Study on Partner Selection of 3PL Suppliers Considering Risk Factors

WANG Su-fang,ZHANG Yong,MAO Hai-jun,LI Xu-hong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-152x.2008.02.017

2008-01-01

Abstract:The paper discusses partner selection of 3PL suppliers considering risk factors,brings forth the selection index system,selects the partners of 3PL suppliers using the method of combining AHP with fuzzy TOPSIS and gives out an example.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

A 3PL supplier selection model based on fuzzy sets

Fachao Li,Ling Li,Chenxia Jin,Ruijiang Wang,Hong Wang,Lili Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cor.2011.06.022

2012-08-01

Abstract:Outsourcing is an increasingly important task pursued by enterprises seeking improved efficiency. Logistics outsourcing, or third-party logistics (3PL), involves the use of external companies to perform some or all of the firm's logistics activities. In this paper, through analyzing the features and role of third-party logistics, for 3PL provider selection, we propose an indicator system and a method for data integration. We also establish a comprehensive evaluation model for 3PL suppliers based on fuzzy sets; furthermore, we propose a compound quantification model based on centralized quantification values, a comparison method based on the synthesis effect, and a 3PL supplier selection model. A real-world case analysis is provided. The results show that the proposed 3PL supplier selection model can effectively integrate decision preferences into decision processes.

computer science, interdisciplinary applications,engineering, industrial,operations research & management science
A Two-Stage Auction Mechanism for 3PL Supplier Selection under Risk Aversion

Fuqiang Lu,Hualing Bi,Wenjing Feng,Yanli Hu,Suxin Wang,Xu Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su13179745

IF: 3.9

2021-08-30

Sustainability

Abstract:The third party logistics (3PL) suppliers selection is a key issue in sustainable operation of fourth party logistics (4PL). A two-stage auction mechanism is designed for the selection of 3PL suppliers. Different from previous studies, the paper considers risk preference of 4PL integrators during the auction and uses the prospect theory to establish the auction scoring function of 4PL integrators. First, a first score sealed auction (FSSA) mechanism is used to solve the selection problem. However, the results show that FSSA is not an ideal method. Hence, the English auction (EA) mechanism is combined with the FSSA mechanism to form a two-stage auction. The FSSA is taken as the first stage auction, and the EA is taken as the second stage auction, and the two-stage auction mechanism is constructed. The two-stage auction can improve the utility of the 4PL integrator and the auction efficiency. In addition, for the degree of disclosure of attribute weights in the scoring function, two states, complete information and incomplete information is designed. In case analysis, the validity of the designed two-stage auction mechanism is verified. The 4PL integrator can obtain higher utility under the risk-neutral auction than the risk-averse auction. The complete information auction does not make the 4PL integrator obtain higher utility than the incomplete information auction.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
Fuzzy Relative Ratio Method for Choosing Third Party Logistics Suppliers

JU Sa,LI Deng-feng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-4993.2013.04.026

2013-01-01

Abstract:On analyzing pertinent literatures,the problem of selecting third party logistics service enterprises is regarded as a kind of typical multiattribute decision making problems.Hereby a fuzzy relative ratio method is presented to rank third-party logistics enterprises,which may provide a reference for enterprises to select logistics partners.At last,the method proposed in this paper is showed to be feasible and effective with a real example.
Supplier Selection with Shannon Entropy and Fuzzy TOPSIS in the Context of Supply Chain Risk Management

Reza Kiani Mavi,Mark Goh,Neda Kiani Mavi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2016.11.017

2016-11-01

Abstract:Supplier selection is the process of finding the right suppliers, at the right price, at the right time, in the right quantities, and with the right quality. The aim of this paper, is supplier selection in the context of supply chain risk management. Thus nine criteria of quality, on time delivery and performance history and six risks in the supply chain including supply risk, demand risk, manufacturing risk, logistics risk, information risk and environmental risk considered for evaluating suppliers. Shannon entropy is used for weighing criteria and fuzzy TOPSIS is applied for ranking suppliers. Findings show that, in the spare parts supplier selection problem, demand risk is the most important factor.

