Discussion on the Proficient Study Model and the Comprehensive Study Model of Liberal Education
Xu-xiang LIU,Xiao-rong MA
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-0717.2016.06.009
2016-01-01
Abstract:Proficient study model and comprehensive study model have differences in the approaches to mastery of knowledge. The ancient liberal education advocates helping people become more cultivated as liberal men through reading classical originals. It emphasizes the method of reading classical great books of philosophy and literature in ancient Greek and Latin, and this is the proficient study. However, modern liberal education thinks all kinds of knowledge have the value of liberal education, claiming that the content of education should not be restricted to literature, history and philosophy. Therefore, the aim of liberal education is achieved through the curriculum system in which arts and sciences are both included. This is the comprehensive study. GAN Yang, a philosopher, holds the view of returning to ancient liberal education when he takes the liberal education reform in Zhongshan University, which is a proficient study model. QIAN Zhi-rong, a physicist, thinks liberal education should be more close to modern life when the liberal education reform are carried out in National Chengchi University, which is a comprehensive study model. Two models take different approaches. One lies in proficiency, and the other lies in comprehensive mastery. But what they have in common is that they both emphasize “general”. Whether proficient study mode or comprehensive study mode, their common ideal is that their ideal and method of education is back to the original idea of “liberal education”, that is, education aims to get people to develop freely. So, the knowledge to be taught should become students’ free knowledge and individual knowledge, and reasonably construct the knowledge structure.