboratories’, and some of these have obtained highlevel results, such as those on the rice and human genomes, and in paleontology. If more of these papers could be published in Chinese journals, then perhaps Chinese journals could obtain a better position in the world. Thus we believe it is of great significance to find out the reasons for the outflow of excellent papers and then take measures to stem this flow.