English Else
Study on selection of partners based on supply chain

Bochao Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ICAMS.2010.5553308

2010-01-01

Abstract:in this paper, the theories related to supply chain, supply chain management and supply chain partners are comprehensively analyzed, and based on the overview of several existing supplier selection models a partner selection model on the basis of AHP is established. This model provides an effective decision support for the objective and comprehensive evaluation of partners in the supply chain construction process. © 2010 IEEE.
A supply risk perspective integrated sustainable supplier selection model in the intuitionistic fuzzy environment

Chong Wu,Haohui Zou,David Barnes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00500-023-08336-0

IF: 3.732

2023-05-04

Soft Computing

Abstract:With the recent focus on supply risk management in sustainable supply chains, it is more important than ever to evaluate and select the right sustainable suppliers from a supply risk perspective. However, few existing studies consider supply risks from the perspective of all three triple-bottom-line dimensions at the same time. To bridge this research gap, this research constructs a supply risk perspective integrated sustainable supplier selection model in the intuitionistic fuzzy environment. First of all, the weights of decision-makers in the decision-making group are obtained by intuitionistic fuzzy set. Secondly, after obtaining the aggregated intuitionistic fuzzy decision matrix considering the weight of decision-makers, the fuzzy entropy weight method is used to calculate criteria weight, objectively. Then, an improved failure mode and effects analysis is used to undertake risk assessments and to identify high-risk suppliers. Last but not least, the extended alternative queuing method is adopted to rank the eligible sustainable suppliers in the intuitionistic fuzzy environment. The proposed model not only reduces the uncertainty of decision-making in sustainable supplier selection, but also enables focal companies to reduce supply risk in their sustainable supplier selection practices and prevent the failure modes that relate to supply risk. The practicality and effectiveness of the proposed model are verified through an empirical illustration in a leading electrical appliance manufacturer in China.

computer science, artificial intelligence, interdisciplinary applications
Selection of Logistics Alliance Partners

陈飞儿,张仁颐

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-9498.2004.03.011

2004-01-01

Abstract:The purpose of this paper is to provide an approach for properly selecting logistics alliance partners and to make a virtual company. Firstly, the paper uses the analytic hierarchical process (AHP) to evaluate the behavior of logistics companies and select the top four competitors. Secondly, the paper uses 0-1 integer programming to select logistics companies so as to obtain the best logistics alliance partners that can cooperate efficiently in transportation, warehousing and delivery. Thirdly, a combination of AHP and 0-1 integer programming is given to work out a better solution.
Supplier Selection Using Axiomatic Fuzzy Set and TOPSIS Methodology in Supply Chain Management

Ye Li,Xiaodong Liu,Yan Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10700-012-9117-x

IF: 4.085

2012-01-01

International Journal of Fuzzy Systems

Abstract:The current paper presents a comprehensive methodology for supplier selection. In the first stage, the linguistic values expressed as trapezoidal fuzzy numbers are used to assess the weights of the criteria. The Axiomatic Fuzzy Set clustering (AFS) method, which handles ambiguity and fuzziness in the supplier selection problem effectively, is applied to cluster the suppliers and evaluate each potential supplier that aims at obtaining initial supplier ranking. In the second stage, the Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (FAHP) model is constructed to determine the weight of various quantitative and qualitative criteria. To address multiple decision criteria in supplier ranking, the Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) is employed to select the final suppliers. A numerical example composed of 30 suppliers and 6 criteria is studied, and the experimental results show that the proposed evaluation framework is suitable for supplier selection decisions even with the dependent criteria/attributes.
Study on Choosing Service Provided by 3PL Agents

徐千里,王伟

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-152x.2009.06.028

2009-01-01

Abstract:The paper builds up an assessment model from the angle of game theory, analyzes the profits of the gents of 3PL and discusses the prior control of risks and a mechanism of choosing services provided by agents of 3PL.
A SPA-based model for the selection of Third Party logistics (TPL) supplier

Baiqing Ye,Shaogunag Sun,Sizhi Li

2008-01-01

Abstract:With the development of economy, enterprises have an increasing demand for logistics. The third party logistics have become one of the most important topics. This paper, through researching the relational current situation, establishes a set of new evaluation index system, and on the basis of it, uses the methods of SPA, Analytic Hierarchy Process(AHP) and Entropy Coefficients to establishes A SPA-based model for the selection of TPL supplier, and proves its possibility by a case finally. It can provide a set of objective standard and method for enterprise selecting its third-party logistics supplier.
Distribution Network Supplier Selection with Fuzzy AHP and TOPSIS

