Quality Evaluation of Clinical Literature on Traditional Chinese Medicine in Treatment of Osteosarcoma

ZHANG Jianjun,SUN Yuanjue,YAO Yang
2009-01-01
Abstract:Objective:To evaluate the quality of clinical research design on traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) in treatment of osteosarcoma. Methods:Literature on TCM treatment for osteosarcoma between 1960 and 2009 were searched electronically and evaluated according to the clinical epidemiological methods of system evaluation. Results:Thirty articles were obtained,including 23 descriptive studies (19 case reports and 4 case series),3 analytic studies (2 case control studies and 1 prospective cohort study),and 4 experimental studies (clinical trials). All the descriptive studies lacked detailed clinical data,the selection of control groups in 2 analytic studies was unreasonable,2 clinical trial articles lacked inclusive and exclusive criteria,2 clinical trial articles didn't describe the randomization methods,the statistical analysis was incorrect in 1 clinical trial article,and none of the sample size estimation,blinding,informed consent and intention-to-treat analysis were described in 4 clinical trial articles. Conclusion:The clinical research of osteosarcoma treated with TCM is at a preliminary stage,and the quality of research design and literature should be improved urgently.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?