Two Dilemmas about Accounting Ethics

任明川

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-6701.2009.04.006

2009-01-01

Abstract:In tracing the one-and-a-half-century history of development,one can find two dilemmas about accounting ethics.One is motivation dilemma.As a profession,accounting sets up its own ethics.However,what's the fundamental purpose for ethics,altruism or egoism? The accounting profession is the major proponent of the former,while the critics of accounting profession are major proponent of the latter.The other is independence dilemma.Audit independence is at the center of accounting ethics.In theory,independence in fact is the most important.But in practice independence in appearance becomes the major objective of accounting regulation.In the US,accounting profession puts more emphasis on the former,while the SEC pays more attention on the latter.This in part creates the problem of double standards.An understanding of these two dilemmas can benefit the research in accounting ethics.