Comparison of Time-SLIP, CE-MRA and DSA in Estimation of Carotid Plaque Stenosis
Dong-xiao ZHOU,Yu WANG,Jie CHEN,Bing-cang HUANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.19627/j.cnki.cn31-1700/th.2017.04.005
2017-01-01
Abstract:Purpose:To evaluate the imaging quality of Time-SLIP angiography and evaluate the differences between Time-SLIP,CE-MRA,and DSA in the assessment of carotid artery stenosis.Methods:Thirty-five patients with carotid plaques were scaned with magnetic resonance with Time-SLIP and CE-MRA sequences,10 of them were also undergone with carotid DSA.After the carotid artery images of the Time-SLIP and the CE-MRA were obtained,the image quality and the pollution situation of each group were evaluated by two senior doctors respectively.The number of vessels displayed by Time-SLIP,CE-MRA was evaluated.Stenosis ratio of 10 cases of carotid artery was calculated by NASCET method.Results:The cases with image quality more than 3 points were accounted for 94.2％ and 97.1％ of Time-SLIP group and CE-MRA group,respectively;and the cases with tissue pollution score of less than or equal to 1,were accounted for 88.6％,82.9％,respectively.There were 210 vessels on both sides.Time-SLIP and CE-MRA showed 199/210 and 202/210 arteries on both sides of the carotid arteries,internal carotid artery and external carotid arteries,respectively.The coincidence rates were 94.8％ and 96.2％.And the consistency of the two diagnostic doctors was higher,the Kappa values were more than 0.80,the difference between the two methods was not with statistical significant (P＞ 0.05).Ten patients was diagnosed by DSA which was used as golden standard.For the Time-SLIP,the sensitivity was 92.31％,the specificity was 97.87％,the accuracy was 96.67％,Kappa =0.90;and for the CE-MRA,the sensitivity wasl00％,the specificity was97.87％,the accuracy was 98.33％,Kappa =0.95.Conclusion:Time-SLIP is a kind of non-invasive MRA imaging technique without using contrast agent,and the imaging quality is excellent,which is suitable for primary examination.Time-SLIP can be used effectively for diagnosis of carotid artery stenosis.Because the Time-SLIP technique does not rely on the contrast agent injection to display the degree of luminal stenosis,so it has a higher clinical application prospects.