Energy transfer processes in Ce3+ and Tb3+ co-doped Ln2Si2O7 (Ln = Y, Gd)
Yong Li,Xiantao Wei,Min YIN,Ye Tao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.optmat.2011.02.017
IF: 3.754
2011-01-01
Optical Materials
Abstract:Research highlights ► The Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ co-doped Ln 2 Si 2 O 7 (Ln = Y, Gd) samples were prepared by sol-gel method. ► Energy transfer only conducts from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ in Y 2 Si 2 O 7 host. ► Energy can transfer mutually between Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ in Gd 2 Si 2 O 7 host. ► The Tb 3+ excitation energy could be transferred to Ce 3+ ion via Gd 3+ ion as a bridge in Gd 2 Si 2 O 7 host. ► The Gd 2 Si 2 O 7 host can convert more VUV and UV radiation into visible light than Y 2 Si 2 O 7 host. Abstract The Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ co-doped Ln 2 Si 2 O 7 (Ln = Y, Gd) samples were prepared by sol–gel method. Structure characterization of the phosphor was carried out by X-ray diffraction. The luminescence properties of samples were analyzed by measuring the excitation and emission spectra. It was observed that excitation energy can transfer mutually between Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ in GPS: Ce 3+ , Tb 3+ samples, while in Y 2 Si 2 O 7 :Ce 3+ , Tb 3+ samples the energy transfer only progresses from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ . Based on the energy level diagrams of respective Ce 3+ , Tb 3+ and Gd 3+ ion, the detailed pathways for energy transfer are explained. Keywords Energy transfer Luminescence Silicate Rare earth 1 Introduction Rare earth silicates have attracted much attention due to their excellent properties. Cerium doped orthosilicates Re 2 SiO 5 :Ce 3+ (Re = Lu, Y, Gd) have been developed due to their ideal qualities for ionizing radiation detection, such as their high density, relative high light yield and short decay time [1–3] . Recently, Ce-doped pyrosilicate Re 2 Si 2 O 7 :Ce 3+ (Re = Lu, Y, Gd), which is another kind of host material in Re 2 O 3 –SiO 2 binary system (Re 2 O 3 :SiO 2 = 1:2), shows much better scintillation performance than orthosilicates Re 2 SiO 5 :Ce 3+ [4–6] . These materials demonstrate much lower afterglow level and absence of luminescence quenching in the wide temperature range [4] . On the other hand, rare earth silicates are also good physical system for studying energy transfer from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ . The luminescence properties and energy transfer mechanisms between Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ are reported in rare earth silicates powders samples [2,7–9] . It is well known that Ce 3+ ion can be used as a sensitizer for Tb 3+ ion. The energy transfer from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ ion is usually very effective which results in bright luminescence of Tb 3+ . Actually, some Ce 3+ –Tb 3+ codoped materials have been applied as blue and green-light emitting phosphors [10] . At the same time, there are some other reports regarding the energy transfer from Tb 3+ to Ce 3+ in yttrium aluminum garnet [11,12] , which has been attributed to the cross relaxation between Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ ion [12] . Energy transfer from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ or Tb 3+ to Ce 3+ also depends on the nature and crystal structure of host. In recent decades, with the developing of mercury-free phosphorescent lamp and plasma display panel, luminescent materials of rare-earths in the vacuum ultraviolet region has received much attention. Such phosphors would have the ability to absorb vacuum ultraviolet energy and efficiently transfer the energy to the luminescent ions. Rare earth silicates have good thermal, chemical stability and are a good host for luminescent materials under vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) and ultraviolet (UV) excitation [7,8,13] . In the present work, luminescence properties of Ln 2 Si 2 O 7 :Ce 3+ , Tb 3+ (Ln = Y, Gd) samples obtained by sol–gel method were studied. The research primarily focused on energy transfer mechanisms between Tb 3+ and Ce 3+ ions, and the efficiency of energy transfer was discussed. 