Abstract:Many well-known logical identities are naturally written as equivalences between contextual formulas. A simple example is the Boole-Shannon expansion $c[p] \equiv (p \wedge c[\mathrm{true}] ) \vee (\neg\, p \wedge c[\mathrm{false}] )$, where $c$ denotes an arbitrary formula with possibly multiple occurrences of a "hole", called a context, and $c[\varphi]$ denotes the result of "filling" all holes of $c$ with the formula $\varphi$. Another example is the unfolding rule $\mu X. c[X] \equiv c[\mu X. c[X]]$ of the modal $\mu$-calculus. We consider the modal $\mu$-calculus as overarching temporal logic and, as usual, reduce the problem whether $\varphi_1 \equiv \varphi_2$ holds for contextual formulas $\varphi_1, \varphi_2$ to the problem whether $\varphi_1 \leftrightarrow \varphi_2$ is valid . We show that the problem whether a contextual formula of the $\mu$-calculus is valid for all contexts can be reduced to validity of ordinary formulas. Our first result constructs a canonical context such that a formula is valid for all contexts if{}f it is valid for this particular one. However, the ordinary formula is exponential in the nesting-depth of the context variables. In a second result we solve this problem, thus proving that validity of contextual formulas is EXP-complete, as for ordinary equivalences. We also prove that both results hold for CTL and LTL as well. We conclude the paper with some experimental results. In particular, we use our implementation to automatically prove the correctness of a set of six contextual equivalences of LTL recently introduced by Esparza et al. for the normalization of LTL formulas. While Esparza et al. need several pages of manual proof, our tool only needs milliseconds to do the job and to compute counterexamples for incorrect variants of the equivalences.

Extension and Equivalence Problems for Clause Minimal Formulae

Classes of propositional UMU formulas and their extensions to minimal unsatisfiable formulas

The Complexity of Variable Minimal Formulas

A Fixed-point Theorem for Horn Formula Equations

Computing Minimal Sets on Propositional Formulae I: Problems & Reductions

Generating clause sequences of a CNF formula

Minimization for Generalized Boolean Formulas

On the Expressivity and Applicability of Model Representation Formalisms

On the Complexity of Solution Extension of Optimization Problems

Equiconsistency of the Minimalist Foundation with its classical version

A general theorem of existence of quasi absolutely minimal Lipschitz extensions

Validity of contextual formulas (extended version)

Small unsatisfiable $k$-CNFs with bounded literal occurrence

Constraint Qualifications for Extended Farkas'S Lemmas and Lagrangian Dualities in Convex Infinite Programming

Bounds for variables with few occurrences in conjunctive normal forms

A Resolution-Based Approach for Extracting Variable Minimal Unsatisfiable Sub-Formulas

Complexity of Reasoning with Cardinality Minimality Conditions

On Lower Bounding Minimal Model Count

Formulas Free from Inconsistency: an Atom-Centric Characterization in Priest's Minimally Inconsistent LP (extended Abstract)

An algorithm for extracting minimal first-order unsatisfiable subformulae on depth-first-search and incremental solving

Remarks on minimal solutions of fuzzy relation inequalities with addition-min composition