Zhiwei Li,Liping Sun,Lanfei He,Xuejun Tang,Xuxia Zou,Minghua Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ICIEA.2019.8834014

2019-01-01

Abstract:Supplier selection is one of the most important activities of purchasing, since it has a great impact on the normal operation and profit of an enterprise. Due to the stringent requirement on the normal operation of State Grid and the diversity of distribution network commodities, proper supplier management is even more important than what is required in other fields. In this paper, a criteria hierarchy for distribution network supplier selection is constructed. To select suppliers objectively, a FAHP integrated TOPSIS approach is proposed. A questionnaire survey is conducted to get the weight of every criterion and a numerical example is given to illustrate how the model works.
ASSESSMENT OF THIRD-PARTY LOGISTICS PROVIDERS USING A CRITIC–WASPAS APPROACH WITH INTERVAL TYPE-2 FUZZY SETS

Mehdi Keshavarz Ghorabaee,Maghsoud Amiri,Edmundas Kazimieras Zavadskas,Jurgita Antuchevičienė

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3846/16484142.2017.1282381

IF: 1.455

2017-03-05

Transport

Abstract:The assessment of Third-Party Logistics (3PL) provider becomes an important issue for enterprises trying to achieve operational efficiency and customer service improvement as well as capital expenditure and logistics costs reduction. It can be said that evaluation and selection of an appropriate 3PL provider is a kind of Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) problem. Uncertainty is an unavoidable part of information in the decision-making process. Interval Type-2 Fuzzy Sets (IT2FSs) are very flexible to model the uncertainty of the MCDM problems. In this study, a new integrated approach based on the criteria Importance Through Inter-criteria Correlation (CRITIC) and Weighted Aggregated Sum Product assessment (WASPAS) methods is proposed to evaluate 3PL providers with IT2FSs. In the proposed approach, objective weights resulted from the CRITIC method are combined with subjective weights expressed by decision-makers (dms) to determine more realistic weights for criteria. A computational study is performed to illustrate the proposed approach and the applicability of it. In addition, a sensitivity analysis is carried out using different sets of criteria weights to demonstrate the stability of the proposed approach. The results show the stability of ranking results and prove the efficiency of the proposed approach to handle MCDM problems with IT2FSs.

transportation science & technology
A modified failure mode and effects analysis method for supplier selection problems in the supply chain risk environment: A case study

Ping-Shun Chen,Ming-Tsung Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2013.09.018

2013-12-01

Abstract:In the emerging supply chain environment, supply chain risk management plays a more important role than ever. Companies must focus not only on the efficiency of supply chain, but also on its risks. If an unanticipated event occurs, all of the supply chain members will be impacted, and the result will cause significant loss. Therefore, this research proposes a modified failure mode and effects analysis (MFMEA) method to select new suppliers from the supply chain risk’s perspective and applies the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) method to determine the weight of each criterion and sub-criterion for supplier selection. An IC assembly company is then studied to validate this model. The result shows that the case company can categorize its suppliers more effectively and at the same time select a low-risk supply chain partner. Moreover, the case company can provide unsatisfactory suppliers with valuable feedback that will help them improve and become its partners in the future.

computer science, interdisciplinary applications,engineering, industrial
An integrated fuzzy AHP- fuzzy MULTIMOORA model for supply chain risk-benefit assessment and supplier selection

Madjid Tavana,Akram Shaabani,Soleyman Mansouri Mohammadabadi,Nilofar Varzgani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23302674.2020.1737754