2 Experimental The Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ co-doped Ln 2 Si 2 O 7 (Ln = Y, Gd) samples were prepared by sol–gel method. The purity of raw materials Gd 2 O 3 , Y 2 O 3 , CeO 2 , and Tb 4 O 7 was 99.99%. The Si(OC 2 H 5 ) 4 was analytical pure. The oxides were dissolved in dilute nitric acid separately, and corresponding nitrate solutions were obtained. After mixing the required amount of the above solutions, certain citric acid (the molar ratio of citric acid to total metal cation was 2:1) were added to the mixed nitrate solution. The Si(OC 2 H 5 ) 4 was dissolved in alcohol, and then mixed with the obtained solution. Ammonia or nitric acid was used to keep the pH value of the resulting solution at about 2.0. The mixture was stirred to achieve a uniform mixing and form a sol. The sol turned into gel after the process of water bath at 70 °C. The dried gel was preheated to get rid of alcohol, water and citric acid at 450 °C for 2 h, then was ground into fine powder and heated in a high temperature tube furnace at different temperature for 2 h, respectively. The prepared samples appeared to be white color in body. X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns were obtained on a rotating anode X-ray diffractometer (MAC Science Co. Ltd. MXP18AHF) under Cu Kα radiation. The VUV–UV excitation spectra and emission spectra were measured at the VUV spectroscopy station of Beijing Synchrotron Radiation Facility, Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences. The electron energy of the storage ring is 2.5 GeV and the beam current is approximately from 160 to 60 mA in measurement. An ARC-VM-502-S monochromator (1200 g/mm) was used for the excitation spectra; an ARC SP-308 monochromator (1200 g/mm) was used for the emission spectra and the signal was detected by a Hamamatsu H7421–50 photomultiplier. The integration time of 1 s and wavelength step of 1 nm were applied for all the spectrum measurements. The excitation spectra were corrected with the photo flux of the excitation beam using the excitation spectrum of sodium salicylate as standard in the same excitation conditions. All the spectra were recorded at room temperature. 3 Results and discussion The structure and phase purity of the products were examined by X-ray diffraction analysis. Fig. 1 a shows the XRD patterns of the Y 2 Si 2 O 7 (YPS) powders annealed at various temperatures. For the sample prepared at 900 °C, an obvious broad weak peak is observed, indicating that the samples begin to crystallize. At 1000 °C, the characteristic peaks of YPS phase appear which are well consistent with the standard XRD pattern of α-YPS (JCPDS 21-1457). The XRD patterns of Gd 2 Si 2 O 7 (GPS) present same characteristic with that of YPS , as shown at Fig. 1 b. It can be seen that the powders remain amorphous up to 900 °C. At 1000 °C, the diffraction peaks appear, this pattern is similar to that of α-YPS phase, indicating that it has same structure with YPS samples prepared at 1000 °C, above 1100 °C, continued refinement of peak shapes and enhancement of intensity are observed, indicating the growth of crystallite with the increase of synthesis temperature. The excitation spectrum and emission spectrum of YPS: Ce 3+ 1% and GPS: Ce 3+ 1% are shown in Fig. 2 . The excitation spectrum monitored 404 nm emission contains five broad bands. The band at higher energy is attributed to host absorption. The other four broad bands from 200 nm to 350 nm are characteristic of transitions from 4f 1 ground state to four lower crystal field splitting levels of the 5d states of Ce 3+ ions. Compared excitation spectrum of GPS: Ce 3+ 1% with that of YPS: Ce 3+ 1%, it can be found that Ce 3+ in both hosts with same crystal structure shows the similar splitting behavior. Beside