Abstract:We study the approximability of two natural Boolean constraint satisfaction problems: Horn satisfiability and exact hitting set. Under the Unique Games conjecture, we prove the following optimal inapproximability and approximability results for finding an assignment satisfying as many constraints as possible given a near-satisfiable instance.1. Given an instance of Max Horn-3SAT that admits an assignment satisfying (1 - epsilon) of its constraints for some small constant epsilon > 0, it is hard to find an assignment satisfying more than (1 - 1/O(log(1/epsilon))) of the constraints. This matches a linear programming based algorithm due to Zwick [Zwi98], resolving the natural open question raised in that work concerning the optimality of the approximation bound.Given a (1 - epsilon) satisfiable instance of Max Horn-2SAT for some constant epsilon > 0, it is possible to find a (1 - 2 epsilon)-satisfying assignment efficiently. This improves the algorithm given in [KSTW00] which finds a (1 - 3 epsilon)-satisfying assignment, and also matches the (1 - c epsilon) hardness for any c < 2 derived from vertex cover (under UGC).2. An instance of Max 1-in-k-HS consists of a universe U and a collection C of subsets of U of size at most k, and the goal is to find a subset of U that intersects the maximum number of sets in C at a unique element. We prove that Max 1-in-k-HS is hard to approximate within a factor of O(1/log k) for every fixed integer k. This matches (up to constant factors) an easy factor O(1/log k) approximation algorithm for the problem, and resolves a question posed in [GT05].It is crucial for the above hardness that sets of size up to k are allowed; indeed, when all sets have size k, there is a simple factor 1/e-approximation algorithm.Our hardness results are proved by constructing integrality gap instances for a semidefinite programming relaxation for the problems, and using Raghavendra's result [Rag08] to conclude that no algorithm can do better than the SDP assuming the UGC. In contrast to previous gap constructions where the instances had a good SDP solution by design and the main task was bounding the integral optimum, the challenge in our case is the construction of appropriate SDP vectors and the integral optimum is easy to bound. Our algorithmic results are based on rounding appropriate linear programming relaxations.

Bounds for variables with few occurrences in conjunctive normal forms

Small unsatisfiable $k$-CNFs with bounded literal occurrence

Even shorter proofs without new variables

A Graphical #SAT Algorithm for Formulae with Small Clause Density

Bounded-Depth Frege Lower Bounds for Random 3-CNFs via Deterministic Restrictions

A Lower Bound for Boolean Satisfiability on Turing Machines

On the satisfiability of random $3$-SAT formulas with $k$-wise independent clauses

Computing Minimal Sets on Propositional Formulae I: Problems & Reductions

k variables are needed to define k-Clique in first-order logic

The Complexity of Variable Minimal Formulas

A framework for good SAT translations, with applications to CNF representations of XOR constraints

Redundancy Is All You Need

An even simpler hard variant of Not-All-Equal 3-SAT

Complexity of Reasoning with Cardinality Minimality Conditions

Computing maximal autarkies with few and simple oracle queries

The Algorithmic Phase Transition of Random $k$-SAT for Low Degree Polynomials

Tight Bounds On The Approximability Of Almost-Satisfiable Horn Sat And Exact Hitting Set

A Note On The Natural Range Of Unambiguous-SAT

On the Number of Quantifiers Needed to Define Boolean Functions

Properties of the satisfiability threshold of the strictly d-regular random (3,2s)-SAT problem

Subsumption Checking in Conjunctive Coalgebraic Fixpoint Logics