Abstract:AbstractThe distinction of systemic linguistics and generative linguistics has led to more problems for systemicists than for generativists: Halliday’s theory has been widely applied but has not been adequately valued as an influential strand of functional grammars in discussions on functionalism and formalism in linguistics; Halliday recognizes Chomsky’s theoretical importance but fails to get Chomsky to respond to his questioning. By focusing on the complementarity and reconcilability of functionalist and formalist approaches to language, this paper discusses the common concerns and dialogues along with discursive differences and rhetorical conflicts between Halliday and Chomsky, and proposes that what stands between them is a difference of discourses of argumentation rather than an opposition of functionalism and formalism. It suggests a few things that at least some systemic linguists need to do in order to further interact with generative linguists who may not be interested in the systemic enterprise. It concludes that since Halliday’s social semiotic theory aims at everyday problems of living and learning, it should not be difficult for systemic linguists to solve the problem of communicating with Chomsky and his followers.

Systemic-functional Linguists on Transdisciplinarity

The Appliability of Systemic Functional Linguistics and Its Role in Discipline Integration

Translinguistics and Systemic Functional Linguistics: Compatible or Discrete

Interviewing Professor M.A.K. Halliday by Hu Zhuanglin and Zhu Yongsheng

The Methodology of Systemic Functional Linguistics

Systemic Functional Linguistics and Eco-Discourse Analysis

New Developments of Systemic Functional Linguistics: Dimensions and Directions

Systemic-Functional Linguistics and Discourse Analysis

On Linguistic Philosophy of Mikhail Bakhtin and Hallidayan Systemic Functional Linguistics

Integration in Systemic Functional Linguistics Studies

Teaching and Research of Systemic Functional Linguistics in a Regional Context

The Interaction and Rhetorical Conflict Between Systemic Linguistics and Generative Linguistics

Stylistic View of Discourse Analysis from the Perspective of Systemic-Functional Grammar

General Survey of the Achievements Made by the Application of Functional Linguistics to Language Teaching

Discourse Analysis Within the Framework of Systemic Functional Linguistics

Reflections on Systemic Functional Linguistics

Systemic Functional Linguistics as a General Linguistics Theory

Metadiscourse and Language Functions

A Personal Interpretation of the Interview Between Halliday and Hu & Zhu

Multimodal Discourse Analysis and Systemic Functional Linguistics

Criticism of linguistics discourse analysis methodology