the bands originating from Ce 3+ ion described above, the peaks at about 273 nm in the excitation spectrum, which is superimposed over broad Ce 3+ excitation bands, correspond to the 8 S 7/2 → 6 I J transitions of Gd 3+ in the GPS matrix, which suggests the energy transfer from Gd 3+ to Ce 3+ ion. The emission of Ce 3+ in the two hosts consist of a broad band with a maximum at 404 nm , which can be assigned to the parity allowed transitions of lowest component of 5d states to the spin–orbit components of the ground state 2 F 5/2 , 2 F 7/2 of Ce 3+ , respectively. Fig. 3 shows the excitation and emission spectra of YPS: Tb 3+ 0.5% and GPS: Tb 3+ 0.5% powders. The characteristic luminescence observed in the emission spectra corresponds with the 5 D 3 → 7 F J and 5 D 4 → 7 F J line emissions of the Tb 3+ ions, and the strongest emission at 543 nm originates from the 5 D 4 → 7 F 5 transition. The excitation spectrum monitored 543 nm in two different hosts both contains two broad bands. The band at higher energy is also attributed to host absorption in the two different hosts. Another band centered 228 nm can be ascribed to the transitions of Tb 3+ from the lower level of 4f 8 configuration to the energy levels of 4f 7 5d configuration. Beside the bands described above, the peaks at about 273 nm and 313 nm in the excitation spectrum correspond to the 8 S 7/2 → 6 I J and 8 S 7/2 → 6 P J transitions of Gd 3+ in the GPS matrix, which suggests that there is energy transfer from Gd 3+ to Tb 3+ ion. The VUV region of excitation spectra of Ce 3+ or Tb 3+ doped YPS and GPS is attributed to host absorption with same maximum around 175 nm. It indicated that energy is transferred from the hosts to luminescent ions under VUV excitation. And the efficiency of energy transfer is different in two matrices. As shown in Figs. 2 and 3 , the GPS matrix can convert more UV radiation into visible light. It better satisfies the performance requirements of plasma displays and mercury-free fluorescent lamps phosphors than YPS. The excitation spectra and emission spectra of YPS: Ce 3+ 0.5%Tb 3+ 1% are shown in Fig. 4 . The excitation spectrum monitored the 543 nm emission of Tb 3+ show 4f 8 –4f 7 5d transition band at 228 nm from Tb 3+ ion and other weak bands from Ce 3+ ion, indicating that energy transfer from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ ions occurs. The energy transfer can be also proved by the emission spectrum with excitation of Ce 3+ band ( λ ex = 340 nm), the absorption of 340 nm light promotes the Ce 3+ ions to the excited states from the ground states. The energy is then transferred to the Tb 3+ ions. As a result, the emission of Tb 3+ is also observed in the emission spectrum. The excitation spectrum monitored by the 404 nm emission of Ce 3+ is similar to one of Ce 3+ singly doped YPS sample, consisting of host absorption and the excitation bands of Ce 3+ ions. With excitation of Tb 3+ band ( λ ex = 228 nm), the emission spectrum presents only characterization of the Tb 3+ emissions. All the experiment results indicate the absence of back energy transfer from Tb 3+ to Ce 3+ ion. Fig. 5 represents the excitation spectrum and the emission spectra of GPS: Ce 3+ 0.5%Tb 3+ 1%. Compared with the Tb 3+ singly doped samples, the excitation spectrum of Ce 3+ –Tb 3+ codoped sample monitored at 543 nm consists of four parts: the band of host absorption at higher energy; the bands with peak at 228 nm which is assigned to the transitions from the 7 F 6 ground state of Tb 3+ (4f 8 ) to the excited states of the 4f 7 5d configuration; the peaks at about 273 nm which correspond to the 8 S 7/2 → 6 I J transitions of Gd 3+ ion, suggesting that there is energy transfer from Gd 3+ to Tb 3+ ion; the excitation bands of Ce 3+ ion from 280 nm to 350 nm, showing energy transfer from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ ion upon excitation on the 5d states of Ce 3+ ion. Upon excitation on the 5d state of Ce 3+ at 304 nm and excitation on 6 I J state of Gd 3+ at 273 