A Note on Pseudo-comparatives Like "john is Rich Like X!" and "like X, John is Rich!".

Benjamin K. Tsou
2010-01-01
Abstract:The title of this paper contains two types of sentences which show drastically opposite illocutionary acts of denial (of John's wealth) and exclamatory emphasis (on John's wealth). This paper attempts to explore the linguistic and pragmatic processes which could account for their different origins by drawing on the notions of pseudo-comparative sentences and Modus Tollens, and by fruitfully exploring them in the contexts of English and Chinese (Mandarin and Cantonese). We show that gradability of attributes could account for differences between the opposite illocutionary forces in English, and that the addition of identity of the attributes being compared could account for differences in English and Chinese. Furthermore, other factors such as different epithets and their use as well as their infixation in disyllabic words could account for some usual differences between Mandarin and Cantonese.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?