2020-03-13

Abstract:Supplier selection is a strategic decision for reducing risk, maximising overall value, and establishing strong, mutually beneficial long-term relationships between the members in supply chain management. Identifying and prioritising the risks and benefits from each supplier enables managers to consider these factors and select the most suitable supplier. We propose an integrated approach for supply chain risk-benefit assessment and supplier selection by combining the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (AHP) with the fuzzy multiplicative multi-objective optimisation based on ratio analysis (MULTIMOORA). The fuzzy AHP is used to measure the importance of the supply chain risks and benefits and the fuzzy MULTIMOORA is used to rank the suppliers. We present a case study to demonstrate the applicability and exhibit the efficacy of the proposed integrated framework. We also study the uncertainty in the output of our proposed framework using sensitivity analysis.
Risk adjusted multicriteria supplier selection models with applications

A. Ravi Ravindran,R. Ufuk Bilsel,Vijay Wadhwa,Tao Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00207540903174940

IF: 9.018

2009-12-10

International Journal of Production Research

Abstract:Most manufacturers are continuously seeking their supplier base around the world and look for an opportunity to significantly reduce supply chain costs. Singular emphasis on supply chain cost, however, can make the supply chain brittle and more susceptible to the risk of disruptions. The objective of this paper is to develop multicriteria supplier selection models incorporating supplier risk and apply them to a real company. We develop two different types of risk models, value-at-risk (VaR) and miss-the-target (MtT). We model the risk-adjusted supplier selection problem as a multicriteria optimisation problem and solve it in two phases. Phase 1 is the pre-qualification step, where a large set of initial suppliers is reduced to a smaller set of manageable suppliers using various multi-objective ranking methods. In Phase 2, order quantities are allocated among the short listed suppliers using a multi-objective optimisation model. In the multi-objective formulation, price, lead-time, VaR type risk of disruption due to natural event and MtT type risk of quality are explicitly considered as four conflicting objectives that have to be minimised simultaneously. We solve the multi-objective optimisation problem using four different variants of goal programming. The models are illustrated with an actual application to a global IT company.

engineering, manufacturing, industrial,operations research & management science
Supplier selection considering strategic and operational risks: a combined qualitative and quantitative approach

Mohammad Ali Nekooie,Mohammad Sheikhalishahi,Reza Hosnavi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11740-015-0643-6

2015-11-05

Production Engineering

Abstract:This paper proposes a combined qualitative and quantitative approach for supplier selection problem. Multi-component product is considered in which various suppliers could provide each required part. A multi-objective mathematical model is developed to decide about the preferred supplier as well as the purchasing quantity of each part from each selected supplier. Strategic and operational risks are taken into account. In order to handle qualitative risk factors analytic network process is used. Two quantitative risk factors including delay and defect are considered. In addition, the quality of the final product is taken into account. To enable the decision maker to make preferred trade-offs between objectives a fuzzy goal programming approach with soft priorities between objectives is applied. The capability and effectiveness of the proposed model is validated through a case study.

English Else
The supplier selection application based on two methods: VIKOR algorithm with entropy method and Fuzzy TOPSIS with vague sets method

Min Wu,Zhujun Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17509653.2011.10671152

2011-01-01

International Journal of Management Science and Engineering Management

Abstract:In recent years, supply chain management (SCM) has become a hot issue of theoretical and empirical research. In supply chain management, the range of manufacturer’s decision expanded from the single enterprise itself to the entire supply chain. As a fundamental decision-making for manufacturers, the quality of supplier performance not only affects the downstream business, but also determines the success of the whole supply chain. Therefore, choosing suitable suppliers in the supply chain becomes a key strategic step, it directly impacts the benefits for manufacturers. However, it is difficult for manufacturers particularly in the supplier selection, to have comprehensive and accurate understanding of the supplier. The supplier selection is a complex multi-criteria problem including both quantitative and qualitative factors which may be in conflict and may also be uncertain. In this paper two scientific and simple calculation methods for manufacture’s decision-makers to choose the most ideal supplier have been provided, this paper deals with the supplier selection problems based on VIKOR algorithm (Vlse Kriterijumska Optimizacija Kompromisno Resenje) which is a compromise multiple criteria decision making approach with entropy method which gives the weights to indicators, and fuzzy multiple attribute decision-making method with vague sets incorporating TOPSIS. The VIKOR algorithm deals with the conflicts between indicators based on certain way to sort the scheme and choose the best scheme. And the Fuzzy TOPSIS with vague sets method helps to deal with inaccurate, incomplete and imperfect information to some extent. A numerical example is proposed to illustrate the effectiveness of the two algorithms. However, in the future it should consider the selection of indicators and data filtration and the right of assignment and so on, to make the results of evaluations more objective and accurate.
Supplier Risk Assessment and Early Warning Based on Fuzzy Group Analytic Hierarchy Process