nm, the emission spectrum presents 5 D 4 → 7 F J transition of Tb 3+ ion and 5d → 4f transition of Ce 3+ ion, the 5 D 3 → 7 F J emission of Tb 3+ ion superimposes the intensive broad bands of Ce 3+ ion. It suggests that energy transfer from both Ce 3+ and Gd 3+ ion to Tb 3+ ion occurs. Upon excitation on the 4f 7 5d state of Tb 3+ at 228 nm, the emission spectrum should only consist of 5 D 3,4 → 7 F J emission of Tb 3+ ion, however, a weak broad band of Ce 3+ emission which superimposes the 5 D 3 → 7 F J emission of Tb 3+ ion is observed. Upon excitation at 228 nm, Ce 3+ ion is unable to be excited directly, it is assumedly due to the fact that Ce 3+ ion is excited by the energy transferred from the excited Tb 3+ ion. The energy transfer from Tb 3+ to Ce 3+ ion in GPS is further confirmed from the excitation spectrum of the sample monitored 404 nm, as shown in Fig. 6 . Compared with the excitation spectrum of Ce 3+ singly doped sample, the 4f 8 → 4f 7 5d transition of Tb 3+ ion was obviously observed. However, the Ce 3+ emission is not found in the emission spectra of Ce 3+ –Tb 3+ codoped YPS sample ( Fig. 4 ), showing that the Tb 3+ → Ce 3+ energy transfer do not occur, in spite of YPS samples have same crystal structure as GPS samples. The Tb 3+ → Ce 3+ energy transfer have not been observed in Ce 3+ –Tb 3+ dual ions activated Lu 2 Si 2 O 7 powders [9] . Obviously, the sensitization of Ce 3+ ion by Tb 3+ ion is not applicable for all hosts, thus it is clear that Tb 3+ → Ce 3+ energy transfer has to occur via Gd 3+ ion as a bridge in GPS samples, the role of Gd 3+ is substantial, the ion has a half-filled 4f shell which gives suitable excited states 8 I for energy transfer from Tb 3+ ion to Ce 3+ ion. While Y 3+ or Lu 3+ ion have a full-filled outermost shell, it need very high energy to be excited, the Y 3+ or Lu 3+ ion would not act as energy transmitter. It should be noted that the Ce 3+ emission is dominant in the emission spectra of Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ codoped pyrosilicates upon excitation on the 5d state of Ce 3+ . On the other words, in the two hosts Ce 3+ –Tb 3+ energy transfer occurs but is inefficient for the indicated concentrations. The Ce 3+ emission in two matrices have their emission maximum at 406 nm and the first excitation maximum at 350 nm, so that the Stokes shift is small (∼4750 cm −1 ). It results in the fact that the Ce 3+ –Ce 3+ transfer is more efficient than the Ce 3+ –Tb 3+ transfer under UV excitation [14] . Another point to be noted is that efficiency of energy transfer not only depends on sensitized ion but also on host matrix. Compared emission spectrum of YPS: Ce 3+ 0.5%Tb 3+ 1% ( Fig. 4 ) and that of GPS: Ce 3+ 0.5%Tb 3+ 1% ( Fig. 5 ) upon excitation on the 5d state of Ce 3+ , the intensity ratios of Tb 3+ and Ce 3+ emissions is greater in GPS matrix. The exchange of Y 3+ by Gd 3+ enhances the emission intensity of Tb 3+ ion; this indicates that energy transfer is more effectively in GPS matrix. And the use of Gd 3+ host lattices makes it possible to convert more UV radiation into visible light. It is useful from the application point of view. The reason for more efficiently energy transfer is that there are two ways of energy transfer from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ ion in GPS matrix. In the first process energy is directly transferred from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ ion. The Gd 3+ ions involve in another transfer process [15] . The Ce 3+ excitation energy is transferred to Gd 3+ ions in GPS matrix. Subsequently, the energy migrates over the Gd 3+ sublattice. It is trapped by the emitting Tb 3+ ions. Schematic energy level diagram showing luminescence mechanism in the Ce 3+ –Tb 3+ codoped GPS powders is presented in Fig. 7 . Main radiative transitions of Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ ion are designated with downward arrows. The 5d level of Ce 3+ lies near the excited 5 D 3 levels of the Tb 3+ in Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ codoped GPS sample. When the 5d energy level of Ce 3+ is excited with UV light at 304 nm, part of the energy relaxes to the 2 F J states by radiative transition and shows broad emission band at 404 nm. On the other hand, part of the energy in the 5d energy level of Ce 3+ is transferred to the 5 D 3 state of Tb 3+ and then partially relaxes rapidly to its 5 D 4 state, resulting in the luminescence behavior of Tb 3+ due to 5 D 3 → 7 F J and 5 D 4 → 7 F J emissions. The pumping light at 273 nm excites the electrons to the 6 I states of Gd 3+ ion which can transfer its energy to Ce 3+ ion, the excited Ce 3+ ion consecutively decays to the ground levels of the f shell emitting a broad band at 400 nm. Part of the energy is also transferred to Tb 3+ and followed by an irradiation behavior. Upon excitation on the 4f 7 5d state of Tb 3+ at 228 nm, the excited Tb 3+ nonradiatively decays to the lower levels 5 D 3 and 5 D 4 . Transitions from these excited levels to the 7 F J levels lead to the blue and green emissions. Due to the interaction between Gd 3+ and Tb 3+ ion, a part of excitation energy of Tb 3+ ion can be transferred to Gd 3+ ion, resulting in the excitation of the 6 I state Gd 3+ ion. Subsequently the excitation energy of Gd 3+ ion in the 6 I state is transferred to the ground state of Ce 3+ ion, The Ce 3+ ion is excited to the 5d state, and then the emission of Ce 3+ is observed. 4 Conclusions The phenomenon of the energy transfer between Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ ion is investigated in Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ co-doped Ln 2 Si 2 O 7 (Ln = Y, Gd) samples prepared by sol–gel method. In GPS:Ce 3+ , Tb 3+ codoped systems energy can transfer mutually between Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ , while in YPS host the energy transfer only progresses one way from Ce 3+ to Tb 3+ ion. It was demonstrated that the Tb 3+ excitation energy could be transferred to Ce 3+ ion via Gd 3+ ion as a bridge. The crucial role of energy transfer from Tb 3+ to Ce 3+ ion in GPS host is Gd 3+ ion, which provides suitable excited state for interacting with neighboring Ce 3+ and Tb 3+ ion. The GPS host would be a better choice than YPS from the application point of view, and it can convert more VUV and UV radiation into visible light. Acknowledgement This work was supported by National Nature Science Foundation of China (10774140, 11074245, and 11011120083), Knowledge Innovation Project of The Chinese Academy of Sciences (KJCX2-YW-M11), and Special Foundation for Talents of Anhui Province, China (2007Z021). References [1] P. Dorenbos C.W.E. van Eijk A.J.J. Bos C.L. Melcher J. Phys. Condens. Matter 6 1994 4167 4180 [2] C. Shi Z. Han S. Huang G. Zhang G. Zimmerer J. Beker M. Kamada L. Lu W.M. Yen J Elect Spectrosc Related Phenomena 101–103 1999 633 635 [3] V.A. Pustovarov B.V. Shulgin S.A. Smirnov E.I. Zinin Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 405 1998 396 399 [4] L. Pidol A. Kahn-Harari B. Viana B. Ferrand P. Dorenbos J.T.M. de Haas C.W.E. van Eijk E. Virey J. Phys. Condens. Matter 15 2003 2091 2102 [5] S. Kawamura J.H. Kaneko M. Higuchi T. Yamaguchi J. Haruna Y. Yagi K. Susa F. Fujita A. Homma S. Nishiyama K. Kurashige H. Ishibashi M. Furusaka IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. 54 4 2007 1383 1386 [6] H. Feng D. Ding H. Li S. Lu S. Pan X Chen Guohao Ren J. Alloys Compd. 489 2010 645 649 [7] J. Sokolnicki M. Guzik Optic Mater 31 2009 826 830 [8] J. Sokolnicki J. Phys. Condens. Matter 22 2010 275301 [9] Y. Li B. You W. Zhang M. Yin J. Rare Earths 26 2008 455 458 [10] B. Wang L. Sun H. Ju Solid State Commun. 150 2010 1460 1462 [11] S. Mukherjee V. Sudarsan R.K. Vatsa A.K. Tyagi J. Lumin. 129 2009 69 72 [12] Heesun Yang Yong-Seog Kim J. Lumin. 128 2008 1570 1576 [13] Z. Zhang Y. Wang J. Zhang Mater Lett 62 2008 846 848 [14] G. Blasse B.C. Grabmaier Luminescent Materials 1994 Springer Verlag Berlin [15] C.K. Lin M. Yu M.L. Pang J. Lin Optic. Mater. 28 2006 913 918