Yang Wang,Chuanwen Wu,Yajing Guo,Bo Zhang,Wenjia Xu,Chen Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/srse59585.2023.10336071

2023-01-01

Abstract:This paper presents a comprehensive study for suppliers’ risk assessment and early warning, with partially applied in aerospace industry. In particular, we identify eight pivotal risk indices that significantly influence supplier selection, namely design and production, supply and delivery, application verification, quality inspection, installation and use, cost control, supporting services, and credit qualification. Leveraging hierarchical analysis and integrating with expert consultations, we introduce a final assessment indice based on Fuzzy Group Analytic Hierarchy Process (FGAHP). This model has been validated in an aerospace industry company with 14 suppliers.
Supplier Selection in Sustainable Supply Chains: A Risk-Based Integrated Group Decision-Making Model

Chong Wu,Haohui Zou,David Barnes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-293117/v1

2021-03-16

Abstract:Abstract With the recent emphasis on supply risk management in sustainable supply chains (SSCs), the evaluation and selection of appropriate suppliers are more important than ever. However, most existing research does not take all three sustainability perspectives of supply risk into account simultaneously and they rarely consider the correlation among supply risk factors in risk assessment. Therefore, considering the uncertain information decision-making environment, this research paper proposes a risk-based integrated group decision-making model for sustainable supplier selection (SSS). First, the weights of decision-makers (DMs) are taken as linguistic terms denoted by intuitionistic fuzzy numbers (IFNs). Second, after obtaining the aggregated intuitionistic fuzzy decision-making matrix considering the expert weights, this study uses the entropy weight method to calculate the criteria weights objectively. Then, the improved failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) is adopted for the risk assessment to exclude high-risk suppliers. Finally, the extended alternative queuing method (AQM) is applied to rank the qualified suppliers in SSCs. This model can not only enable enterprises to reduce supply risk in SSS practices and identify and prevent the failure modes that lead to supply risk, but also reduce the uncertainty of decision-making, in order to make supplier selection more accurate. The feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed model are illustrated through application in a leading Chinese electrical appliance manufacturing company.

Study on Partner Selection of 3PL Suppliers Considering Risk Factors

A 3PL supplier selection model based on fuzzy sets

A Two-Stage Auction Mechanism for 3PL Supplier Selection under Risk Aversion

Fuzzy Relative Ratio Method for Choosing Third Party Logistics Suppliers

Supplier Selection with Shannon Entropy and Fuzzy TOPSIS in the Context of Supply Chain Risk Management

Study on selection of partners based on supply chain

A supply risk perspective integrated sustainable supplier selection model in the intuitionistic fuzzy environment

Selection of Logistics Alliance Partners

Supplier Selection Using Axiomatic Fuzzy Set and TOPSIS Methodology in Supply Chain Management

Study on Choosing Service Provided by 3PL Agents

A SPA-based model for the selection of Third Party logistics (TPL) supplier

Distribution Network Supplier Selection with Fuzzy AHP and TOPSIS

ASSESSMENT OF THIRD-PARTY LOGISTICS PROVIDERS USING A CRITIC–WASPAS APPROACH WITH INTERVAL TYPE-2 FUZZY SETS

A modified failure mode and effects analysis method for supplier selection problems in the supply chain risk environment: A case study

An integrated fuzzy AHP- fuzzy MULTIMOORA model for supply chain risk-benefit assessment and supplier selection

Risk adjusted multicriteria supplier selection models with applications

Supplier selection considering strategic and operational risks: a combined qualitative and quantitative approach

The supplier selection application based on two methods: VIKOR algorithm with entropy method and Fuzzy TOPSIS with vague sets method

Supplier Risk Assessment and Early Warning Based on Fuzzy Group Analytic Hierarchy Process

Supplier Selection in Sustainable Supply Chains: A Risk-Based Integrated Group Decision-Making Model